Alex: Welcome everybody to the open internet pod live on X every Thursday, 12 p.m. UTC. And again, as a video on demand and podcast every Sunday, 12 p.m. UTC in your favorite app. Today, we wanted to talk about a topic that we touched upon earlier. in the context of ancientification, enclosure, which is the corporatnet, like big corpora, right? We, without realizing it, we ended up in a situation where most of the internet is owned or surveilled by corporations and that's how they make their money. And I thought that, you know, it's one thing for us to talk about it in a way that is very technical and we can like dissect things and tell you. Exactly the mathematical equation that results in the result that we have today Or we could just try and do it in a bit more of a human way like take real examples discuss them and show how they A lot of things that you experience today either on the internet or in real life Can be tracked back to some form of an gentrification that has happened along the way. So with that said I think we should start with a bit of a bit of a how should I put it like collateral and certification, which is Richard: Ha. Alex: coming from Norway. Apparently, Norwegians may be subject to EU regulations allowing the scanning of private messages, photos and files. And I think this is like a perfect way to start the discussion because it shows that Even if you yourself might not be the one doing the incertification, you can get incertified by osmosis by literally being close enough to the EU that you get the stink on you. Richard: Yeah, well I mean this is we were just talking pre-show about how all the development frameworks out there were built by the big tech companies and that means that, you know, everyone who starts building software starts using software the way they want. And this is exactly the same kind of thing, but it's the legal version, right? Like you live too close to the EU and so even though you haven't signed up for these things, all of the companies you operate with their systems you know, have to follow EU law, so they basically just, you know, want to continue those over onto the, you know, things that serve you in in a in a place like Norway's case, you know, there's a good chance that they're part of some, you know, greater scandy region or northern Europe or something. And so they're like put in the same data centers as as the Danes or the Germans and you know, those guys are going to implement EU rules. So you get you do get this creep and it's actually one of the things that kinda do on purpose too. I think if you look closely at a lot of the regulation out there, the big tech firms push for these sometimes broader than you'd expect them to rules. And I what the reason for it is is that they're actually wanting to get the same thing everywhere to make their lives easier. Or they've snuck something into the system that they want to deploy everywhere because in this case, like, well, we have to scan your phone means you know, they also happen to be able to, you know get other information out of there, you know, one way or another. So whatever it is, how often a can of Coke appears in your family photographs, right? They can also drag that out if they want to, because they're scanning your phone. Alex: Right, it's something that you, I think you mentioned something in a previous episode where you said that once the law gets passed, companies will create the same code for all regions, all jurisdictions, all countries, right? So then the actual capacity is already built into the app. You're just waiting for the law so that you can turn it on. It's no longer something that you have to build. It's there latently, right? Richard: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And there's a bunch of reasons this is bad, right? One is the code is lurking there, even if it's technically turned off in your region, ready to be used. if it accidentally gets used somewhere, right, then the kind of p that'll argue, well, you know, don't fine us as many million dollars because, you know, we didn't mean it. We were just like we processed the Norwegian data the same way we do the German data. Oops, sorry. Et cetera. So you you end up with a bunch of reasons that this you know i is negative and it it's mostly just around once you've got the tool lurking there, it's very easy for its use to begin even if it's not supposed to be being used. So at some point that it gets turned on and that doesn't get flagged or whatever, and so now it's now it's part of the pie everywhere. Alex: Right. And to maybe also point out some of the things that we can do on a personal level. You know, there's there's there's not that much that you can do. So a lot of times you hear these things and like, but I'm just a normal person. Like, what can I do? Like, I need to use my phone. I need to I have to send messages. So that is correct. But you should also know that there is a growing number of people and you have this movement. It starts maybe with framework and then maybe it starts with the know with the steam deck and then it starts with the you know make your own phone and all these trends are sorry Richard: those neckbeard guys down at the Linux user group, there's people, right? The C C C guys, the KOS, computer club guys. yeah, who have been on about this stuff for a long time and there's a growing number of people, organizations kind of popping up everywhere who are who are who are pushing on these things. Alex: Yeah, so what the message I was trying to say is that, you know, help is on the way. Don't despair. We're all working on it. Sado is working on it, doing their part. The Linux guys are doing their part. The phone manufacturers, the new guys are also doing their part. there is a... How should I put it? It's one of these things that it's in the air. Like you can feel the wave coming. So, you know, we're not just saying this to like scare people. We also want to let you know that we are working on it and not just us. That's cool. Do you want to talk a bit about this live facial recognition technology in Australia or? Richard: Yeah, I mean, just just quickly, I think it's it's again the sort of thing that we're seeing happening generally. what's super interesting about this is in the show notes if you go one of the links is to the West Australian police's own web page about what they're doing with this broad facial recognition software. So what it is is it's not the sa it's not the face unlock level facial recognition, which is is this face, this other face matching That way. So I you know R U U. this is just point it at a crowd of people and see if any of the faces in that crowd match any that you're looking for. One of the first things to come up about this, and one of the things that isn't talked about on the WA police's website, at least as far as I can see, is the fact that this was trained in presumably North America. I'm guessing it could have been China. but lighter skinned faces it's more accurate because it was trained on that right it it's Alex: Hmm. Richard: you know the machine's not racist but it just was trained that way so guess what more false positives on darker skinned people right now like I think the world tends to splinter on politics so just take it out of that just if you're in group B this thing is way more likely to hit you than group A which is ridiculous right And the fact that it's gone out that way just shows you that like I think there's always a sense of the police are doing a thing. So they've they might they're part of the government. So they've done a proper job and they've looked it up and there was a commission and then they had a tender process and then and this software therefore must be good. And so actually no. Right. Like actually this went live with very, very well known bugs. Like it's know, whatever it is, think it's something like ten times as likely to accidentally say that, you know, spot you in a crowd against some mugshot. You know, and again, you know, people are thinking, they've got this great perfect mugshot of the person's face. Like this the shot they could have could have been from someone in a passing car or something, right? And they're using this to match up to to look for people. So the chance that you're gonna have a couple of police come up and pull you away out of some random crowd in in Western Australia is much higher if you're a member of certain groups of people. So like to me it's like if there's flaws like that, why do we why do we think this is the system's a good idea? Like in what in what world is this helpful? So I think this is, yeah, this is just another thing that has me feeling like we really seem to be losing sight of a lot of things w that the societies we we live in were built around. Alex: Yeah, and I think that we are as part of shift from being public first and then maybe private later. We're moving more into world where due to the prevalence of technology at a lower and lower cost, right outside of RAM memory, you end up in a situation where it becomes incredibly easy to just have constant surveillance, right? So people's priority will shift. You will no longer be so willing to share gazillion pictures online because why would you do that? You're gonna end up trading some AI. You're gonna end up maybe having your identity stolen. mean, there's so many negatives Richard: Yeah. Alex: now to being part of that trend. You know, there was a time when the Internet was peer to peer and then it was equal, right? It was it was a network of peers. That's how I like to describe it. And now with this whole platform user frame, right, where you have the big platform and you have the user and you have like a 200 page terms of agreement that you have to click. Yes, otherwise you can go in. You know, there's a saying the house always wins. Right. And there's, there's a, if you feel like it's harder and harder to earn money or start a business or pay for the tools that you use, it's not, you're not crazy. It's, is like that because the whole idea is to create monopolies. Everybody wants to have their own monopolies. That's why we call it the corporal net because what used to be an internet of peers now is a corpo net of the big guys, big corpo and all the plebs. And that sort of frame has to change. We cannot be part of it anymore. And it's becoming more more real, right? You have stuff like, for example, mid 2018, net neutrality got repelled, right? This means that ISPs can make Netflix go faster and Amazon Prime go slower because they have a deal with Netflix. And then you think like, my God, look, I only pay $20 for my Netflix plus internet. But you don't realize like behind the scenes, probably that ISP and Netflix got together on the deal, both get a discount and you're just paying, it doesn't matter because If the cost of the subscription is $20, the real cost of the service is somewhere between 50 cents and a dollar, tops. So they Richard: Yeah. Yeah. Alex: can give you 20 % discount, they're still making bank. And I think that, Richard: Yep. Well it's it Alex: you know. Richard: yeah, it goes deeper than this because like part of what's driven the ability of the internet to do what it does is that for a long time the you companies that built the infrastructure or paid for building the infrastructure on the for the best part just knew they could sell more if there was more of it. Right. If everyone has, you know, a broadband at home, then they'll be able to use Amazon more or Google more. So at Google and Amazon We're happy to be part of building international cables and general infrastructure and stuff like that. What's happening now with this with this shift is if they're allowed to shape the traffic, it's like letting them build the roads so that you know like letting Audi build the roads so that only Audi's cars can can drive on them, right? So suddenly instead of wanting more capacity and better service for everyone. They're actually now it's flipped. Now they're like, Well, we don't want you to go and discover other streaming services. So it's better if there's a limited amount of bandwidth, because we're getting preference on that. So our service works. We'd really rather not that somebody else can come and stream to you. And so it it it it circles in on itself. It gets worse and worse. Alex: Yeah, and like the latest thing that I thought about as I was listening to you, I think a lot about the next generation of gaming consoles and the fact that PlayStation 6 is supposed to be somewhere around a thousand dollars, which is obviously no longer that price where people can buy it for their kids as an impulse or like a Christmas present. And there are talks that the next step would be to have a PlayStation that is only a portal and you stream the games to your portal because the hardware is so expensive. So in order for the prices to go down, don't even not only will you not own your games, you won't even own the hardware. So you just Richard: Right. Alex: stream the actual game to a portal and then they can get the cost down to like 300 bucks or 200 bucks or something. And it's this continuous, continuous cannibalization of the, mean, like degradation of the service of ownership, Richard: Mm. Alex: you end up, classic quote, you will own nothing and be happy. Richard: Yeah, well I think I mean it's it's the classic system again. the Sony have no desire for you to have gotten a good deal on your hardware. Right? If they could get the thousand dollars out of you in subscriptions, they'd rather that than actually have to do the work of building the expensive PlayStation compete in the market, find RAM somewhere, you know, and and put this thing together. So From their perspective, yeah, that just just render portal, you know, is just a it's just a customer acquisition thing. It may have in some cases a a side benefit of like letting a few people who can't afford a console, you know, shifting where the market is. So some people can come in. but that that's not that's not the reason that they're interested in it. They're interested in shifting it to a place where they can then, you know, get that recurring revenue, which is just you know, jumper juice to any corporate kind of finance team. But on top of that, they can then say, well, like where obviously when you had the PlayStation three or four or whatever in your house, Sony was in a weird relationship with you where they like they want you to buy a new one, but they don't want you to just go away and say, well screw this. And so they have to try and keep a set of games working on the one console and then they'll do some shenanigans like start making games that are not Really playable on the old console and trying to push you. Whereas with with a subscription model where you're on your portal, right, what are they going to do? They'll just tell you, it's five bucks a month more because it's more expensive now, but you're you're getting upgraded to PlayStation NF or 36 or whatever they decide to call it, and that's you have no choice, right? And none of your games work if you stop paying, etc. etc. So you're gonna fork out the extra, the extra five dollars. Alex: Yeah, it's I mean, you can you can see you can see this on the horizon, right? Like they announced that they will stop physical games in by twenty twenty eight, which is literally killing the secondhand market. Right. That's an justification right there. Like you're killing the secondhand market because you want people to use your storefront. But once there's only one storefront, I mean, what can happen? I mean, it's like. Obviously, you're not going to get any sort of sale or you're to get one is like 10 Richard: Yeah. Alex: % sale on Christmas, right? Because they don't need to take down the prices. And the next step from that is like, you can't afford that. Great. Here you can't afford a thousand dollar console where you buy licenses for 80 bucks or 100 bucks. If it's GTA six. Great. You can buy this little portal for for 200 or $300 and you get a subscription and that's like $20, $30, whatever. And at that point, you have literally zero comeback, right? There's nothing you can do. It's like the moment you stop paying, you lose access to everything. And that is not really customer friendly, but it is the continuation of this model, this business model. This is how it dies, basically. I hope. Richard: It's it's one of the last well, we hope it's the last it's one of the last. It's certainly the most recent step I think we've seen in this in this process, right? And it's you know, like I I I kind of feel hopeful in some ways because we saw, you know, the kind of apogee of mall culture somewhere in the early two thousands, I think, in the US, right? And now we see empty malls. People have changed a lot about how they want to do those things. And I feel The mall is in a lot of ways a great analogy for this, where it's like, you know, the corpo space, right? You're in a corporate space where i everything is curated according to their desire. Someone designs the hallways and the patterns to get you to spend more. You know, they think through things like having food there so you never leave. and the corporate net is is similar. It has a lot of delicious in it. not necessarily healthy delicious, but it has a lot of things to keep you there. But it's It's all designed around keeping you on it and all designed around extracting as much from you as it can while you're there. That's its purpose. Alex: I would say that the internet today resembles more and more a casino. It has no windows, you get Richard: Yeah. Alex: free drinks, get discounts on some packages, but the whole point is to keep you there. The more time you spend there, for example, you could be using your imagination to build things. You could be using your imagination to have fun with your friends. But what platforms like, you know, even this platform or Instagram they're doing, they're monetizing your imagination. Your Richard: Yeah. Right. Alex: creativity, your imagination becomes, you know, a line on their bottom line. And whatever Richard: Yeah, it's Alex: you get back, you get back like crumbs, which Richard: Yeah. Alex: is really good for something like Sado because, know, surprise, surprise. Your margin is our opportunity. And we were talking a bit about this before we started the live show that even something like Steam, which is the holy grail of doing monopoly, right? Richard: Yeah. Alex: You can still, they still take a cut. They still take 30%. Richard: Yeah. Alex: Right. And then imagine a world where you have something like Steam where you don't need to make an account. You just, you don't even realize you're walking into the network and then you find the game. And guess what? The game is not the same price as on Steam because there is no Steam cut and you only pay for the network use and instead of being 30 % more expensive, it's 0.01 % more expensive because that's the only cost you have. Richard: Yeah. Yeah, no, I mean it's super interesting because I like I like that casino analogy a lot because I mean I think we all feel it, right? The casino knows that they'll get money out of you because they have this thing that you'll keep coming back for, right? They're they're trying to hook you in and we all know that sense. And some of us get hooked in, some of us don't. But the free drinks are there so that you stay close to the ATM so that you can, you know, come back to the back wrap table with another couple of hundred bucks or whatever it is. That I think is really true. The big difference is that the casino's much more open and understood what what that trade is really. They try and hide it, but it i it's really obvious. Whereas the second point that you just made i like is really the big difference to me is that what's happening now on the internet is that thing that we want is being farmed from us ourselves. So they're finding people's creativity, like you say. But it's not rewarding them in some kind of r any realistic proportion. but it's also being pushed through a mechanism that makes it you know, the short reels, those sorts of things, right? It's been pushed through the mechanism that's trying to make it that, you know, addictive dopamine repeat that that we all want when we get stuck on these things, right? And so it's a double it's a double whammy. It's not just the casino, it's that the other people around there are the are the thing that, you know, is being farmed to to make to keep you to stay. Alex: That's such a great point because imagine if Coca-Cola would force a can of Coke down your throat every minute. That's what's happening with reels. You don't realize it, but they're giving you this little dopamine dopamine dopamine hits. And because it's not something that you can see or like, my God, I'm not thirsty anymore. my God, I'm getting sick. There's too much sugar, I'm fibrillating, my heart is palpitating. You don't feel that, Richard: That Alex: but you walk away from it and literally you don't know what you've done the last 30 minutes or 45 minutes. You just had this like moment in time where you just like disappeared from the world. Richard: Hm. Yeah, I mean well, that's that's that's where the casino analogy comes back into being really great, right? The no windows, no clocks, no it's designed to be that little box that doesn't have those things, you know. it would be really interesting to see what would happen and if you had a little thing that just stopped you watching them for ten seconds the first time and twenty five seconds the next time and if you know Alex: You know, they actually have that by accident. They have now on the Instagram, they force you to watch ads. So they stop the Richard: Right. Alex: scroll for an ad, which is perfect because then it like, kind of like snaps you out of it. And then you just like Richard: Yeah. Alex: close the app and you get out. But that's, they're probably going to remove that because it's just. Richard: Yeah. Well or they'll they'll work out like what they'll do is my guess is if that's an issue, they'll do product placement into into content, right? They'll for they'll use some of those creators out there just to to to push the ads for people so that it's it it's coming at you that way. Right. Yeah, yeah. Alex: I mean, that's the holy grail, isn't it? The combination of advertising and entertainment. That's why you have so much success with these content creators. But it's really crazy because I think if you would take, know, and this is ancientification, if you take the most successful content creators on YouTube, which, you know, in my opinion, they're like they're being picked. so that you have this like carrot on the stick so everybody aims for that, right? They need a few examples of success stories. But if I would take someone like MKBHD or Dave2D or LinusTechTips, which are like really big, they make a lot of money. And if I would tell them how much money they could really be making if they were on an open network, Richard: Mm. Alex: I think they would get depressed. I mean, they all make a lot of money as it is, but they don't understand how much money Google takes out of Richard: Yeah. Yeah. I think the there is a bit of a devil's agreement in there, in that part of the difference is that like the big platforms want to have fewer, bigger people, partially because this equation works better in their favor, but also they're less likely, you know, the more stars you have in your stable, the more likely there's going to be a scandal involving one of them or a problem or whatever. So you want to have like concentration because it's just easier to manage and and do it costs you less. so there might be, I mean, I think on one side we if you had you know more of this content being created on open platforms and stuff, we'd have a much richer garden with far fewer superstars, right? I think we've seen that change and and happen with things like going from album and and then cassette culture and so forth to downloads right now. Now we've got a lot of people who put their music out through digital channels and they have enough of a following to keep doing exactly what they like, but you know, they're not ever going to be a Michael Jackson or a you know Bruce Springsteen or something. They're going to they're gonna, you know, stay niche, but you know, they're getting a living out of that. So I think that will change, but but that's a separate part of the o argument. I think that's also, you know, positive. What we're talking about here is, yeah, I think if you look at it, I was reading an article recently, I think I mentioned it. few episodes ago on private equity moving into and buying these channels. Right. so when you see that you're starting to realize okay, there's certainly nothing organic about this anymore when that's happened. You know, they might be watching for the people popping up organically and and and getting into the biz, but what they're doing is, you know, they're right they they're going up to these larger following groups, buying them out, offering them a a large payout, and then some kind of Exit plan, right? So some kind of, you know, you get 20 million bucks or whatever, and then you have to stick around for this much time. This much of the content has to be featuring you, but they very deliberately have a thing where they start introducing co-hosts and sub, you know, substreams and stuff like that. And you know, it's it's it's become a playbook. and the thing is, we kind of all know the delivery mechanisms change, but if you kind of you know look at network T V. I mean, who does these days because of this stuff? And like where radio got to eventually where it was just completely dull because it was, you know, prepackaged formats and prepackaged ideas, et cetera, just being churned out of factories. Alex: Yeah, and you know, because we talk about what is the corporate, right? I think that if we would take the level of surveillance and fingerprinting Richard: Yeah. Alex: that is happening online and would bring it back into the physical world, I think I think people would just never leave their house. I think they'd just be like, I'm not leaving my house because the moment you go, let's say you go shopping. And there's like 20 people looking over your shoulder. What did you buy? What did you put back? How long did you look at that can? Did you read Richard: Mm. Alex: the back of the can? Did you read the front of the can? which Richard: Yeah. Alex: aisle did you walk on first? Which? Richard: Yeah. Alex: Why did you change your mind at this aisle? you interacted with the the meat section. Are you vegetarian? Richard: Mm. Alex: Are you a carnivore? Like that's every little thing that you do on the Internet is completely under surveillance. Richard: Well, I think the thing to think about as well is sometimes people are like, well, you know, they could see me at the supermarket or I used to go to a corner store and the guy used to know my brand of cigarettes or whatever. Yeah, it's not so bad. A couple of things to think about while this is happening. You gotta imagine that the people who are getting this information are then yelling like old New York stock exchange style, like anyone interested in someone in you know needs adult diapers, is anyone interested in someone who you know, they're trying to vend that information as far fast as they can. They're also the people who can shape, you know, like inception style, they can shape the shop you're walking through as you walk through it. So they're then using this information to try and guide you towards their goals, right? Which might feel good sometimes. well who guess what? Something popped up that I really needed. You know, isn't that nice? But it's also the thing they chose out of the set. that could have popped up. You know, it's it's the one that they felt was most profitable to them, which includes the possibility at times to be like, we know people love this brand, but we don't have a great deal with them. So screw that. I mean that happened it with I think it was Africola or something. There was like a Coca-Cola competitor in South Africa and it was laughed at and pilloried for a while. Got quite popular and then eventually Coke came in and said to every corner store in like the country You can't stock our stuff, which included candy bars and all sorts of stuff, if you stock them, right? Squish. And Alex: Yeah, yeah. Richard: that that these are the people you're dealing with when they're when they're surveilling you, that they're they're prepared to do that kind of thing to like make sure they get the maximum out of your time. Alex: Yeah, and then let's say that you come back to the store the next day or the next week. They pretty much know, you know, to continue that knowledge, they pretty much know what it is that you want to buy. Right. So not only can they like shape your experience, but then they know that you kind of really need to buy this specific oil every time. So maybe let's just like take the price up a little bit, because this one Richard: Yeah. Alex: is a must have for you. Right. So let's just like lift that up and find your pain point. What's your pain point, Richard? You know, like at what point Richard: Yeah. Yeah. Alex: will you stop buying it? And then I can select, you know, Alex is only willing to pay $20 for oil. Richard is willing to pay $25 for oil. Guess what? Next time you go in the store, I get it for 20 bucks. You get it for 25 bucks. and, and so Richard: Yep. There's there's there's that and sorry, go ahead. I've got a Alex: Can you imagine as we're moving towards a digital world, can you imagine this thing being more more prevalent? It is like coming into your physical world because the more time you spend in this corponet, the more you will be subjected to these methods, which is why the open internet is so important, which is why open source is so important. Just to get back. the same sort of autonomy that you're used to having in the physical world, in the real world today. Richard: Yeah. Yeah, and I think this is also like that whole description there was based on it working, right? Error free in essence, right? So they've identified you and it. So I had a classic example the other day where we were thinking of a birthday present for a friend's infant. Like, get him a swimsuit, like baby that age, great fun going swimming with your kid for the first time. my wife happened to have been looking a at them on the phone. She suggests to me, What about this idea, mate? Good idea. Go back to what I was doing. I was looking for something like hardware, computer hardware wise on AliExpress. Suddenly I get that ad. Right? Now this is inside we've all seen this. Like we've all had it with the trips to wherever or whatever. But this was this was a leak. I hadn't searched for anything like that. And I'm running Linux, etc. I'm pretty sure I wasn't recorded. I'm guessing because my stuff is fairly tight. They identified the house or the IP address or something. And so they just they just assumed that it was the same person looking and they hit me with this ad. What if you're in an apartment building that has one IP address and you suddenly, you know, you someone in in the building works out, you're going away. Right? Or you're getting a divorce or whatever, because of the same kind of leak, right? And it puts you at some disadvantage, either embarrassing or actually dangerous. because you had nothing to say about this, but you've got this data leak going across because of the mass surveillance and the attempt to use it. Right. And it wasn't anything that you did and it wasn't the intended purpose of the system, but it accidentally it happened to dox you on something you really didn't want people to know. Alex: Information is power and the more information you give away, the more of your power you give away. I think that, you know, it's, it's, that's, I don't know if I can put it in more simple terms, because you want to share your information with people that you trust. You don't want to share your information with everybody. Like I, my doctor should know about my health problems, not 20 different ad agencies that are surveilling me all the time. So, you know, this, this idea of instantification and enclosure and the corporal net, you know, they're, all literally tied together in this business model that is continuously extracting. So. I don't know. It's, it kind of also destroys society in my opinion, because it, it, it reduces the trust level in a society because. Like, I don't know, I don't know. Let's say we moved this into the physical world. I don't know if the guy in the store is trying to help me or if he has some deal on some specific items and he wants to sell them to me, which is, Richard: Right. Alex: you can find that today without doing any of the internet stuff. But imagine it being everywhere, at every corner, right? It's not like Richard: Mm. Alex: I walk into a store and I know this guy is going to try to upsell me. It's like I walk down the street and everybody's trying to. sell me Richard: Mm-hmm. Alex: which is you know why would I leave my house I come back to say yeah I will not leave my house anymore Richard: Yep. Yeah, well they're all they're all yelling at each other too. Alex is coming, try and sell him a bigger popcorn, right? Yeah. Alex: Yeah, Yeah, yeah. And it's, you know, and then you also have, you know, because I talk about is like breakdown of society as a result of an education, you know, you have people moving to back into villages, because they don't like their work because their work has become, you know, devoid of meaning, because everything has been optimized to the nth degree, right. And And as a human, you have to behave more and more like a machine in order to have a job. have some friends who work in advertising and there's a lot of criticism in advertising today because people complain that it's not creative anymore. And they say like, we are still creative. It's just that all the clients are data driven. So they don't want to test anything anymore. They just look at the data. And that's how Richard: Right. Yeah. Alex: you get like this wall of bland. You get a wall of bland in advertising. All the ads look the same. It's some, some silly, stupid thing that makes no sense. But the data says that that's how you should do it. So. Richard: You see, y yeah I mean you see you see waves of that in sport too. All all the coaches, you know, the money ball comes along and then everybody does it and suddenly every team looks identical and then it takes some maverick who's gonna be like, I don't care, I'm gonna just hire on feel and you go through cycles because yeah, it it fails after a while. Alex: No, I agree. But I think the difference here is that it's one thing that you see a trend in a specific area. And it's another thing when you see this trend in everything, like all aspects of your life, from medical care to school to education to entertainment is becoming part of this trend. So it's not like ancient education and enclosure is restricted to the internet. Here we notice it because we work in this domain. But the ramification, because I think it's the business model. I genuinely think that this is a result of the business model because you always have to provide shareholder value. Everything is driven by the stock exchange. You to hit your targets. we are, how should I put it? The real economy, which would mean building things is becoming less and less important. And the financialized speculative economy is booming. I don't know, to Richard: Yeah. Alex: me, we're like, I don't know. I don't know what I wanted Richard: No, no. Alex: to say with that, but it's just like. Richard: I I think well I think it's it's that combination of things, right? So you you're absolutely right. Pi it's it's data driven decisions being made by focus groups and committees in rooms looking at optimization questions, right? which just doesn't get you anything vibrant, et cetera. And the issue is that people people sort of tend to think, well no, but there'll be another Steve Jobs with another iPhone or whatever. It's like Well, there there will be. There will be disruptive cool things happening. It's not like that's not gonna happen at all. But the default mode for corporations, logically, it's the logical thing to do is to try and move toward monopoly and then to essentially insidify. It's just a it's it's not something that happened because someone invented some craven way of running a company. It actually makes sense, right? That's what you want to do. you want to take over a market and if you could with airlines or with anything else, you'd suddenly see like, you know, real deterioration because of the lack of competition. but companies would prefer to work that way. So it's not like it's not surprising. Alex: I have a test for you if you want to do it like anyone watching I suggest this very simple test. Go to your favorite convenience store. Let's say go to the soap and shampoo section and use your wide lens on your phone and take a camera. Take a picture of the entire shelf. Then take that picture and ask your AI agent whichever one you use. How many companies own all these brands? And you're going to have like 30, 40, 50 brands. And I'll tell you, it's like one or two companies own all the brands. It's the illusion of choice. Richard: It was it it was a shocking moment for me as I think a thirteen or fourteen year old when my father came back from a business trip as an industrial chemist and he'd been working for a client of the organization he worked for on soap powders, on on washing detergents. And my dad's thing was stuff like powders and how do you make them flow a nicely out of a box or down a conveyor belt as whatever. Like how do you make foam? So he'd been there and They were wanting to make like the stuff flow out of the boxes, but they also wanted to mix like bigger pink granules with little blue ones, but not have the pink ones all fall down the bottom of the box. They had those kinds of problems. And he worked, you know, for up to wherever the factory was once a week for, you know, for the weekdays for a few months. And one day I asked him like what he was doing, what it was all about. And he's saying, it's all the same stuff. They're putting exactly the same soap in nine or ten kinds of boxes and right at the supermarket, you say all of that from the super fancy one down to the it's all the same stuff. Maybe there's an advantage if it it it is easier to get this one out of the box than that one. But these ones with the funny blue bits and these ones with the with the like super shimmer or whatever. It's like occasionally there's a little bit of an extra thing in there to make the stuff glow in the dark so it looks wider. But it's all the same soap. And you know, that's That's just there to to maximize. And in fact, what that's there to do is just for every price point there's something where you can give more money to that company, basically. Alex: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I they want to hit every price point on the way, right? So it's like, how much money can you pull out of your pocket? I'm selling the exact same product. just add a bit of bedazzle here and there. And, Richard: Yeah. Alex: you know, that's, but, but, but it's true. And I think that, you know, there's the saying, on, on, online that if it's free, then you're the product. I would also say that if it's convenient, then you're also the product. If it's. If it's sold in a big chain of convenience stores, guess what? You're the product. So I think that we kind of have to like shift. We won't be by our own volition, our own will. It's going to be a shift induced by the fact that it's just getting so bad. But, you know, be more local. Be more, you know, go to your local butcher. you know, find that crazy lady who does their own shampoo and creams and buy from her instead. Obviously, it's going to be a lot more expensive. But guess what? That is the actual cost of things. Right. Like when you buy from the insured fires from Big Corpo, what you're buying is a product that keeps its price because they keep reducing the cost of it. And that's insuredification as well. The fact that you go on YouTube and they kind of figure out how many seconds of an ad they have to show you before you have to skip or before you bounce. All these little things that they do in the real world in corporations has taken over the internet. The internet went from being a peer of networks to being like two or three big corporations trying to increase their margins. And that is the corpo net. Richard: Yeah, I think we were saying right at the start, there are people who are trying to build things, Fediverse, you know, what we're doing at Sido and connecting with what Alex was saying, we're building this so that you have ways of connecting with people and actually being able to take the time to find out what they're doing for for people to be able to share things and not have the algorithm whisk them away out of people's view. you know, there's a there's a real understanding amongst anyone, try to set up a creator type account on any of the big platforms that you you kind of live in fear of these ghostly figures that wander the the algorithm de you know you know depromoting you you know demoting you down lists and so forth and Alex: Shadow banning. Richard: shadow banning all sorts of things but but usually you know it's just understood, I can't put a link in this thing because they w you know the company's worried that the users will then link away. Right. And so you can't, you know Do that and people just immediately kind of these days we're so used to that stuff that people just internalize, okay, can't do that. Gotta like, I'll put it in a follow up post or whatever. And then of course the algorithm starts penalising that too, because they still don't want you to do that. And and people are losing sight of the fact that like, you know, it's actually possible to be free of those things. and there are people like us at SIDO who are trying to build systems where you can have a thing like a blog or share content or rent content online and stuff and it's and it's again it's just a deal between the two people involved. It could be a totally free sharing or it could be a business you're building. but you're not you know, there there is no intermediary trying to fiddle with that to maximize their own profit out of the exchange. Alex: we are removing the third wheel, right? We're removing the third party, the go in between layer. Richard: Yep. And that can be someone who doesn't want you to talk to the people. It could be censorship. It could be someone who's just thinks it's more profitable for them if you talk to someone other than the person you want to talk to or happen to be talking to. All of those third wheels, those intermediaries are gone. it does require that you then actually, you know, start acting because that, you know, dopamine feed that's sort of straight down your throat intubated down your throat is is gone. but it gives you ability to actually form real relationships, discover things that genuinely delightful and all of that sort of stuff. Alex: And more importantly, it's a lot cheaper, a lot, Richard: Yes. Alex: a lot cheaper, like order of magnitude cheaper. All those margins that they're growing, taking money out of their pocket and giving you a worse product. We're saying that margin is our opportunity. We're going to take those margins to the actual network cost of the service being provided because the network only needs to pay for itself. It doesn't need to provide shareholder value. Richard: Yeah, I mean I've been saying bang on for ages about like opt-in advertising and open internet and how cool that is. And I think that's something, you know, that's really important for people to like maybe get a sense of is yeah, it it really is an absolute ripoff, aside from how annoying the ads are or whatever, the you know, someone got paid Alex: but they're data-driven. Richard: Someone got paid three dollars or something like that for you clicking on the thing that that you followed or for sitting that long through the ad. They got the three dollars. You got maybe a tenth of a cent worth of of their energy and time to actually bring the webpage to you. You paid for the wires to their data center. You know, you paid your ISP. They literally paid, you know, half a penny to generate the webpage you were seeing it on, but got paid three dollars to do it and you were the what was sold in the process. Alex: The reason why Alphabet, Google, YouTube, Spotify, Netflix have such high valuation is because they're selling something that costs from a cent to almost zero for 20, 30 dollars a month. And once we break that idea that it has to cost that much, their whole house of cards just collapses. Right? So the moment you can walk into a free network and you don't even notice it, you don't have to create an account, you don't have to download a wallet, you just walk in and all of a sudden your identity is your own. Your products that you bought. Well, you know, if you bought it, it says that you bought it. If you license it, it says that you licensed it. If you rent it, it says that you rented it. It's not buy and then under the buy is like, in fact, it says It's a license, but I put a sticker on top of it and call it by because there is no law that forces me to say that I'm actually provided with a license. Richard: Well, s rec recent case, forget what it was, yeah. Sell it as one and then turn it into the other on people and wait for them to s yeah, to ch come and yell at you. Alex: Studio canal couldn't couldn't agree with terms with Sony. So now 550 movies that are published by Studio canal disappeared from the Sony movie store and all the people that bought those movies the movies disappeared from their library. That's that's the platform. That's the platform user relationship. Right. Richard: That's fine. That's it's fine. Yeah. Alex: And something like that cannot happen on the open Internet because they don't have the right to do that to the customer anymore. Richard: Well they don't have it's not engineered that way. They don't have their fingers all the way into the hard drive on your machine that's storing the movie. They just don't. And so your your world is your own and you know, the the the methods of transferring the thing to you mean that it's yours, genuinely. Alex: time flies when you're having fun and I think I've had lots of fun this hour with you Richard. What is the the best Richard: Yep. Despite the despite the negative to topic, it has been really interesting to talk about, really fun to cover. Alex: I don't see it as a negative topic per se because we are talking about it and we are bringing it to people's attention so that you understand that exactly. Richard: Yeah. The the darker aspects of the co of the topic, but yeah. Alex: No, no, no, I agree with you. But I think that to talk about it in a way that highlights it without being doom and gloom by saying that, you know, there are people working on solutions to solve these and Richard: Yep. Yep. Alex: these solutions are closer than you think and they're coming. So you know, hanging there and Richard, I'll let you close the episode with what is the, let's say, what is the optimistic outcome that you see coming in the next few years, considering all this ancient education enclosure and the corpo net. Richard: it's it's the revolution is coming, Alex. I think all of those the the the people in the you know that everyone imagines as hood you know, hoodie wearing hackers in dark rooms and all of the privacy wonks and the my software is free people. they've been fighting the good fight and I think the discussion today shows why more and more people are interested in what's been going on in that space and why things like Linux and Firefox a are are are seeing a an uptick in use. you know, graphene OS, free phones, open phones, that sort of thing. I think to me that increase in awareness is the key thing. It's why we do the pod, right? It's it's about, you know, getting the message out in a way that helps people connect the importance of the things that motivate the people who've been ri working really hard on this stuff. I'm one of those people I know plenty more dedicated to it and really feel it. And I think one of the things that's sometimes hard to come ac you know, hard to get across from that that position is why it matters, why you care so much, why other people should care. And so it's good to take the opportunity to go through these very real, very, you know, i lived experience examples and say to people, here's here's a few dots. Let's help you, let's let's connect them together, together and then we'll we'll we'll kind of show you from there. why this stuff matters maybe more than you'd thought previously. and that, you know, sadly is partially 'cause the walls are closing in. But I think the the flip side of that is that, you know, we're actually seeing people really start to to to care. And that's causing more and more pressure on a bunch of levels, more usage of of open tools and open software, more pressure on legislators, more people thinking about where they're spending their money and and and what the results of that are and and to me that's all positive. Alex: I agree completely. So on that positive note we're closing another episode Richard: Yeah. Alex: of the open internet pod again please share this with your friends family anyone who may have lost hope about the internet yeah so thank you so much for joining us and we'll catch you guys next week have a great week