Paul DelPonte: Welcome to True Crime Prevention, the podcast that melds True Crime with Real Solutions. Let's expose how all crime starts the same way, with a chance. Today we won't give it a chance. I'm Paul Delponte and I work with McGruff the Crime Dog. Thank you for joining us. And we've got a special guest with us today, and we're going to get into the issue of fake ads and why they exist, how they are proliferating, and how we can hopefully stop them. but before we do that, ask you all to click like and subscribe. Let's build up our our viewer base. And as we get in with the episode, if you can leave comments, drop the comments in. Let us know if you've ever if you've ever picked up on a fake ad, if you've been scammed by a fake ad, and we'll get into that. But today we're very lucky to have with us a journalist, an investigative journalist. And I I I like to say there's a little bit of crime dog in every investigative journalist. They go in and they uncover the facts. And Katharine Schwab is with Forbes magazine and she did a deep dive into the issue of of fake ads. And she joins us. Welcome, Katharine. Thanks for joining us. Katharine Schwab: Hi, Paul, thanks for having me. Paul DelPonte: You bet, you bet. And and as I said, there there there is a little crime dog in you, so we will go from there, but to let folks know the our headquarters, the National Crime Prevention Council, sits atop of the old Washington Post building. So we'll be doing we'll sh be channeling a lot of Woodward and Bernstein and following the money on the fake ads, because that's ultimately Money for ill-gutten gains. So let's get into it. Katharine, let me ask let's kick this off asking you why did you pick this topic to do such a deep dive in? And for folks who haven't seen it, there's an article in Forbes. TikTok quietly gutted its advertising rules. Scams have exploded ever since. And it's also good to know that in-depth journalistic coverage is still alive and well. And if you haven't read it, I could So Katharine, why did why did why'd you take this on? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, thanks, Paul. So this actually came, I think, as as many great stories do from a tip. So I heard from someone inside the company about some of these issues at at TikTok, which I know we're gonna get into. so it kind of began with with a source who had just left the company and wanted to speak about their experience. At TikTok and what they had seen when it came to advertising in particular. So TikTok obviously is a huge advertising business. they're owned by ByteDance, which is a Chinese massive tech company. their primary way to make money is through ads. however, through my reporting, we uncovered that. TikTok had changed some of its rules that it uses to police advertisers and as a result there was this huge rush of of fake advertisements that were being used to scam people. Paul DelPonte: So let let's help our listeners out here a little bit. When you hear the term fake ad, that might mean different things to different people. Katharine wanna explain a fake ad, w what it is, why it exists? Katharine Schwab: Sure, yeah. So the fake ads that I focused on in my reporting, and as Paul, as you said, there could be a lot of different kinds of fake ads, but what we're really talking about is a an advertisement that looks like it's advertising a real product or real service, but is actually fake. That product doesn't exist, and the person is just trying to steal your money. So as an example, I spoke to a woman who is a creator on TikTok who had kind of fallen for this scam multiple times. And essentially sh the way that this playbook works on TikTok, and this is kind of the the predominant scam on TikTok, is you see an advertisement for a product at a really good price. So in her case, she was looking, she saw an ad that looked like it was from Aerie, which is the athleisure company, and she saw that they had heavily discounted pajamas that were six bucks, which normally these pajamas cost like eighty dollars or something. And so she was like, wow, that's a great deal. I'm gonna get an early start on my Christmas shopping. And so she told me how she, you know, went to the site, she filled up her cart with maybe $40 or so worth of pajamas, which is a lot of pajamas for six dollars each. And you know, she paid, she paid for it, and moved on and kind of assumed that those pajamas would one day show up and they never did. So this is a kind Paul DelPonte: It never did. Katharine Schwab: of core way that scammers are targeting people on TikTok. Paul DelPonte: And now those scammers also have her credit card information. Katharine Schwab: They sure do. Yeah. Paul DelPonte: And so it it it fuels itself. on our website ncpc.org and mcgruff.org, we have different tips you can use, look at, but these ads are are they there are things like, well, if Amazon is spelled what a why, you know it's fake, shut the browser, things like that. But as we understand it and what we're seeing more of, Katharine, and maybe your reporting confirm some of this, some of these ads are becoming increasingly more sophisticated and harder to spot as fake. Katharine Schwab: Yeah, absolutely. These these scammers are really, really very good. it looks identical to the legitimate website. I think in the case of this woman, her name's Lottie, she on her credit card, it did not say Airy. And that was when she went back and checked when it had been a month and she had never received what she thought she had bought. she she saw that it had kind of another another name instead of Airy. So it can be really easy to fall for this kind of scam because it really looks very, very good and they've gotten very sophisticated. and I s for this story, I spent a lot of time in the TikTok ad library, which is a compendium of all of the ads that TikTok runs in Europe. It's required by the European Union. They passed a r law to require TikTok to do that. So that's not available for the United States. So we don't have really any sense of what is running on TikTok. Advertising wise in the US, but you do in Europe. So it gives you a little bit of a sense of what these kinds of ads look like. So when I was trying to find examples of what these ads might look like, you know, I'd heard from kind of firsthand victims who had had this happen. I heard from people inside the company about this problem. but I was looking, I wanted to see the ads myself. And Paul DelPonte: Yeah. Katharine Schwab: so you type it, if you search 90% off. in the TikTok ad library, it pulls up thousands of ads, many of which are kind of the same ad repeated over and over again. they often just have crazy prices. Like I remember there was one, you know, for like a Ralph Lauren you know, polo shirt that would retail for more than $150 for like three dollars, something that. I mean, that is, feel like a a common sign. That should always be a flag for anyone is if it is too good to be true, it probably is, right? This is very much, it Paul DelPonte: There you go. That old attitude holds true. Katharine Schwab: sure does. that's definitely either not a real Raf Lauren shirt or it's just never gonna show up at all, and they will have taken your credit card information. So Paul DelPonte: Right. Katharine Schwab: people should be very kind of wary any advertisements they see on TikTok. Of course, like legitimate brands. are heavy advertisers on TikTok. This doesn't mean that all TikTok ads are are somehow fake. But when when something seems too good to be true, double check. And in the best case, I mean reached out to all of the brands that I mentioned in this story, including Hey Dude Shoes and Figs are also as well as Nike, like their big brands are being impersonated as part of these scams. And some of them didn't get back to me, but Hey Dude and Figs both said the best way to make sure that you're buying from us is to go directly to our website. not don't click the link through the advertiser or ad through the ad itself. and so you can always double check. Paul DelPonte: There you go, good advice. so let's get into again. You said it's either they're gonna take your credit card or what if you get any if you get anything, chances are you may not, but what you get might end up being a fake product. It's not gonna be a real laugh, Ralph Lauren or Gucci or whatever. so for folks who are are regular listeners. We'll know that we when we talk about fakes and scams, we always urge people, if you don't know where the money's going, to be careful because, you know, for example, say you go to go to Forbes website and you want to subscribe, which you want to read this article, a good thing, please do, right? Exactly. Katharine Schwab: Please do, please do. Paul DelPonte: But you hear Forbes, you know what you're gonna get. You know, you know you're gonna get quality journalism, you know you're gonna get a business perspective. economics in there and those kinds of things. So you've got a good idea. You don't know what's going to be in next month's edition, but you kind of know what you're going to get with your money. So you you feel comfortable that you're going to give somebody your credit card number. If you're looking at an ad and you don't feel that same comfort level that you do with a quality brand that you've known over the years and trust, don't give them a credit card number. get away from that act, close your browser, reopen it and go to what you know is gonna be legitimate. And then you'll see, no, it's not ninety they may have a sale, but the chances are it's not gonna be ninety percent off. tell me Katharine Schwab: Yeah, exactly. Paul DelPonte: so you reached out on a as as any good journalist would to others for comment, you reach out to TikTok. What what sort of TikTok's position in defense of this? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, it was interesting. They well so a a big part of the story is not just that These ads are prevalent on TikTok. Scams have always been prevalent on social media. This is a huge problem. Other companies have this problem. As a journalist, that's not really a story anymore because it's just an ongoing problem. What is different here, and what kind of prompted this reporting, was that TikTok actually changed its rules about policing these ads specifically, and they took away all of the guardrails on these ads. Last fall, according to multiple sources from inside the company and internal documents showing what their policies are. So this is how they determine if an advertiser is allowed to run ads. So they used to have a policy for this type of scam. It's called kind of within the company, it's called a non-delivery scam. They used to have a specific policy that if an advertiser was running these ads, they would get immediately banned. And they changed that policy so that now they are not banned anymore. so obviously you and we did a bunch of reporting to try to understand the impact of that policy change. and in doing an analysis of unverified anonymous scam reports on the Better Business Bureau's website. I did a lot of work. With the help of some AI and machine learning to do data analysis on all of those scam complaints to show that after this policy change, reports of this specific type of scam shot up 200%. So almost triple in Paul DelPonte: Wow Katharine Schwab: the six months before this policy change and the six months after this policy change. So in the story, so we have a we have a chart kind of showing, and and that that also is the the amount of reports that mention TikTok at all also rose 142% over that same period. Overall, scam reports were going up during that time. So it's important to note that all scam reports for the Better Business Bureau had gone up 60%. But you can see that that's a pretty significant increase for TikTok-related scams and then specifically non-delivery scams on TikTok. During that period. So, you know, the Better Business Bureau, none of those are verified. It's all anonymous people kind of submitting those complaints to that nonprofit so that you know, try to warn people and hopefully those things can be investigated. So, you know, none of those complaints are verified. But I think it shows kind of at a at a high level what that scale looks like. so when Paul DelPonte: Yeah. Katharine Schwab: I went to the company for comment. they basically kind of were like, This is all false and didn't engage with anything at all. so it was pretty disappointing response, I would say. 'cause I feel a hundred percent Paul DelPonte: Well, Katharine Schwab: sure about the reporting. Paul DelPonte: That's why we're here to shine a light on this, because as McGruff famously said when he first appeared on TV in the 1980s, keep your lights on. Lights make crooks nervous. so let's continue to shine a light on them. So so we National Crime Prevention Council, we got calls. We got calls before they changed their policy, and we put something out which you included in your story, and we thank you for that. To keep shining the light on them because this was a problem. Fake ads were a problem before they changed their policy. Now it's grown exponentially worse. And what we found when we first we we gave TikTok 24 hours before we went public to say and they didn't fix it. So we went public, we went public and they fixed it. Fixed it. For a little bit of time, then they're back. And you uncovered some of that. What what did that lead you to conclude? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, I think TikTok has a si serious enforcement problem. So, you know, I think I think there's there's multiple pieces to this. So one, within a tech company, and again, every tech company has these challenges. Facebook similarly has had huge, huge problems with with scam advertisements. but my reporting focuses on TikTok, so I know a lot more about it. so there's the policies, right? These are like the rules that they use to say, okay, this is allowed, this is not allowed. then there's actual enforcement. So, you know, TikTok is has a heavily automated enforcement strategy. So they use computers to try to figure out if a piece of content violates their rules. and we have found through a number of reports, not just this one, that they really struggle to enforce their own rules. So with my colleague Ian Martin, who h also helped me on this story, he did a couple of stories that showed certain types of content that was slipping through the cracks. that's really egregious. So for instance, accounts advertising cocaine, methamphetamines, you know, opiates, etc. without a Paul DelPonte: Right. Katharine Schwab: prescription. That those that content is also on TikTok. that definitely violates all of their rules. that should result in an immediate ban for the advertiser. it's definitely against the it's definitely against the rules. And yet some of that stuff is still slipping through. it's a cat and mouse game for any social media platform to try to crack down and make sure that you don't have bad stuff. You're not you're not putting out bad stuff or hosting hosting illegal content. but TikTok clearly has a real a real issue with this. And they've been they've been laying off moderators and they've been downsizing the people who are overseeing that enforcement as they Paul DelPonte: Some Katharine Schwab: move more toward algorithmic enforcement. Paul DelPonte: Hav having looked into t at least TikTok at a very detailed level, would you say there are structural design flaws in the way they accept advertising that allows this to happen? Is there something in their system that is I mean a 200% increase means there's something in their system that's not working? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, they made a deliberate decision to no longer ban the advertisers running these ads. So that is that's that's less of a systemic flaw and more of just they deliberately decided to do that. Paul DelPonte: It's deli there's an interesting word, deliberate. Okay. so Katharine Schwab: Yes, they they deliberately made that decision. my sources told me that they understood the reason for that decision to be revenue. So TikTok wants to make more money. This is how they make money is through ads. if you if you allow advertisers to run more ads and more sketchy ads, they are going to make more money. So it's a very clear equation there. And my understanding is that kind of the revenue drive at the company is really intense, especially because ByteDance is spending a lot of money on AI, as most tech companies are. And so they are trying to juice their revenue. So this is this is why this is happening. you know, internally the executives at the company, based on my sourcing, have defended this change as well. We had too many good, legitimate advertisers who were getting banned because of these old rules, and we've streamlined them, we've reduced the number of rules to streamline the process so that fewer good advertisers are caught up and get banned accidentally. but I think from my understanding, that is really not what ended up happening as a result of the change. Paul DelPonte: I would say in advertising is something that is very familiar with the National Crime Prevention Council. It's our bread and butter. And on social media, because they are not as generous as newspapers, television, and radio, we generally pay for those ads where the other medium will generally donate time to Good cause crime prevention and in McGruff the Crime Dog ads. That does not happen on social media. So when we place ads on social media, we generally they want a credit card. They get the credit card right away. Algorithms and their check systems are focused on keywords. one of our largest advertising campaigns currently is on fake pills with fentanyl. So in a lot of the ag algorithms, the word fentanyl pops up and it gets banned. no, it is not very sophisticated. So you're you're you're banning Katharine Schwab: Yeah, it's not very sophisticated. No, no. Paul DelPonte: the very thing that is designed to help. now when we if we were to put money down and place an ad in a magazine or a c cable service or or something else. An ad undergoes something called fact checking. The fact checking occurs before the ad makes its way into the publication or broadcast. But on social media platforms, it's all designed as you point to it, you've they they have to get this income in quickly to sustain their engine that they're trying to build. So they take the credit card number and the ads start running right away. So any fact checking they do, albeit as minimal as they do, if not any at this point, it sounds like, happens after the fact. So if you're running a fake ad, selling, pointing somebody to a website for the sole purpose of either selling fake products that are probably fueling some criminal enterprise around the world, or just stealing somebody's credit card information to further steal their money after you already took their money for whatever alleged product they'll never receive they also have your credit card number and you know could be out that night buying airline tickets all around the world and other things. So it is all about the money. And as you follow the money as NCPC has followed the money, as has Homeland Security, Interpool in Europe and others, The money always ends up in criminal enterprise hands. Terrorists, drug dealers, drug cartels, gangs, MS-13 makes quite a bit of money while selling fake products. They're not selling them on the street corner, they're selling them online. So, you know, as that old adage goes, you know, why do rob banks? Well, why do you why do you place ads on TikTok? That's where the money is. And getting getting to it as you started uncovering So would you say, having spoken to a number of people at TikTok, including a former employee who came forward to you, as well as current executives there, where does the onus of change lie? Is it do you is it something TikTok should be taking care of and isn't? And if there happens to be an a state attorney general out there somewhere or somebody like that listening? Katharine Schwab: Ha ha ha. Paul DelPonte: Is it something they have to step in and fix, or do you do you think the company's able to fix this? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, I think that's a great question. I think that from the victims of this scam that I spoke to, people feel like it's TikTok's responsibility to not take money from scammers and to put scam advertisements in front of their audience. I think, you know, that's that feels like a pretty a pretty obvious thing that you shouldn't be profiting off of illegal activity. you know, I think TikTok's response would be, well, we do a lot, like we're trying, but this is a huge problem. but I think the reality is is that they have kind of made deliberate moves to profit off of this. and, you know, I think that's that's problematic. and you know, I think there have been investigations into Facebook's practices here because there's been some more concrete reporting about about Facebook. So I wasn't able to determine how much money TikTok is making off of these advertisements. some of my sources said They're way too smart to ever write that number down. so I wasn't able to get that number. however, Reuters has has reported that Meta in 2024, about 10% of Meta's revenue, which is about 16 billion dollars, may have come from ads for scams and banned goods. And that reporting resulted in a bunch of lawsuits and regulatory action. against Facebook. So, you know, that is still kind of pending and hasn't hasn't resulted in a fine or anything yet. but Facebook it obviously is a much older company than TikTok. Paul DelPonte: And much larger. Katharine Schwab: yes, it's larger with Instagram and Facebook combined Paul DelPonte: Yes. Katharine Schwab: for sure. And TikTok hasn't been around as long, but it still has immense immense scale. So I think looking at Facebook, yeah. Paul DelPonte: immense scale, especially among particular demographics. Katharine Schwab: Yes, absolutely. Definitely a younger demographic on TikTok. so you know, I think it will be interesting to see if the government decides to to step in. Paul DelPonte: In interesting. I I think it'll be a matter of journalists like yourself to keep shining the light on it. Groups like NCPC, but more importantly, you folks out there, you know, pick up the phone. Call your call your state attorney general. You know, call your member of Congress. Say, hey, look, I know a bunch of people who got scammed. And this money in TikTok, if you're listening, you're taking money from people like MS thirteen in Mexican drug cartels, because that's really where the money is fueling. And if you're comfortable as a company doing that in selling your goods and services to everyday people, including your young demographic, ask yourself how you slept that night once you know that. You know, part of this Is to some extent a issue of corporate responsibility. I will point to back in the 1980s, there was a huge scare around Tylenol where cyanide was ended its way up into some Tylenol pills and people started dying. Johnson Johnson McNeil Consumer Products at the time, the manufacturers of it, they voluntarily Shut down manufacturing and they issued a voluntary recall, didn't take the FDA call. And what a lot of people forget: there must have been thousands of people who were dying from that. No, it was six people. And Johnson Johnson knew that was their reputation. People are buying this product to get better. And they wanted to protect their reputation. So TikTok, again, if you're listening, this is your reputation. And one of the things that we have talked about, and even you know, the social media industry talks about it too, about online ecosystems that you know they're creating this vibe. TikTok presents itself as this fun, energetic vibe that it encourages creatives, creators to be as creative as possible and to share that. that's that's the point behind it. But they're creating it in this artificial digital universe where there are not the safeguards and guardrails where they're controlling it. So in the real world, if you're selling drugs and go go back to the way drugs used to be sold, and anybody older than 30 is old enough to remember, you had to go to some dark, scary alley and and encounter some scary looking individual. Drugs. Now you pick up one of these and you get it. And some of these platforms have geolocators, so they know where it is. They put it in a ride share vehicle and it shows up at your doorstep. But so those guardrails, the guardrails of, the police know drugs are sold on this corner, so we can't go there anymore. All those guardrails are taken out of the ecosystem. That's what I think the companies don't understand. They're bragging about their ecosystem and they're selling it. They're selling it to users. This is why you go here. and different platforms have a different purpose, different clientele, different, if you if you want to sell crafting projects, you go to Etsy you you they develop this reputation. Was there a sense in any of your conversations with TikTok that they What was the sense of corporate responsibility you were getting back from them? Katharine Schwab: the company just flatly denied everything and clearly takes has decided to take no responsibility at all. So, I mean, they were basically like, we have plenty of policies, we don't allow deceptive and fraudulent advertising, blah, blah, blah. I think the the reality is that like that's not what the reporting shows. I think one important point to make is that, you know, TikTok is not. Selling fake products. TikTok is not selling drugs. But their platform enables other people to abuse it. And that, again, that abuse is common across social media and has been a problem with the internet since the very beginning. There are Paul DelPonte: Right. Katharine Schwab: good actors and there are bad actors. A core part of how these platforms work and how they operate is that they're not liable for what runs on their platform. So this is called the section section 230, the famous section of the Communications Paul DelPonte: Yes. Katharine Schwab: DC Act of 1996. And this provision essentially created what we created the modern internet because suddenly you could build a business online and host user content without being liable for what that user said. So I think that's it's become an important part of how the internet works currently. There's been a lot of criticism of that law in particular because of exactly this question around who is responsible when this kind of content runs. Yeah. Paul DelPonte: Responsible and who's building what? TikTok is right. They should not the the intent of Congress at the time the law was passed is that a corporate executive should not be determining whether somebody posts, I like the president or I don't like the president. That you know there's an inherent American First Amendment freedom, and you don't want that constricted. The danger is NCPC believes that if you start extending First Amendment protections to drug dealers and child traffickers, you you've gone down a very slippery slope, which is not the intent of our founding fathers, which is not the intent of the First Amendment. that logic in and of itself is a scam to protect drug dealers. And people are buying into that is the danger. Now, in the next few days, there will be a very closely watched trial that's going to begin in Los Angeles called Neville v Snap, which there are 60 plus plaintiffs all suing Snapchat under the sale of fake pills where resulted in the wrongful death of their children, all in California. And the thesis and the basis of the lawsuit is not. Section 230. It is what did Snap engineer that enable the sale of drugs? Which is a separate question over a posting issue. It is, is there something in their algorithm? Is there something that fosters this? and that's going to be very closely watched. It's going to be start beginning in a Katharine Schwab: Yeah. Paul DelPonte: few days, and one. The one good thing it is in California, where there are TV cameras allowed in the courtroom, we can get to watch and see that unflow unfold. One interesting note, and it's taken a couple of years to get to trial, because there were a lot of pretrial motions, one of which TikTok asked the judge to dismiss the whole lawsuit based on section 230. And this is one of the first instances where judges said no. And it wound its way all the way to the state Supreme Court, and they all concurred. Because one one thing, one interesting thing the judge pointed out in some of the preliminary no mo motions was heck, you're saying dismiss this based on, but you've got something so nebulous, it's almost like we need a trial to understand what Snapchat is. So, how can you make that determination without knowing what's inside it? It's, you know, equate it to a car. If you've got a dangerous car, if it's dangerous to begin with, and you slap a seatbelt on it, seatbelt is only going to be so much effective if there's a design flaw in the car itself. And that's what I think judges are going to take a harder look at in this trial. In in other trials, i i it's okay, yeah, you have a right to take an ad, but just because you have a right to take the ad doesn't absolve you of your responsibility for accepting money from criminals. Because you're fueling a criminal enterprise. the industry as we s as we have seen it from our end, doesn't want to hear that. And it sounds like your reporting bats that up what the unwillingness to even comment. Does that make sense? Katharine Schwab: Yeah, yeah, certainly. I think prosecutors have definitely had more success with this argument around design flaws than kind of other arguments that have been made about Facebook's Facebook's harm, Snapchat's harm, et cetera. So I'm not surprised that's kind of the direction that they're taking this pr this particular lawsuit, which is of course similar to this Paul DelPonte: as well as how do you protect the intellectual property rights of the company that's making the real merchandise? which is something NCPC has encountered. I'll give you a very tangible example. there are a lot of people who want to just sell McGruff t shirts and make money on it, not realizing It's a registered trademark of the National Crime Prevention Council. So periodically we go online and we see who's selling fake t-shirts. And we found them, we send them a takedown notice through the website platform and they comply with it. However, in a recent example, I sent a takedown notice to one website. And after sending that takedown notice to it, as you said, they take it down for a minute and then it pops back up. In my different social media feeds, I started getting ads generated by the website company, not the advertiser, that basically said, since you clicked at this McGruff t-shirt, maybe you want this one. So for people listening out there, I'll give you the the real thing as your earlier reporting, and as you said earlier on the interview, if you want to make sure you're getting the real thing, go directly to the website, go directly to our website, the McGruff Shop. And if you use if you use the code at checkout, McGruff Nation, you get a nice little discount. good to know. And you're ensuring that you're getting the real product, which are all made in the USA. and the money is benefiting our work to warn other people about scams like this. So, you know, it's important for us, as it's important for the athletic wear company that, you know, if if people want their merchandise, if they want the next years line of that merchandise, they have to have money to hire their designers to keep the new designs coming out for next season and and all of that. So, a lot of people are getting harmed in this. The the advertising agencies who make real ads are getting harmed. the the list of harms goes on. And in this case, the biggest harm is a consumer harm who they're getting their credit cards and their money stolen. And they're getting it stolen electronically. By a system that somebody wrote the algorithm for that is enabling it. It's more than just the posting. And I think the companies have to start being more and more aware of that and start, you know, if if they don't start voluntarily improving the system, there will come a point in time when it will be forced upon them. and then they're gonna come crying and screaming and folks like us are just gonna say, you should have fixed it earlier. Too bad. Maybe we ought to send a little note to FBI Director Kash Patel and making sure he's aware of what Tik Tok is doing. But you know, part of part of it is that information process, letting people be aware. So if you're if if you're listening, go to our website. We have lots of tips. We also have some advocacy measures that we're pushing for. There is legislation pending in Congress. I won't give the bill number because It'll change in a few weeks with the new Congress. But there are two pieces of legislation. There's the Stop Scams Against Seniors Act, and there's another piece of legislation to create a national plan to combat scams. And interestingly enough, scams have been around for a while. online scams, I I like to say someone made money selling illicit child porn. On the internet before Jeff Bezos ever made his first dollar. And as well. So we've known about scams for a long time. I mean, there have been scams going back to Ponzi and you know centuries. And we still don't have a national plan. We need a national plan. And you know what? For those who may not remember 411, that phone number where you dialed to get you know somebody else's phone number, no one uses it anymore. It's pretty much defunct. We need to turn that into a national fraud hotline. And we need to give people a mechanism, if not to stop fraud, to make sure others are aware of the frauds that are going on and keep the drum beat up. So we've got we've got some things we're pushing for. So I urge you go visit our website. Please fill in the comments. If you think, if you have an idea, if you've experienced a scam, let us know about it. There's something we can do, but we can't do anything if we don't know what's going on. That's the way we shine a light on it. Katharine, thank you so much for your reporting. Thank you for joining us. call Katharine and we and when you when you subscribe to Forbes, you'll be able to get a link. You can search her name and get her link and be right in touch with her. So th there are many advantages of today's digital communication. You can get in touch directly with a reporter and give them the tips that they need to do their job better, just like you know, most crimes are solved by giving a police officer a tip. It's not the police officers themselves, it it's the people out there. You can't have public safety without public involvement. So stay involved in the fraud issue. And on behalf of McGruff the Crime Dog and the National Crime Prevention Council, thank you for joining us, Katharine. Thank you for listening and come back again and help us each week take a bite out of crime.