Replayables 31 PT: You got fired, so you drowned your sorrows in booze. She had to get a part-time job working a grocery store cash register. Only reason she could earn a wage at all is the manager liked how she looked in a skirt. Welcome back, everybody, to a new episode of the Mini Playables. And this is a special. We're recording this a week ahead, so everybody knows this will be going up as close to Halloween as possible. I am joined by The two individuals that don't have a mini presence here when we podcast, Tony and George, welcome back. It's great to be here, I guess. I'm more excited. I'm ready. We are doing not a full game, not an accessory. It is a demo. We are doing PT, the demo of a potential Silent Hill game/slash property from 2014. George. Get us started. at this time, did you hear about PT when it first came out? What's funnier to see about this is that we've all come at this experience from a different angle, right? This comes out and immediately there's a buzz. It's scary, it's trending. everyone wants to play it. But then, you know, within a couple of days, there's a falling out and the demo gets yanked off the marketplace. So I had tagged it as saying, I'd like to play this, but my I think my hard drive was full. So I dilly-dallied for a day. I I don't know what to delete. I'll think about it tomorrow. And then it was gone. So I never got to get my hands on it, but I watched everyone I followed on YouTube and Twitch play it. So I c I experienced it vicariously. But man, yeah, what an experience. Yeah. for me, I obviously heard about this demo when it first came out. I'm a film nerd, so I was so interested to hear about Guillermo del Toro moving. And this is shortly after P. Pan's Labyrinth. This is maybe a few years after that. So he's really in the hearts and minds of people. And all of a sudden he's getting involved with Kojima to make a video game. And this demo had come out. And people are so scared of this thing. And then all of a sudden in three days, it's gone. And I gotta tell you that I never played it until they came out with the Unreal Engine of it. So as a spoiler alert for this, spoiler caveat, whatever. I have never played the original PT. So any feedback I give about the game is only related to. To the new Unreal Engine created one. I obviously watched let's plays of it a decade ago, but I can't speak to that as well. Tony, did you hear about this game when it first came out? What did you heard about it? And I'm assuming you've also only played it in the Unreal Engine. I have never heard of this game. I heard about it, or game or playable trailer. I heard about it about two weeks ago from this podcast. So that's where it came from for me. I of course found the Unreal Engine version or the Windows version and was able to play it doing th through my PC to try it out. so that's about as far as I knew this thing that you were so obsessed with was all I knew was like, I gotta try this. Apparently it's amazing. Yes. And if anyone's ever listened to a Metal Gear Solid podcast, they are a Metal Gear Solid podcast. They know that Tony pronounces his name Kojim So that's why we bring Tony out into balance us so we don't gush too much. The gush George, before we hop into the game, can you talk a little bit about some of the like how the idea of this game being a demo and also some of the stuff that was happening at the time with like PS4 selling for for crazy amounts of money and stuff? Yeah. So I'm kind of glad I didn't get it on my hard drive because I would have been absolutely tempted to sell my PS4. PS4s. I don't know, what were they s they were four or five hundred dollars? maybe f I'm gonna guess five hundred dollars at the time. I think they were they're always around five hundred when a console comes up. If you had PT loaded on the hard drive, you could sell your PS four for anywhere from eight hundred to maybe fifteen hundred dollars on eBay. That's insane. Eventually eBay started taking the listings down. It it I think they said it it violated their terms of use and policy because you were selling a software that maybe you weren't supposed to have anymore. 'Cause it which that's a whole nother issue Don't get started on that. But yeah, it it was crazy how it's this spread like wildfire. But then Kojima has this falling out with Konami, and all of a sudden it's gone. this is one of my primary reasons why I think we need physical media. Granted, this was a demo, which was never going to make it to physical media. But to think that you could have something so important to the zeitgeist just flash away is nuts. So this is around the time, this is twenty fourteen. So Reddit is really coming into its prominence as like the hub of the internet at this time. So this thing comes out and it's like the first thing that I remember ever exploding on in like video game Reddit world. And everybody's trying to share this thing and everybody's trying to find a copy of it. And everybody's like, How do we emulate it? We can't. It's too early. Like the the the technology, all that stuff. So it's such a crazy time. And then to never for to never have access to it for so many years because you couldn't emulate it software wise until this thing got bigger. I think the only thing that is interesting to me about this is that this might be the scariest game I ever played, first time I ever played it, and it's a demo. Yeah. They put so much work into a game that maybe just you know it's as long as Yoshi's story, but it's twice as scary. Tony, have you ever experienced this for? A dem or just something that blew your mind and you you I don't know. I don't even know how to ask the question, but Let's not go with the words blew my mind so much as Yeah, it was creepy and it was the the weird like the fact that you I was playing it, so just from my perspective, I wake up in a dark room, I'm like, this is a little bit eerie. Like something gonna jump out, like 'cause everyone said it's a scary game. Okay, all right. So anytime I go into a corner that's dark or I turn a corner, I'm just waiting for a jump scare because I'm I'm assuming that's what they're gonna do. Because that's how games get you with scary things, because otherwise it's like, that's just a funny looking character and they're acting weird. I'm not afraid of them because I'm not in that place, but this is a jump scare, it it makes you jump. It gets it gets you on that instant in your face kind of action. So I was ready for those, waiting for them, and they just weren't happening. But then the weird, creepy, eerie things that were happening, I like, All right, this is getting a little bit kinda odd and like it's growing a little bit of tension here and there. And when I finally leave the first room and I walk through it, I'm like, I'm back here again. Okay, so it's a loop. I'm trapped in a loop. Yeah. my God. I was never gonna end. I rewatched my stream today and I'm like, I'm so confused when I walk back through that door the first time. I'm like, huh, what is going on here? And then I walked back through it again and I'm like, okay, this is a thing, I guess. I immediately tur tried to turn around and go back. I'm like, well, I'm gonna see if this is loop is infinite. I'm like, no, I can't go backwards. The loop is what makes it so great because It just layers on the creep as you progress. And then things start to not change. You're like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. You're like more scared because something's not happening. And then you just have to explore creepy bathrooms and look up at creepy second floors. And you're like, Of course then all falls apart when you're stuck in that room and you have to look for like four little pieces of paper. And that w that didn't hit. I know. And and it's a playable teaser. So if there's any gripes about this game with the puzzle solving or whatever, this is a demo. This is the most rough draft of a rough draft. But that being said, the amount of care I felt like was put into this game, it's only three to four kind of physical spaces, right? You have the bathroom, you have one hallway, you have two hallways, and then you've got that kind of center hub area where by the end of the game, like that refrigerator is just going back and forth. But similar to a movie set. Every corner has something. There's some set design everywhere. So you walk down that hallway and to your right is furniture and a clock. You go down left and all of a sudden there's pill boxes and there's pictures and there's a telephone. And this whole thing is sprawled out with what doesn't feel like like it actually feels thawed out. So, George, how did you feel like that small space was used? Did you ever feel claustrophobic? Or did you ever feel like it was it was like a a good use? Because you mentioned the loop is is what really makes it, right? Yeah, I I I love the idea of it. I'm actually glad this didn't become a game. I don't know if the game could live up to a full experience of what you felt in this demo. We'll never know. But that little tidbit of there's the one hour of you just get to explore every nook and cranny, it's per it's perfect as is for what it is, right? Again, I very happy this didn't become a full game because I feel like we all would have played it and went, well man, that demo was so much better. The demo is great because despite the annoying puzzles and some of the stuff that's in it, it's such a short, compact experience. Tony, did you hearing about this game in the two weeks that you had leading up to it about how scary it was and the hype kind of offset the eventual like you just knew what you were going into, right? Like you weren't. I kinda did that expecting. I was like, I'm expecting it to scare me and stuff. And there's the one room I think I came around. I'm like, all right, this is like my third or fourth loop where something changed. And I turned the corner and I'm like, something's gonna jump out of me. And I turn the corner and there's this tall, creepy standing lady there. And I'm like, Yes. All right, well, clearly she's gonna jump, scare me, or grab me. I'm like it I was just waiting for it. I'm like, Come on, do something come on, it's gonna happen. It's gonna happen. Then all the lights turn on like now it's really gonna happen. Now it's really gonna happen. And I'm like, Nothing's happening. So it's just like Okay, I guess I need to go forward to make it happen. And finally I go forward and the lights come on and she's gone. I'm like, okay, she's somewhere. This isn't great. I know this is coming. So it was that like the they it did do a good job of building that tension and things. I have my c other complaints, but it the I saw a clip or not a clip, but a a tidbit about the game and it was like it doesn't use dream logic, it uses nightmare logic. is the best way to describe it. It's just pure unadulterated nightmares and you can't get any kind of logic behind what you're doing. Okay. I need to ask you one more question, Tony, before before we hand it off to George. Mm-hmm. When did you first meet Turkey Baby? And what did you think of Turkey Baby? So I wish I had recorded my my play session just because I remember s that happening when I hear the baby crying, I look into the room and somehow I activate the loop to end and I get to the next loop and then the door opens and I'm like, I'm not going in there because there's just a flashlight blinking on the ground and it's real dark. I'm like, something is gonna jump out and grab me. I think the the crazy I'd seen the crazy lady by then or I maybe I hadn't. I was like something is gonna jump out and get me. I know it. I can just tell I'm like I'm not going in there and I'd walk around I'm like, this is the only place I can go. I have to go in there, I guess. All right, here comes the jump scare. No, it didn't happen. So the fact that like I kept anticipating a jump scare and it didn't happen was kind of weird and building tension. So then I had my flashlight and I'm looking around and I look down I'm like, so there's a fetus baby in the sink. All right. That explains the crying. I was like, he's crying. I was like, it's a bathroom. Cool. And fetus baby in the sink. Okay. Yep. I was like taken aback by that. George, when you first met Turkey Baby, how was how was that? Were you guys were you guys fast friends? man. I I'm watching I don't remember who I was watching at the time play it, but just there like visceral, just like it just that's exactly what I felt. That's scut. This is why I don't really play horror games. I know. Now, the first thing I thought about when I saw Turkey Baby is wow, it's gross. The second thing I thought of when he starts talking to me, I'm like, the voice acting is good. Yeah. And I'm like, and you know what? A lot of the production value in this game is better than a real game gets. You were listening to the radio a lot in the beginning, and it's really good voice acting. It's like Really, it's almost like Alan Wake ish in terms of the radio broadcast you're getting. And then the voice acting is good. And, you know, and I don't think any of that changed for the Unreal Engine. I think they basically just upped the graphics and the sound design. But Tony, were you impressed with some of the production values for a demo? I was gonna say that the it was kind of crazy how much effort went into a demo like this for what it does. the I have some complaints about the lack of instruction in certain spots where I was just I did certain things and I don't know how I did them. Yep. the big one was the gouge it out. the eye in the picture? Yeah. Had no idea how I did it. I was just like, hold the controller and I looked at it and then I pressed some buttons and all of a sudden it was like it gouged it and the door opened. I was like, what did I do? Do I have to press like six different buttons to do this? Like I have no idea. And I remember in the menu it said something about make sure you test your microphone. so I'm gonna have to say things. So at one point the radio was telling that same story about the the murders and things and I get trapped in a loop and the door the bathroom door won't open. I'm like, that's right. The daughter hid in the bathroom and the dad said, It's just a game and she came out. So I must have to do that because I watched someone shut the door. So I'm walking around the game screaming at the doors, it's just a game, like an idiot, going, There's gotta be a reason that I had to use my microphone and this must be it. And they didn't do squat. So you turn this into a semen from Dreamcast where you're just using your little microphone to give instructions. It's C Man. C Man. George, is there anything else about this game that I mean you still stands out to you or moments that really got you? Because for me it's the fridge. The fridge is one of God. Probably a negative that stands out to me is I I repeat it again, that that when you have to find the different pieces of notes everywhere. Anytime I've seen someone play this game, it's just it everything grinds to a halt. And y you gotta you gotta bring that up. It's like okay. This was a demo of things they shouldn't be put in the final prep. Absolutely. The game has no UI, right? The game really doesn't have and again we're talking about well, there's a pause screen, I think. What? I think there's a pause screen. That's it. There is. But nothing like when you walk up to something, it doesn't just say like, yeah, hit X or do something. Later in the game, the polished version, would have given you direction, but I'm assuming they had a deadline for this thing and they had to send it out. And it's like, okay, they just gotta find the notes, but they can't complain because it's free. I didn't learn to interact with something by zooming in with the R stick until the fourth loop. Yeah. And you keep talking about having to find the card, the the paces of a picture, George. I found a bunch of them just playing, but I never picked them up. I never had to use I never had to solve that puzzle. Somehow I skipped that one entirely. That's so strange. I never finished that and I never finished a couple of the other ones. I also think this is this is a great lead in to now the the partnership that Kojima and Guillermo del Toro have, right? This was the proof of concept, which I'm sure was why Destrandon got picked up right away. The amount of perfect timing cohesion that has to happen, where Kojima and Guillermo do Toro somehow come together, talk about doing this project, get funding for this demo before Kojima has his falling out with his previous company. And then this demo is really great. But what makes the demo so great is that it's so hard to play for so many years. And it's like all these perfect things had to happen. For this to become the most infamous video game ever, that's not a full game, right? There's never been anything as infamous as this as a separate property, as an accessory or anything outside of a full studio game. So I just think it's it's it's amazing. And if someone has not played PT that is here and you have a computer good enough that can play the fan made version, and obviously now with AI, we've got a fan made version of everything or merges or everything happening. But this is a really nice one. Tony, would you recommend this game? we normally don't do this on mini playables, but is this game replayable? I would say it's it's not really replayable for me. once you beat it, you beat it. you can try to go back and see if you can see some of the other loops. I never saw the crazy thing in the second floor. I only ever saw the fridge and the crying baby in the fridge. And every time I saw it, I was like, that's gonna fall on me. That's my first thought. I'm like, they're gonna crush me to death. I've been eaten by the crazy lady once or twice by then. So I was playing and I like picked my phone up to look at something, and all of a sudden the screen jumps because she attacks me and I'm like, Okay, I'm getting eaten now. Cool. but no, I would say once you play it one time, I wouldn't give it a a second play or anything. I you could try a couple of the loops and and kinda get it. There's a couple of things that was like I Don't know how I finished the room. I accidentally did the right thing. So I couldn't even say, yeah, this was cool way that this puzzle solved or something. Some of them were very simple and some of them were just super convoluted. And I went back and looked at how to do some of the loops online. I was like, I definitely didn't do that or realize that I did that. But okay, I somehow the door opens, I'll go through it. Yeah. George, instead of asking you if this is replayable, do you think I know you mentioned before that you're happy this didn't become the full game. But do you think the full game they could have lived up to this, this how close could they have gotten to the quality of this demo? Cause it's such a vibey game. It's such a spooky, you know, it's building that tension. For an hour, it's building tension. Tony's looking for jump scares. He's not getting them. He's getting vibes. You can't vibe out like a 10 hour game, right? I'll give you two answers. If you look based on what they've done since. Death Stranding is a game where there's interesting stuff going on, but the gameplay in between, some people find boring, some people find relaxing, but it's definitely drawn out, right? That wouldn't have boded well for a horror package. But then you look at, he's working on a horror game right now. So if that game hits, maybe I'm wrong and the full game could limit the potential. Or maybe they needed more bites at the apple, I'm not sure. Either way, the way things have played out, this is probably the best case for Kojima. For him if he was gonna you don't fall out with a big company like that out of nowhere. So if he was already experiencing problems, for him to go out at that time and for this to get that for the PT to get so much notoriety, really couldn't have been better for him. There this could not have been a better Kojima's this person that the lore of him, he's this rock star figure, and th this is this couldn't have been a more perfect way for him to go out with Konami was his trailer. So to to help me not dislike this any further in an alternate universe, PT doesn't end Kojima's relationship with Konami and he they do make a Silent Hill. And I don't know enough about the Silent I didn't even know this was a Silent Hill game. When you kept talking about PT, I didn't realize it was a playable trailer for Silent Hill that was going to come out. I had no idea. So it wasn't until the very end I was like, by the way, this is Silent Hill. And I was like, wait, that's the guy from Death Stranding. Right. And it's like, now I understand why he's in Death Stranding. It's like 'cause this relationship had already been built and it just went somewhere else. So in this alternate reality, what do you see as the game? You've played the demo. So the demo, say, is w level one of the game. You get the you get out of the demo area and you get into the streets. What's next? if you know anything about the Silent Hill franchise or anything, pitch me your what's what's after this? Or we just do this loop forever, or it's a new loop in in the streets. Because at the end of the game, you can with the demo, you can walk the street and I at that time I was so annoyed with how slow you walk, I like, I can't stay in this game anymore and I I turned it off. But if you can walk the streets and and explore a little bit, what do you see as the next thing? Do you go into other houses? Do you now in a different loop out in the street and you have to stop? Like what what's your pitch for the next level or rooms or things like that? I I think it's like what you described, and that's kind of similar to Silent Hill one, where there was a town. And there are things to do from place to place and a little bit of solving puzzles and gameplay, but the the real guts of the game are in a school, in a hospital. Yes. So probably there's tent poles where, one is nightmare turkey fetus refrigerator house. And then, you know. What does that go for on Zillow? God. And and another one is, you know. Clowns with pickles coming out of its ears. I don't know what he's gonna do. So each one would probably be its own little experiences. The is the idea I would think you would draw out from this. Also it's it's a s I agree with George. I think it would be like a set based thing or a set pieces where similar to Silent Hill one, you've got the town, but most of the houses are locked, most of the streets are rolled up, and then you it really takes place in the hospital, the church, the the big locations, right? But this this didn't have big locations. It's one location. Well, that's just under the consuming. But the other thing that strikes me about it is that I've never played a Silent Hill game that wasn't in the third person perspective. This is the first game in a first person perspective that would have been a Silent Hill game. So I don't know how much more that means there's less combat, there's less fighting, and it's more just exploratory. And so again, I have no clue where that game goes because I don't know how that game evolved. Yeah, it was and I don't know if it was in first person just because of the limitations or if they were gonna stick with that format the whole way. I think it was supposed to be a break from what they were doing because you know, Silent Hill Downpour, Silent Hill Homecoming, and I can't remember the one after that. F things were starting to no, it was this was pre F. So things were starting to really go downhill and people were upset that it was becoming more action oriented. So this was then the knee-jerk reaction to say, okay, you don't want action? no action. You don't want Silent Hill to turn into Resident Evil kind of thing. Yeah. Right. Instead you get Feetus in the Sink. Yeah. Yes. Classic Feet a Sink. Tony, that is a great question. Because I had thought about what the with like the ambiance or what how the game feels if it was blown out. I never thought about where you go next. I never thought about what would fill that because Maybe do you ever pick up a gun? Does it become a first person shooter? I doubt it. I doubt it, right? I really don't think you do. I think maybe at best you get you get a you have a flashlight, maybe you get a a phone or something that you can make calls that flesh out your story. My thought was may maybe you get like a nightstick or something to protect yourself once in a while, but like nothing aggressive, nothing to fight back with, just things to defend and get away. Because you can't run in the demo. There's only one p one room where you can actually run and you're drugged up anyway, so it's hard to see what you're doing. I I was curious if it was gonna be like that loop was gonna start and it was gonna get longer and longer. So then they would add rooms onto the loop, or you would then be going into another area and we you get into a door at the end and it brings you through. And if you're doing it right, you keep staying in that area. But if you're doing it wrong, it takes you back to the first loop. Or you have to go back through the first loop and it And maybe it ends up being a long sequence of loops that tie all together into one long string that you have to learn your way through. Yeah. I can see different ideas, but I never played Silent Hill and I don't know the franchise or the or anything well about it. I've seen like one movie years ago and I heard it wasn't I I heard it was not true to those the games and it was very bad. It had like the big guy with the the pyramid head in it. Yes. And that's about pyramid head. But Yeah, I I wonder if this would have been a shorter game. I wonder if this would have been a a a two, three, four hour game similar to some of the other survival horror things and it would have been 'cause if you're gonna build this quality, this is an hour demo and you're gonna build this quality out through four or five hours. It's not possible to go if Guillermo del Toro could make a twelve hour movie that was that good, he would have made one, not in a video game. You know? It's like you know This feels like a a twelve hour game for your first time playing it and a two hour game once you know the ticks and trips. of where to go and and how to do it correctly and how to beat it faster. Because I saw I did look a little bit on PT later and was like, here's how to play the game. If you play it normal and you don't know what you're doing, it's gonna take about this long. But once it then it was like, here's how I played it and I got it done in like twenty five minutes. And then people are trying to speed run it by doing things correctly and jumping loops so they can break the sequence and get the to the end faster. So it's like you can find ways around some of the default puzzles. So you do it slow way where you just Fumbling your way through. It's a longer game. And it it builds that that story. I think that would have been an interesting. It becomes less of a survival horror and more of a puzzle horror. Trying to figure out the logic of who was thinking this is a good way to open a room by looking through a peephole. Agreed. George, anything else on your part on PT before we wrap up here? No. I think we No, but we talked about the the the the craze of trying to buy it. We talked about legacy kind of. We've talked about playing it. Yeah. It i if any of this seems interesting to you and you like being scared, go play it. And if you don't like being scared, continue to listen to people talking about it. Because even watching people play it is scary. Yes. And if you want to do an hour stream, go find a let's play of someone doing it. There you go. hopefully retropolitan gamer. And it's a really fun game, but the one thing I recommend is just really focus on it. Don't treat it as a second screen. If you're really interested, it'll take you less than an hour. And it's really fun. and obviously we didn't do this as a replayables because the biggest what's age the worst in history on the replayables is that this game isn't finished, right? It's like the biggest what's age the worst ever. It's not a finished game. It's just like this little playable teaser that, you know, they probably got out on a deadline and they were like, no one's gonna play this. Like, who cares where the photographs are? Who cares how we blow the guy's eye out? it's like we'll fix it later. And then this thing blows up and it's incredible. So thank you for listening to this episode of the mini playables for George, for Tony, for Turkey Baby. I'm Retropolitan, Alex, and I'll see you guys next time. Thank you, guys. Thank you.