Replayables 28 Silent Hill: Welcome back to a very spooky edition of the Replayables podcast. I am Retropolitan Gamer, aka Alex, and I am with the one person I would trust to guide me through the fog of Silent Hill. Welcome back, George. I didn't mark my map. Okay. Well, good thing that I now have a fully built out map from playing that game, because if you did watch my stream, you know that I called that game what was it, Cartographer Simulator or something, because I'm pulling out the map every twenty six seconds. We are doing the original Silent Hill for PlayStation One, released January thirty first, nineteen ninety nine, and we're doing it just in time for Halloween. So, George, talk to me about when you first played Silent Hill. And if it wasn't at launch, had you heard rumors about this game series? I had heard about this game, but I didn't have a PlayStation one, right? I think I mentioned that before on the on a c a podcast. So a lot of times when I played these games, it was because I had a PS3 later signed for sub for PlayStation Plus and they just gave away a bunch of these classics for free. I got all the Silent Hills, I got all the Resident Evil's, other random ones I can't remember. But I didn't get to it until a lot later. So even though I had heard about the spooky atmosphere and it was a pretty good game and obviously the franchise had been going and going and going, I came at this super late. Yeah. For myself, I ended up s using my my couple of hard earned dollars that I got from Santa around Christmas and I saved up and this is a a funny story. I go to like I don't know if it was this kind of one of those tower records or something, and I go in and I buy Silent Hill on PlayStation One and I buy three CDs. I buy Jay-Z volume two. DMX's second album and WWF the Music Volume Three. Ooh. So I walk out with a big hall with my Christmas money. And it's funny because my PlayStation's in the living room with behind the computer. So my dad was always right behind me. So I couldn't play DMX or Jay Z. So it was always WWF the Music Volume Three. So I'm listening to the Broods theme while playing Silent Hill. It was very apropos. But no, I bought this game at launch, beat it at launch, really was impressed with this game. And I think I had heard about it from really good reviews. They said that this was around the time where a lot of different survival horror offshoots were coming, right? You had a dino crisis around this time and a lot of hero with tank controls against whatever monsters and you've got formula. And I loved it. So how did it feel going back to it later? Did you feel like were the graphics and everything just a a little hard on the eyes at that point? No, you know what? For PS one game. This isn't so bad. the FMVs are funny to laugh at now in retrospect. And I'll do that for all of them. Like Final Fantasy IX still just looks so cartoony chunky. Yeah. And you get that same bit with the characters in this one, right? But at the same time, and maybe I'm jumping the gun on some stuff here, at the same it's fun, like you see the end and you see like they have an outtakes one, and it's still these blocky characters like pretending to move around like real people. So it's all part of the charm. It r it really is somehow a charming game. It is. What was your experience with horror games up to that point? Were you someone who dabbled in it when you were younger? Or is this something you maybe came to later on? yeah, my mom would not let me buy horror games. That was that was not gonna happen. But as I started again, my own games as I got older, I played the first three Resident Evil. It was something I was always curious about because again, didn't have the PS1. So I went back for them. And played the GameCube version, which scared the hell out of me. Yeah, that was a good one. that's about it. Like I didn't I'm not one for pure horror. So survival horror speaks to me more. Yeah, it's funny that we differentiate that because I find pure horror a little much at times like outlast. Yeah. But then survival horror I find can be up to par with it, right? Like parts where the nemesis are is Inv you know, chasing you in Resident Evil 3. There's Person Silent Hill where survival horror can even stand up to that traditional horror. Yeah. For me, I had had a lot of experience with the Resident Evil. played Dino Crisis. My first horror game ever was Friday the 13th for the NES. yeah. And what was really scary about it was the controls and not really the game itself. Now it it scared the crap out of me when I was six or seven years old, and you walk into the cabin and Jason's there just like throwing his knives at you. but in hindsight, I realized part of that fear was that I just had no idea where I was going or what I was doing. but then, you know, you didn't have a lot of horror during the Sega Genesis Super Nintendo era. You know, we had like the original clock tower on the Super Famicom and little gems like that in the 90s, but not a lot. So this was where it was picking up for me. and yeah, I I thought it was I thought this was well, we'll get to it later, but I thought that this was such a step up in terms of horror. How did you how did you feel about like how scary Silent Hill was? It's interesting, right? It's I would say it's objectively not a scary game. Okay. It is a spooky game. It is a tense game. They really build tension. But there's it doesn't rely on jump scares for the most part. it's creepy. But I didn't go to bed at night and I have nightmares about Silent Hill, the way I might have with maybe like a dead space, if it really got me. Or those zombie dogs in Resident Evil. Good lord. You know, these dogs were not great either, but at least they didn't jump out of windows. Silent Hill was so scary to me in 1999. And I've gotta say that it actually remains just as scary to this day for me personally. Okay. I think part of that is this masterful sound design. That's gotten even better when you now play it with headphones. It's one of those games where, you know, when I was playing on my CRT screen in 99 and the sound was like, okay, I still appreciated the music, the the the sound of the radio that instills that fear in you, or a lot of the death noises. But I think a big part of it too with Silent Hill is that it goes the next level. Like Resident Evil is pretty safe in terms of there's not a lot of gruesome human deaths. If anything, it's like zombie dogs. And then in this game, like there's little kids with like, you know, trying to stab you with knives. And there's nurses who's who are getting like the the John Moxley crimson mask. Like, don't do you don't you feel like they just they take it a little level farther? The monster design is so much better. Yes. And by better I mean extreme. And in this respect, it's extreme still within you know, like they didn't overdo it. sometimes you see these monster designs in games, you're like, I don't know, man. That's just it lost all semblance of whatever it is was supposed to be. But the monsters here all make sense. You're in a hospital and there's creepy freaking nurses. You know, you're at a school and there's zombie children, like, ugh. Or not zombie, like what a ghosty, whatever, I don't know, whatever you to call Yeah. It everything was really well thought out here, which was super cool. So I felt That the Silent Hill character design is so much more original than any other survival horror game I'd come across before. Because in Resident Evil, you've got the template of the zombies. That's pretty much well packed down. You bring in the dogs, which very Wolfenstein 3D. There was a lot of a lot of ideas or you know, easiness. And then you get really cool with the nemesis later, and they get very original with that. Silent Hill had to create all these enemies from the ground up. There's no traditional zombies, vampires, any of those. Were you as impressed with me at how original the cast of characters were in Silent Hill, especially the enemies? Because I came at it so late, no. But it it's I wasn't impressed, but at the same time, it just felt right. You know, everything like I said, everything made sense within the scope of what the game's trying to do. You're in this town, and then you know, it's like, yeah, when you're outside in the fog, it's these animals. But then you go to specific places and the monsters are really specific to where you are. So it just felt felt like a really well done, well contained narrative. Everything I did screamed to me of yeah, I'm caught in this spooky town and I'm not, you know, doing ninja flips and throwing rocket launchers at Nemesis. Yeah. Did you watch the I know we both watched the movie last week, but did you watch the movie at all when it first came out or was this your first watch? I forgot this movie existed. Well, there's three Silent Hill movies now. yeah. I I'm there's gonna be a fourth, I think. I don't know. Didn't the fourth one like just come out this year? I know one came out. You use Letterboxd, which is like the movie review app. And Silent Hill one's got like three point one, and it's like considered a pretty medium movie. You'll enjoy it. And then the next two are like below a two star. It's like one point eight. And it's it's like an IGN review. It's really hard to get below a two. These movies have to be pretty bad. But what did you think of the movie? How do you think they adapted the game? And I so the movie also, you know, it takes its license and I think it needs to. You you can't I don't care what video game it is, even The Last of Us, like you can't just take that and one to one translate it to the big screen or the small screen. Yes. They're different mediums, they tell stories in different ways. So I didn't mind that they took the setting, they took the characters, and they made new protagonists that operate within that world. I think that worked really well. it didn't obviously progress in the same manner or or land in the same place. But overall, this felt like a good homage to what Silent Hill is. You could tell the director knew what he was doing as far as adapting the source material. Was it a perfect movie? No. No, it wasn't. But I had really low expectations and they were met. They were exceeded. It was really cool that this came out after Silent Hill two came out the game. Because then you get Pyramid Head in the movie, and he's the scariest motherfucker like ever in gaming for me. He is so terrifying. And I thought the movie had some charming the wheels come off the bus in the third in the third act. A little bit. But you know, this was also at a time where we were getting this huge influx of video game movies. It felt like in the 90s we wouldn't touch them. We got a Mario Bros. movie, we got a Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat did okay. And then in the two thousands we get the Assassin's Creeds, the Resident Evils, Doom, Max Payne, Silent Hill, two Final Fantasy movies. Why do you think do you think it was that computer generation was getting better and it made video game movies easier to make? Like, or do you think they're just that was the hot IP of the decade? I think it's a combination of that. That helps, right? Especially because video games have no limitations from that respect. I mean Obviously there were hardware limitations, but really your imagination could just go run wild. But also I think there was more respect for using that license. You know, you look at like the original Mario Brothers movie, you look at what else came out at that time? Well, I just left my head. But there are the Street Fighter movies I'm thinking of. They tried and they definitely looked at it and they definitely plucked things that they thought the directors thought would work for a movie, but they didn't respect the IP itself. No. And these companies didn't have as much as a hands-on approach to protecting their IP as well. So you just had these slot movies. And if it made money, it made money and that was fine. But now you get to this era of the Silent Hill movie and and everything else you just mentioned. Company's starting to realize, like, no no no. We matter. Like we're not just the obscure hobby no one wants to talk about. Like we have multi million dollar IPs that you need to actually use correctly into a movie. Yeah. It wasn't it it wasn't, you know, all the way there yet. Like you still had your terrible like other movies like anything you bull made was god awful. but nowadays a video game movie has a much better chance of being not just good but great. Yeah. I agree. The one that broke my mind that wasn't good. And I went back and I rewatched it because I love the Max Payne game. And Max Payne was the first game I ever streamed two years ago. I needed kind of a cinematic game where there was a lot of narration and talking, so I didn't have to talk the whole time, which is a far stretch from who I am as a streamer now. But Max Payne felt like that should have been the easiest adaptation to a movie that noir setting. built in like a a Teamu Sin City and it still would have worked. I was so surprised. Do you remember watching Max Payne, Assassin's Creed, any of those games that were tied to franchises you loved and did you feel like they were stabbing you a little bit sometimes? I was so burned by the first couple of video game movies I watched that I actively avoided them. And I wanted to watch Assassin's Creed and I thought about it and I was like, No, I really like this franchise. I don't want the sour taste on it. That came later. Yeah. And naturally. But I still haven't seen it to this day. And I mean, listen, you could probably twist my arm and I'll do it if we ever do a podcast on Assassin's Creed. But yeah, I it was like a thing where I you know what it was? I think I watched the second Mortal Kombat movie, and that was it. Annihilation? Yeah, that annihilated video game movies for a long time. Johnny Cage dying right off the rip. I was like, nah, I'm out. I'm done. I watched that movie. I bought that movie as a bootleg five dollar VHS on the corner of a hundred and twelfth in Broadway. And I got home and I was so mad. I was like, This movie sucks. You know, bad a movie has to be when you think when twelve year old you thinks it sucks. Like the bar for a twelve year old as a as a movie critic is pretty low. Pretty low. At that point, Angels in the Outfield's still my favorite movie. So if I think your movie sucks, this is terrible. But yeah, thank you for watching the movie for me. You don't have to watch the next two, please. I I will save you from that. you know. That that nightmare, that level of fog. All right. Let's hop into what has aged the best with Silent Hill. Why don't you get us started? 'Cause I feel like I always steal yours. Well, it it's it's the atmosphere, right? I love the foggy town where you can't you have to rely on the radio sound to let you know enemies are coming. Yes. I I can't think of another game that really nailed that, right? You know, just that literal foggy atmosphere and obscuring things just enough. I think that also t t dives into, you know, having this sort of like alternate hellscape dimension that you you go to a w a level and it transforms into maybe the same structure, but within each room everything is like totally warped and different. I don't recall having played a game like that in a you know earlier than that, or maybe not doing it the same way. I agree that the vibes in this game are p possibly top five ever in gaming. I think it is The everyone knows this if you've ever s read anything about Silent Hill, but the fog was created to mask hardware limitations. They couldn't do, they couldn't get the draw distance the way they needed to, because I think it was the first time in a survival horror game where they were making fully 3D rendered worlds. So at any point, with what's age the best, I don't even know if this is the age the best or the worst, but you can spin the camera around Harry. So in the Resident Evil games and Dino Crisis. There's a fixed camera angle in every room. And in Silent Hill, you can spin it 180, which was a revolutionary for survival horror at the time. But what that means is you're in a 3D world and they create the fog to kind of mass the hardware limitations. But man, did it work? I can't, there's no way. Like that was thought of as a hardware thing first, but when they probably were playing it, they were like, this works incredibly. The the less draw distance makes it scarier, right? I saw something, I think it was on Reddit a few years ago where someone put that game through a filter and like up the loading times and got rid of the fog. don't do it. It's so much worse. It is so much worse. Don't do it. Yeah. I mean that the yeah, you're right. That atmosphere is is immaculate. It it's amazing. And it's crazy that they level it up even more to Silent Hill too. Like you want to talk about big jumps in quality and big jumps. Like Silent Hill one is already like really, really great. And then Silent Hill 2 just like levels it up. And I can't wait to go back and replay that. And I will have to talk about that game at some point, just to talk about Pyramid Head for like an hour straight because he is such an epic villain. For myself, I steal this on every podcast I do, but I thought that this was in a a really great game for sound design. I thought that the music is great. I love that in the movie, they open the movie with the opening song of Silent Hill, and they use a lot of that. I don't know how to describe it. It almost doesn't sound like music. It just sounds like a consecutive series of noises that are really spooky. And I thought that this game was some of the best sound design on the PlayStation one. And some of the best we'd had epic soundtracks. Final Fantasy's had epic soundtracks once we got to CD. But this was one of the first times where I felt like the C D was utilized overall for sound design. Is that something that stood out to you at all? Yeah, there's a difference in the the way you write a score, you know, a lot of RPGs or even or even any video game for the NES probably, you make your beeps and boops and that's the primary feature that you're you're listening. It's like active listening almost. And in this stuff, this is more like your movie soundtrack. You're making an atmosphere. You're using sounds not to make a melody, but to create tension. And yeah, I absolutely noticed that. I also noticed in the movie they had that Silent Hill theme as it hit the credits at the end. That was good. It was. the as a horror aficionado, by the way, going back to the movie, my biggest red flag is when a horror movie is over a hundred minutes. I'm like, why like evil dead one and two, Texas Chainsaw Massacre is eighty seven minutes. How do you need two hours for a horror movie? Yeah, you don't. Yeah. Like that's normally like, you know, I'm s some of like the later Jasons get a little long, but yeah, that's just on a side note, that's like What am I what are my red flags when it comes to horror films? I'm like, Silent Hill, how are you? Two hours and ten minutes. Like I would not have noticed that. That's good. Edit, edit yourself, brother. I am gonna mention something else that's age the best, because you just mentioned it and I want to get your take on it. But that we're gonna call it the hell dimension when the alarm goes off and all of a sudden like the sidewalk rolls up and you have all those greats. Like as a as a as someone who grew up in New York City and seeing those greats, like you walk over the subway ones. That is just terrifying. It's like an industrial nightmare for me. But yeah, when you first got to that hell dimension the first time you played the game, like what were your impressions? I thought it was really a really cool idea. Like I said, I've never seen something that did it quite that way where it's really again, this is really smart. They're they're exploring what their limitations are on the hardware and how do you save space? How do you make sure the loading times are right? They took assets they already made and just threw a code of payment on it. And You know, a lot of games do that and it's lazy. This was intentional. it reminds you that you're not in Kansas anymore to pull from a different movie. so that way you know like, no, I'm in it now. Like the big monsters are coming out. And I have to be on my guard. And this this changes the gameplay accordingly. You're going for a little bit less puzzly and a little more action. Silent Hill is One of the most confident games I've ever played. And what I mean by that is you made a point where it goes for it. Silent Hill always goes for it. They never stop short for fear of failing. They never stop short for fear of something not working. Like whenever they even have a jump scare, the cat jumps out of the locker and you're like, whoa. You know, like, okay, all games have that. And the cat goes around the corner and you listen to the cat be eaten by a monster. That's what I mean when when I say that Silent Hill. follows through and goes all the way. That hell dimension could have been half assed, could have been whatever. They really invested in it. And they made it. And the hell dimension to me is what takes that game from spooky to really scary at times. Even like the sound design when you're now walking and all you hear are the sound of your feet hitting the metal. I mean it's it's incredible. Yeah. And you got these like creepy enemies like the giant Bugs that only exist in the Hell Dimension. Yeah, I know, right? That face that says it all. And I love that those are in the movie. Now I love that those are in the movie. I love that the nurses made the movie. Those are the big ones. Yes. Anything that's age the best for you. How do you feel about? one other thing about being confident in Silent Hill. The opening cutscene is so great. The way that that game opens and the music, and it's almost like a You know how they put like a hook in the beginning of a podcast where it's like thirty seconds to a minute of the best parts? Yeah. This is like a trailer of the whole game. Yes. It actually doesn't give too much away. It doesn't show too much of the scene with Lisa. It doesn't show a lot, but it also talks about its confidence where not a lot of movies just like give you a teaser trailer or something. I thought the intro to this game ruled and I thought that it it knew how to start and pull you in. It made you feel like you were playing a scary movie. Right. It felt very twin peaksy. It had that vibe of like, we're gonna show you these really goofy characters and you're gonna see them and now you're gonna recognize them because you saw in the beginning. But at the same time, these are like the tenth pole points, and you have a lot to go. And you gotta wonder how you're gonna get there. You're gonna wonder what these characters are doing. And I also love that they kept that going at the end, too, and had the outtakes and all that stuff. That that's one of the things that aged best for me is The general presentation. super cool that they I I love when games don't take Lempels too seriously. So the fact you had this high tension horror vibe and then it ends with the outtake bloopers. Love that. So good. Yeah. And the fact that this PT, this playable teaser, you know, that Guillermo do Toro does like 20, 15 years later, you can see so much of Silent Hill's DNA in there. In terms of, you know, we're gonna do a mini playables about it and like not gonna try to spoil PT at all if you've never played it. But there's moments in the game that are like outrageous and kind of funny, and particular in the bathroom when you run into certain things. And it's like Silent Hill almost feels like Guillermo del Toro and like David Lynch came together and made a video game, right? Because you talk about that Twin Peaks element and then you talk about that that horror. And yeah, I I I couldn't believe how warmly I felt about Silent Hill until this most recent playthrough. It was a game that always existed in my mind as this real relic of the survival horror times. And then I'm like, actually you were the pinnacle. Like you were you were one of the peaks, you know? Anything else that's aged the best for you? I want to call out the math system in a positive way. I would rather have it than not. So please, yes. I love that. It's not the fog of war that you fill in. It's a literal map. yeah. And Harry is drawing on it, you know, basically. Very innovative. Again, just adds to this vibe of he's like, he's just a dude lost. And he has to be like, that door doesn't work. I went in there. This one's unlocked. don't know, don't go past this building. Circle this 'cause I already went there. Very cool. again, the whole atmosphere. All these little elements build into this great presentation of a game. I thought the map system was incredibly intuitive. I love that I can open it up at any point and feel like I was getting somewhere, feel like I had a direction. Sometimes I'd have to pull it up two or three times on the way because I'd get a little lost. I do wish that there was a small mini-map or something in the upper right hand corner that maybe gave you just the intersections you were at, something. So I didn't to open the physical map all the time. You know, it's like, go right or left here. But I agree that the map is very intuitive and I miss it when I go back and I play older survival horror games, right? Like I don't think Dino Crisis had a map, or if it did, it wasn't as intuitive. And I don't remember Resident Evil's until four having a map, maybe. Resident Evil would have one, but you'd find a chunk of a map and then it'd be like, This glowing green part is where you have to go, or maybe unexplored. Yes. So it was not that organic. you know, dude with town map that he's drawing in kind of vibe. Although did did that town map have a map have the insides of the hospital sketched out? Probably not. But that's fine. Agreed. That's a great call actually on what's age the best. I I make fun of it as cartographer simulator, but that's just because I had to open the map like every thirty seconds. But I'd I'd so much rather have it than not, right? Like that game would be unnavigatable. No, no, no. It it would be unfun. It would be it would be unfun. It would be unplayable. Un American. Un American. There we go. So why don't you get us started on what's age of the worst? Because you're gonna have the biggest one, and I am so excited to hear how you describe these these lovely controls. Two words for you. Mm-hmm. Tank. Mm-hmm. Controls. I wasn't expecting controls to come after tank. Please explain. I understand it's what all the games did at that time. It's an excuse for like why you would do it, of course. That's what everyone did. They are not the best way to play a video game. I don't care what game it is. Tank controls are a relic of the past. I am glad they live in the past. I don't need to see them anymore. That being said, does that prevent me from going back to this game? No. But man, it's just not a natural way to play a video game. I think the original Resident Evil comes out in ninety five. This game comes out in ninety nine. So we are four years into tank controls. We went almost half a decade with a specific genre having tank controls, a very successful, right? It was like so weird to me when I first played Metal Gear Solid. And all of a sudden, if I go left and I go right and I go up and down, I was like, yes, like I'm we're back, baby. But you know, and I you know what? I don't even remember. So I haven't played Silent Hill two. On the PS2 and long enough to remember if they got out of the tank controls by then. I I will be able to kind of speak to that in in December when I play it. But the tank controls are brutal. And in this game, especially, everything this was at a time where you had auto aim. So sometimes, you know, like there's two enemies in front of you and you you shoot the one to the left, and the one to the left is like is kickable. So you don't have to waste any more bullets. Right. And I turn to the right a little bit and I go to shoot the one on the right and it goes back to the one on the left. And I'm like, My guy, like Harry, like know how to aim. Yes, the tank controls are are king of what's aged the worst during this time period for any of these games. So so now I have a question for you, 'cause when I watched you play through this, I saw you were pretty for the most part clearing out rooms of enemies. When you play Survivor Horror Games, is that what you do every time? Or do you eventually get comfortable with a game where you're just running around, like specifically zombies and our in the Resident Evil games? In a Resident Evil, so here's the one thing. And then we can get back to what's age the worst is the difficulty in Silent Hill because they sure do give you a lot of ammo and they sure do give you a lot of healing items. Now I played on normal. There was easy, normal, and hard. I played in the middle, but the middle is like kind of where I am. But I just blew everybody away because A, they didn't respawn, and there's so much backtracking in Silent Hill. There's more backtracking in Silent Hill than there is in Resident Evil 2 in areas like that because they're more expansive. Yeah. Resident Evil 1 is just a mansion, so it's an infinite amount of backtracking. But as you go later into Nemesis and Resident Evil 4, you're consistently going into new areas. So that's part of the reason why I blew the enemies away. But yeah, they do give you a lot of ammo and a lot of health. So I was like, you know what? Let's make this into an action adventure game. something that's aged the worst for me is the feeling of being lost at times, even with the map. Sometimes I would get to a place and I would be really confused. They didn't for example, in the school, you have to put the medallion into the wall and then the piano opens. But no one explained that to me. So I didn't realize that I was like, that's where the second medallion comes from. Why would I bother going to put the first medallion in? I'm just gonna wait till I have both and I can put them in. And then I was basically stuck and had to look it up and realize so there are times where you are a little lost in that. I even think in the beginning, you have to like get to the doghouse and you have to like check random front stoops of houses. Like it's just a little confusing at times. I don't when you first played it, did you get a little lost? Yeah, this is from that time where puzzles were made and they were just a little too obtuse. You I think I I can remember you playing Clock Tower a few days ago and it was like, I have to press this button for an elevator. It doesn't work. And then you killed some monster and suddenly the button works. Why? I don't know. Because because they didn't want you to sequence it. Some monster? I killed a big fat gross like weird baby thing. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, you're right. I I despise that. I despise when something is just like a a time lapse lock or something or a part of the game. So I understand that's what they did at the time and it's nowhere near like a point and click kind of obtuseness. Still, it's just a bit too much. I agree, where you you're gonna get confused. There's really no logical connection between things sometimes. I don't know if that's better or worse than modern gaming where you're just spoon fed stuff. Like if you stare at something for more than two seconds that gotta war, Atreus is like, Hey dad, did you try this? And you're like, Come on, stop. I I'm I'm playing the video game of your kid. Yeah. I I have story in between what's age of the best and what's age the worst. So the biggest difference in the movie is that in the game, Dahlia Gillespie runs the cult that sacrifices her daughter that leads to all the nightmares and stuff. And in the movie, and sorry if I'm spoiling properties that are 20 years old plus, in the movie they make Dahlia Gillespie into a more empathetic character, and the cult takes Alessa and And sacrifices her and blah, blah, blah. The story itself was actually kind of fun for me. I like that idea. I like the idea of Alessa and Cheryl being split. It's very spooky. It's very supernatural. And it kind of lets me know right away like I'm going into more of a supernatural world. Resident Evil is like not supernatural. Resident Evil's T virus left. It infected these people. This is something that you could see happening in real life. Whereas Silent Hill is like we're going full supernatural. Right. So did you how did you f find the story and that supernatural element of the game? Yeah, again, I want to go back to this felt more like a coherent plot for a TV show or movie where I could follow things, there was mystery, but it was intriguing. And yeah, Resident Evil, the does the story truly matter in the first Resident Evil? I don't know, man. Evil Corporation makes zombie like fine. It's yeah, I'm not there for that. I'm I'm there to survive with rooms. I that's a great elevator. Yeah, right. But yeah, Silent Hill gets more in your head. and that's why in some respects someone might like it better than Resident Evil. I could see that. I don't really have anything else that's aged the worst. Some of the voice acting is not great. Yeah. But for the most part, Harry, the nurse whose name I always forget. Lisa. Lisa. Cheryl. Some of the voice acting from the side characters are bad, but also some of the side characters are really, really random. Like the rich dude with the briefcase whose name I don't know. Kaufman. His voice acting. Kaufman. His voice acting wasn't great, but also his like kind of jamming him into the end of the story felt weird. Yeah. but for the most part, some of it's this is like a teetering thing, right? Where it's like the voice acting is age the best, but also the worst. Dahlia Gillespie is a little over the top, but yeah. But it was pretty good. Yeah, I think she's supposed to be. It's that whole vibe, right? Like you're you're bought you're playing a Twin Peaks horror game. It's such a good way of I don't think that a a game got this vibe correctly until Alan Wake, probably. I think that's like the next time that they get it correct is because I love the first Alan Wake. The second one was okay, but the first one that was a real crisp. First one was so good. I think so Chris. I'm sure there's some niche games that we like just don't aren't in our orbit. But like as far as, you know, mainstream, like good selling games, yeah, that's that's about right. Yeah. anything else for you that's age the worst before we we talk about where it ranks in in horror games and how scary you found it. Now we hit all the big points. I'll well tell me. Well, you already said, you said this was pretty scary for you, but it was this more scary than Resident Evil? Yes, this is a this is a top five scary video game for me of all time. And there are times that spook me, like when you're playing Resident Evil two and the dog jumps through the window. Pretty early in Resident Evil 2. Nemesis busting through the wall in Resident Evil 3 makes that a top five horror game for me as well. But I thought that Silent Hill is immaculate with the vibes and the sound design and headphones and despite the grainy graphics, I thought I think it's very, very scary. I'm interested because it doesn't scare you too much. Is there a game series that has ever really gotten you on the on the horror side? Yeah, it's it's n it's never the game as a whole stomach, right? Like I'm like you just said, Outlast, I couldn't finish. I it scared the hell out me. because again, horror's not my bread and butter. Yeah. Like I I I saved the game after I think a corpse just comes swinging down from the rafters on a noose. And I saved the game and I was like, and then I turned it back on and my wife's like, what are you playing? Like, this game outlasts. It's scary, but don't worry, I saved past the scary part. And as soon as I walk in the room, the body comes flying down again. my God. You were in the duck house. She literally ran out of the room. Or the Resident Evil remakes, like the the the the middle remakes, the GameCube era, not the newest ones. Again, dog jump through the window. Or I thought Resident Evil 4 had its moments too. And Resident Evil Four, I played it for the Wii and it was pretty scary for the time. Like even though it was like real people or like whatever, it was like the townspeople, man. Some of them were pretty freaking scary. It was also like the gross And then another one I want to call out is Resident Evil Zero. I did play that. You're on a train. And you know where you're used to? And I think this is true for PS1 era as well. You're used to these graphics where the backgrounds are almost like painted, it looks like, right? So they're static. And if something looks a little fuzzy, like, this could move, it is. It's gonna get up and try to get you, right? And that's almost always true until you play this game, Resident Evil Zero, where I cleared a whole train. There was nothing else that looked like it could move. And on my second run through a zombie came out from between two seats and I was like, How is that possible? Yeah, yeah. I I I hold this game in very high regard. and I think that, you know, we'll w when we get to the legacy of it, I think this game does so much for scary games and for for horror on on the console. Would you like to get us started with your hell dimension take? This is a a hot you're standing above sewer great or whatever metal greats right now, and these two enemies are coming down on you, and the only way you can fight them off is with your hot take. Silent Hill one is strictly better than Resident Evil 1. Okay. It is maybe has a couple less jumps that get you, but the vibe is better. Yep. Camera is better. The map is better. maybe the only thing I give Resident Evil is there's a couple more guns. Maybe. But on a whole, I think there's more endings to get. I think it's I know it comes later, so maybe it's not fair, but you we always compare Resident Evil and Silent Hill because they're both the pinnacles of survival horror from that generation. And I don't know. May I I think a lot of people disagree with you on that, but I think Silent Hill is the better game. I would almost and this is not my hot take, but I would say that First three Silent Hills pound for pound, I might take over the first three Resident Evil. Yeah. And that's just for me being such a horror movie fan and being such a horror game fan when I when I really come across stuff that I like, I could almost say that the first three pound for pound is there. What I will say is that Silent Hill did just as good of a job introducing. most gamers to horror the same way that Metal Gear Solid did that for espionage. I feel like Silent Hill is the most important horror game of all time. And I say that because it pulled at a time where horror was very niche and you were maybe looking for a clock tower on the Super Famicom or you were looking for like these really weird underground PlayStation one games. I feel like Silent Hill is the most important horror video game of all time. Because it allowed pure horror to move into like a friendly mass market environment for gaming. I know if that's a hot I'm not gonna fight you on that. I'm not gonna fight. I'm not gonna fight that. You're supposed to fight me on my hot takes. I I put it up there with Metal Gear Solid in terms of getting gamers into new genres that they previously may not have dabbled in. Final Fantasy VII with RPGs. We get to this disc based time and we get to this kind of, you know, the the the genres start becoming more sophisticated and all of a sudden we've got these new genres and Silent Hill put the hat on for horror and was like, All right, motherfuckers, let's go. Let me guide you through this fog. I think we need to parse out because it's a difficult conversation, right? W horror versus survival horror. So re I think Silent Hill almost lives in two camps, right? It's got the pure horror and the story and everything that's going, but yet it has the guns, the ammo, the puzzles. I think survivor horror horror trends more towards the Resident Evil side over time. And then horror like Silent Hill, if you look at the games now, yeah, there's combat, but they really scare the heck out of you. And Resident Evil went so far away from that and had to come back to it. Whereas I feel like Silent Hill was like was there. If you had to do genres like a hundred percent Resident Evil and Silent Hill s share the same genre, which is their survival horror first and foremost. But I feel like the extra elements really accentuate the horror part, right? So for survival horror, I feel like for Silent Hill, horror is all capital letters. You know, like if that makes any sense, because like that part is so much more accentuated. It's like, I don't even know, like a you know, point and click adventures. And then Diablo 2 comes around and all of a sudden you have like a point and click RPG. And it's like it just adds that extra element. So it's still technically a point and click game, but it's like extra, that's a good analogy. But Yeah. My hot take is that without Silent Hill, I don't know that we have a a a healthy horror game life life cycle, you know? So Yeah, maybe you never get to the collaboration with people like Gill and Otomo to do a PT because horror is looked at as still like the stepchild of of gaming. Isn't it crazy that a playable teaser, a one hour playable teaser, is still one of the scariest video games ever created? It's it's really You know, I wonder if it's almost a blessing in disguise. Like, could the game have not lived up to it? I know. But yes, we'll be doing a mini playables on that next week with Tony. It'll be very, very fun. Yeah. I know. And I gotta replay it. That's a game, though, that wow horror, like top five. Yeah. Yeah. All right. This is part of the time where we give out an achievement. This is our second podcast doing this. And what we do is we've now accrued a List of achievements from previous podcasts. And I am going to hand out my achievement. This is the from Mega Man X. This is my Storm Eagle achievement for killer soundtrack. And that achievement, congratulations, goes to Silent Hill. You get 30 gamer points for this. You have an outstanding immaculate soundtrack. And your soundtrack is what differentiates you. From games like Dino Crisis and Resident Evil and really makes you stand out as one of the cream of the crops for survival horror. What kind of achievements are you giving out today? I would like to dig back to the Pokemon Yellow achievement of cha of horrible death scream. we're gonna award sorry, it's more like Go ahead. We're gonna give that to I don't know, take your pick. Whatever gross monster sound comes out of their mouths. The worst is when you you kill the kids that are like trying to or the very small ones and they make like the squeaking death. Yeah. Yeah. Very apropos achievement. I and I I can never not think of like anytime there's a death sound or something, I can never not think of Pokemon Yellow. I was like That that joke should be perpetuating for as long as you're doing this. Exactly. That'll be one of our one of our running bits for the rest of our the rest of time. As we start to wrap up here, I wanted to know how you feel Silent Hill has aged. And I like, you know, this is where, you know, we'll talk about the legacy of the game next, but how do you feel like the IP has aged between its movies, games, and like reputation on the streets? It is Certainly not what Resident Evil is. I think Resident Evil is now the peak survival horror. and I mean that's a whole different discussion. But Silent Hill totally lost its way when you're in, I think, PS3 era. You know, downpour, homecoming, and a couple others after that. We're not hits. Got away from I think that pure horror. But it's back, right? Silent Hill F. It looks amazing. It is so creepy. Yeah. And Town Town Fall came out this year too. Silent Hill. Mm-hmm. Town Fall. It's getting really good reviews. So yeah, Silent Hill seems to be back. Yeah. And it's, you know, it's still got now it's got action. Like it's it's more on that survival side than well, no, I shouldn't say it's more. The horror side is still locked in. It's just now there's combat really solidified draped on top of it. man, the scenes and that and and the idea that there's still like this alternate dimension you fall into, that persists and it just works. Would you I forgot to put this on the the rundown because we always talk about this when there's any games talking about a remaster or a remake. Without answering if this game is replayable, would you play this game? Cause I didn't touch Silent Hill 2 remake or remaster it. I did a I did a let's play of it. But I'd be interested in playing it if I played a Sil would you go back and play a Silent Hill one remaster slash remake? Yeah, I think I would. The game is short enough where if it's not that new, like it just looks better. That's fine. I would love to see a remake where they redesign some of the levels, you know, keep the story the same, or maybe maybe even embellish the story a bit, but give you new experiences within it with different and like with upgraded graphics, some of these monsters would be horrific. maybe I don't want to play it now. Actually, now that I think about it. But it does have a high ceiling. I think that obviously you talked about it. What Silent Hill one through three and Resident Evil one through three, it's like, okay, they're kind of neck and neck. And then four comes out, and at that point Resident Evil just levels up. And then now with the remakes, Resident Evil is so like the number one and two survival horror IP are just not even close anymore, right? It's just Resident Evil has just taken that bag and then with the movie this year, that is one of the hottest intellectual properties in all of multimedia. Capcom is That being said, Silent Hill coming back with the games, having a strong run previously, and still having a fan base of people that truly love those old Silent Hill one through two. I feel like Silent Hill has aged very well. I feel like Silent Hill has really persisted. Not a lot of 90s games, Metal Gear Solid, for instance, hasn't aged as well. Like a lot of these intellectual properties maybe haven't survived. Silent Hill, despite making two very bad movies and a couple of games that were very mid. They've survived. And it's it's it's based off of that incredible foundation and being able to pivot back. And you know, the other examples on this have been Dino Crisis and Resident Evil, but those are two Capcom games. Those are two games that they built the engine for on Resident Evil One and kept refining it and putting out new stuff. For Silent Hill, for Konami to come in and for to them to kind of come into this genre and do it extremely well and innovate on it and make the the 180 Make the one eighty camera and the map system. Right. And do all these innovations. Like that is wow. Like Konami is, you know, we we already know they kick so much ass with Castlevania and stuff. But then like this was a sweet, sweet cherry on top of that that nineties Konami era. yeah. Yeah. Before they got into the Yu Gi butter, like it's just Yu-Gi-Oh games as far as the eye can see. You never want to go in the Yu Gi butter. Yeah, for me, the legacy of this game is it just leveled up horror gaming for most gamers. It allowed a more niche s area of gaming to be more accessible and to feel a little more safe. You weren't gonna get something that was gonna like crazy shock you or it was actually gonna be like a horror game where the horror was built through the gameplay and building a a really realistic world as opposed to like silly shock and gratuitous gore and stuff that we had. found ourselves what was that game that was banned? my God. It was like it wasn't fight night, but it was this fighting game that was banned because it was insanely gratuitous gore and all that stuff. And it's like we got really weird in the nineties with gross out stuff and wasn't Eternal Champions. No, that one Noah I'm gonna I'm gonna edit this out, but I'm gonna look it up. One of the few games where they probably got the adults only ESRB rating. yes. All right. Do you remember Thrill Kill? No. The four player 3D fighting game that was banned, adults only. And it was like such a big deal. It was like on the black market for like PS1. Like people had this game that was yeah. So we got into like crazy gratuitous and Manhunt, like yeah. The gap between Manhunt and Silent Hill is crazy. Like Manhunt does a decent job of building this. kind of world and this this vibe. But Manhunt is like again gratuitous and whereas Silent Hill for for a gross game, Silent Hill is still more charming and mature than some of those other ones. Yeah, and more more thoughtful, I think, too. Whereas y you had stuff come out in the Xbox like Manhunt Postal or even you might even be able to lump some of the condemned games in there. You're like you're you're just you're just going for shock value now. I'm not saying some of those games aren't good. Like I think the condemned games actually are pretty good. But yeah. What's your legacy of Silent Hill 1? I think for its series, it sets the tone of having multiple endings and a joke ending. I love that there's a joke ending with the UFO and that you have to, you know, run through some hoops to get that. That's great. And that persisted for quite a few. I don't know if the newest ones do that. I would imagine they don't, but I I you know, I don't actually know the answer to that. but for a long time, like this set the tone of you're gonna have this search spooky game. But once you played it two or three times, you wanna see like, the dog did it is the ending. That was one for one of the games. Like, yeah, it's there, it's great. All right, so our penultimate question is this game replayable? No. With the caveat that the f the one time that you go through this game, it is and I hadn't played it for like twenty plus years. So it felt like I was playing a brand new game. So when I talk about replayable, like there's games where I go back and I replay every few years, right? For me, Silent Hill is not like that. It's a little slow at times, it's a little rough. And once you know most of the puzzles, it's like any other survival horror game, right? A lot of the fun for me was figuring out what piano keys to hit. With the birds, or to figure out where to put the stones in the door to figure out that puzzle, right? So I feel like once you do the puzzles on a lot of these games, it's you know, it's like braid. It's not as fun going back once you know how to do it. is this game replayable for you? Yes. And see, I'm gonna answer this question properly this time. Yes, I think you can go back and replay this. I think the replayability is going through different endings, doing it as fast as you can, you know. I'm not one for speed runs, but I think there is fun to be had and like running around enemies. I know I don't have to fight this guy. I can just run straight to this doghouse. That could be a lot of fun. and then to answer the question you haven't asked, I would recommend if someone hasn't played the original Silent Hill, I think it's worth a play. Tank controls be damned. I think you just have to understand that it's gonna happen. You're gonna you're gonna accept the tank controls into your life. You should play. 100% agree. I don't think that you necessarily should play Resident Evil One, Two or Three to play any of the remakes. But if the Silent Hill remaster or remake is gonna come out, I think Silent Hill one is one of those games that's really worth seeing what it was before you play the remaster or the remake. Because twenty seven years later you may not fully understand how important this game was for leveling up an entire genre of gaming that exists today. But I agree that this is like immaculate vibes. It is, you know, the the graphics are a little funny, like the way like every time Harry wakes up in the in the diner and his mouth is just like a gape. Like some of it's a little silly. Yeah. But it is, it is really the the foundation is there. Okay. So for recommending, so for bonus level, mention anything about Silent Hill or anything about like horror games that didn't come up. And then I'm gonna let you go first because I I think I might know your pick, but I don't want to take it from you. Recommend a spooky game just in time for Halloween. This is coming out on Tuesday, so people are gonna have a week and a half to go through your recommended game. And you know, going back to your comment, no horror movie should be over two hours. I don't think any horror game should be over like ten hours, right? I think a horror game is is Did you consider Resident Evil four a horror game? Cause that one was like fifteen hours and I actually enjoyed the duration of that. Or is that more action? I think it's more action. It's not that there's no horror in it. But at that point the gameplay has fully switched over to a full action game. That's true. so I think that's a little different. but if you're going for real spookiness, you can't overstate your welcome. That's why a lot of games now are short. The little short packaged horror games. I'm not gonna recommend one of those. I'm gonna recommend Until Dawn. Until Dawn is a fantastic cinematic game. You wanna talk about experiencing a horror movie? Wow. I don't think the later ones capture the magic the same the first one did. I I don't think they come very close, to be honest with you. But that first one, if you have if you like horror, you need to play Until Dawn. I haven't ever played it. You need to play it. Damn, I do need to play it. You know what? I I was looking, you know, it might have to wait till next spooky season, but I definitely will want it. That's that's on my short list. we we mentioned it already and I didn't know if you were gonna take it, so I'll take it. I thought that Alan Wake was a really, really narratively strong, short indie game that ruled. So yeah, Alan Wake is a wonderful pick. Silent Hill two is is honorable mention, but if you're gonna play Silent Hill one, you're probably gonna go straight to two. I'm gonna give you I didn't really love Alan Wake too that much. I thought that they did a good job of trying to level it up and make it more horror filled, but it lost that twin peaksy charm of Alan Wake one. So that's what I'd recommend. Yeah, Alex Alec Alan Wake had a really good narrative twist. And I like when games call back to certain things. like Kotor does a great job of that. Alan Wake does a great job of that. that always gets me every time. Yeah, I would 100% recommend Allen Wake. It gameplay holds up too. I don't think it's you know a game that would be like a chore to play. Agreed. George, thank you so much for joining me today on this this trip into the hell dimension, aka doing a podcast with me. Appreciate you as always. And again, I'd want no one else navigating me through the fog of Silent Hill. As long as we're holding hands. Got it. Well, let's let's fill out this map together. And we'll see you next time for another episode of the Replayables. Take care of yourselves.