Annie: The court had to not just see the facts of this case as, this kid kicked and hit his mom. It was no, this was a kid suffering from rad who was just popped in the mouth so hard that he thought his nose was broken. And then when he doesn't behave in juvenile hall, we get these reports in court before trial, he's misbehaving. It like, Yeah, what do you expect? You put him in a jail setting and he has special needs. I raise a little a little bit of evidence, enough to be like, hey, maybe this is self defense. Then the DA has to beyond a reasonable doubt say, no, this wasn't and the DA offered nothing to refute our claim that David: Welcome to Another Not Guilty. I'm David. We're Nikhil: I'm the kill. David: public defenders here to share the untold stories of the criminal justice system. Nikhil: Objection! That assumes there's justice in the system, which there ain't. I prefer calling it the American criminal system. David: Okay, stories from the American criminal system from the forbidden point of view. The one that the man doesn't want you to know about. Also known as the point of view of the defense. These stories are about Annie: Stories are David: the many not guilties we public defenders get on a daily basis in an unjust criminal system with the deck stacked against us. Okay. well welcome back to another Not Guilty. this my name's David. Nikhil: And I'm the kill. David: Today's episode, could be one of many, but we it's dedicated to the juvenile side of defense work. Nikhil, why don't you tell our listeners what the of juvenile side of defense work entails? It's called juvenile delinquency. Nikhil: So in at least in California, juveniles accused of crimes have the right to certain types of trials. It's not the same as adult court, but they have what we call adjudications and a judge decides if they're guilty or not guilty. And, both me and David have have spent some a good portion of our careers in juvenile work and it it remains very challenging for I'd say two reasons. One, the kids are very I guess prone to confession and manipulation by by law enforcement and school authorities. So they'll oftentimes say kinds of things that will prejudice their cases, l further down the way. But also because the person deciding their case is not a a member of their community, like a kid or even an adult. It is a judge who is very cynical and skeptical and usually I would say ninety nine percent of the time is gonna find them guilty no matter what defense you put on. So I I think it's one of the most challenging areas of loss because no matter how good of a defense you have, no matter You lose you David: Always lose. Nikhil: always lose, And so with that being said, we have another loser with us today. Let's welcome Annie, everybody. Annie David: Welcome to the show. Annie: Thank for having me. Nikhil: thank you for being on our show. So Annie, I I recently heard you had a loss, but something something surprising happened. Can you tell us a little bit about that? Annie: Sure. this was a g th I think actually this may have been my first trial in the juvenile court, if not the first one of the first, and it was handed off to me, meaning I didn't really have a lot of time with it before I had to go to trial, which was fine because in this particular case it wasn't super complicated. when I first read it, I just thought, Why are they prosecuting this child who's eleven years old? Nikhil: Well eleven that and that's unusual, right? Annie: That's that's on the lower end of the kids I've had a nine year old. and luckily there was a DA in that case who was like, I'm sorry, I just can't prosecute a nine year old and she dismissed it, but that's not common. but yeah, eleven eleven tends to be the youngest that we see. David: A fun fact about juvenile is the an element of the every crime is that the prosecutor has to prove the if they're under thirteen, right? Is that the Nikhil: Yes, under thirteen they have to David: prove that what they did that they knew what they did was wrong. Nikhil: And they usually prove that by some cops saying, Did you did your mom tell you that it was wrong to steal something? Yes. And then they're like, well you did know it was wrong and that's how they prove David: Was that bad? Was that bad? Nikhil: And what's what's an example of something right to do? Doing my homework. Yeah, it's pretty bad. Yeah. Annie: Yeah. Nikhil: okay, so but eleven year olds, very young, you had this case handled. Annie: Yes, so this case in a nutshell we lost it trial, but the exciting part was the delayed recognition we got from the Court of Appeal that overturned the decision that wasn't in our favor, which was pretty exciting even though it came so far after the petition being sustained. David: You forgot about the case, right? You moved on with your life. Annie: well, I actually I unfortunately would come across this kid in juvenile hall from time to time and but yeah, I moved on other cases David: Well so can you just tell us a little bit about the case that leading up to a trial? It got handed off to you, which means that someone in the office was was like, Hey, do this trial Annie: So this case is similar to a lot of the ones I had in the courthouse I was in, in which the kids that come in there didn't just steal a piece of candy and then, they got slapped on the wrist and they went on to their happy home. a lot of the kids that I would come across in juvenile court, it's like they started out life, behind the eight ball. So a lot of them were exposed in utero to drug use, a lot of them are abandoned early on, bounced around through foster homes, witnessed violence or sexual vic abuse victims. And so this particular kid was there was we didn't have confirmation, but there were pretty strong indications that he was exposed to drugs. While he was in utero, he was put under the adoption and foster system very early on and because of that and because he didn't ever get a stable living environment for any great length of time, he developed what's called reactive attachment disorder. Yes. he was a rad kid in the wrong way. Nikhil: Wow, so he was a rad kid. no, that's the it's like definitely this very study. It was like a phenomena studied in the early nineties at the end of the Soviet Union with a lot of these kids coming out of right eastern bloc countries with no parents, with a lot of intense social and behavioral issues because of of their up lack of stable home at at a young age. Annie: Right. I didn't have a lot of time to look into it, but it was a part of my argument when we were at the trial. but basically it's it goes down to the and I'm gonna not do the the disorder justice and trying to describe it, but basically as an example when a baby is crying and when it doesn't get its needs met, it doesn't get soothed or feel feel comforted, the sort of Pathways in its brain don't develop the way they're supposed to. And so it creates this disorder where the child doesn't trust easily, he can't manage his impulses and his negative reactions to behaviors. And so that was in my mind important in this case and in the defense because the court had to not just see the facts of this case. as this kid kicked and hit his mom. It was no, this was a kid suffering from rad who was just popped in the mouth so hard that he thought his nose was broken. And so you had to see it from his perspective, to really get the defense I was I was trying to argue to the court. David: So what happened so you hit he popped. Annie: So what happened? So this kid, he was eventually I don't know how long his I don't remember how long his parents had adopted him, but he was with an adopted family. And what had happened was mom was wanting the house cleaned. And he I think he had a sister, I don't know if she was adopted or as well, but Nikhil: It was an adoptive mom wanted. Annie: yes, adoptive mom and it was adoptive dad. mom was and I don't think dad was there. Mom wanted the house cleaned. and this, special needs kid wanted help and he kept asking mom, can you help me? Can you help me? And she was getting frustrated with him. And I think ultimately just said, Go to your room. And so he was sitting in there. I think he got frustrated and he called her some racial slurs on his way to his bedroom, which understandably pushed her buttons. And so she's probably now charging into his room to discipline him for saying those things. what had happened was he was on his bed and she said in her testimony that I wanted to pop him in the mouth. and she testified that with an open hand she kinda smacked him in the mouth. the child said no, it was a closed fist and my nose started bleeding immediately, not like a drip, but running onto the ground like a faucet. And he was crying and thought that she broke his nose. the heart of the incident came right at that point. she probably realizing that she hit him too hard, ran to go get something to clean up the blood. And he and his piz from his own Shoes and seeing what's going on is, wow, my adoptive mom, who I probably have trouble trusting, just smacked me in the face and broke my nose. she comes back at him to wipe the blood and he's like, Don't touch me, and he's like kicking at her. He's sitting on his bed, barefoot, kicking at her, trying to not let her come near him again. so that's part of the charge. And then that kind of back and forth goes on some more and he ends up swinging at her like with his hand. It hits her on the side of the face and I think knocks her glasses or breaks her glasses. And so that's the incident. And so Nikhil: So that's like the so that's like a the crux of the What and what do they charge? Annie: they charged him with a felony what David: Tony What? Annie: assault with a likelihood to produce great bodily injury. Nikhil: So the eleven year old they charged with eighty eight eighty sulf by I means likely to c create pretty David: Reduce great bodily injury. Nikhil: wow, so that's that's a pretty serious felony. Annie: It's a serious felony, yeah, for sure. And it's David: Did it say G B I also? Nikhil: They didn't alleged you. David: L L G B. Annie: No, they didn't allege it. David: Okay, so and then so just one count? And Annie: Just one camera. David: that's for the s the slap on the face or hitting him in the face. And Annie: Or the highest. David: just the everything combined? Ever just everything combined. Annie: I think it was more like the punch c 'cause she said that it knocked her glasses off. Nikhil: man, knocked your glasses off. I wear glasses and I'll tell you right now. The force that it takes to knock those glasses off my face. Woo. real quick, so and that wa and it wasn't charges it wasn't he was was he arrested for a different offense and then the DA chose to file it as a felony? I don't Annie: remember what he was arrested with, but just the rest of the facts, she then calls I think he runs out of his room and runs outside. He's found by the police hiding behind a bush crying, our, horrible perpetrator. And mom calls the police and tells the police that she wants him prosecuted. Nikhil: Wow, the mom calls after that, w calls the police after what she did, she wants him pro Annie: Right, right. When I first read the case I was like, Why aren't they prosecuting her? it was it was bizarre to me that the child was the one being prosecuted. David: Do you ever find out how long this child was had been with this adopted mother? Annie: I haven't seen the file in so long that I don't remember, but I know I did at the time. I think it was at least a few years. Nikhil: Okay, wow. Annie: but the bat there's a whole backstory that I discovered. I always got the sense that these parents, for lack of a better phrase, had adopters remorse. I feel like they adopted him, they wanted him to start, and then they didn't. It was like very clear in their body language and the things they would say that they didn't want this child anymore. And I feel like they were trying to do whatever they could to have him removed without them basically dropping him back off at DCFS. the father would constantly call probation and rat him out, so to speak, while his case was pending and even after, he did this, he did that, we can't We can't, handle him and of course he sat in custody the entire time, over a hundred days while this case was pending. David: So there was no current open DCFS case when he came in. Annie: I don't believe so. David: And he was arrested and in custody the whole time. Annie: the whole time. I tried to obviously explore release back home, but I the parents didn't make that very easy. Cause they would say he's out of control. And he probably does have behavioral problems because he has rad and they weren't educated on on that disorder and they weren't equipped to deal with his special needs. Nikhil: Which seems funny to me, these people are, generally I think the concept is if you're gonna be adopting you're this altruistic person. Right. Trying to provide a home for a child that's in need, but it seems like some like at least from my experience in juvenile, I felt like a lot of parents or adoptive parents I ran into were manipulative or only their own behavioral issues or had some other ulterior motive for adopting kids. Did you feel like they just were just ill equipped to deal with a rad kid and didn't want to learn about how to better handle him? Annie: My sense and it's just like a a gut feeling I had. It wasn't based on anything more than that. But I got the sense that they thought they were probably adopting some cute little boy that they could just have a quote, normal and by normal not a special need. Gotcha. Nikhil: Neurotypical. Annie: Yeah, little family, but someone with rat has very special needs it's not enough for the parents who have just read read up on it. there's a lot that they should have been prepared with and I feel like they bit off more than they could chew. And once they discovered what they had, they didn't want it anymore. and the the biggest confirmation I had of that was when after the trial, the only kind of bone the commissioner threw us was he reduced it from a felony to a misdemeanor when he sustained it. And he did release the minor back home and I r in cases like this where the kid was in for a while and we went through trial, I like to be outside the door when they're released to, give them a hug and and see them without dividers. and I was there when he was released and and every other case I've had like this, the parents can't hug the child fast enough. There's tears, there's excitement, it's just like a lot of emotion and when this child walked out of the door, I think the dad patted him on the shoulder and the mom didn't even extend her arms. It was the worst reception I'd ever seen. Nikhil: That's terrible. Annie: And I feel like they were just totally disappointed that he came back. Nikhil: Yeah. Do you think that that they they may have thought that this was it this was their opportunity to find this kid's no longer our problem anymore? Annie: Right, 'cause w in of course we were trying to work out some kind of a resolution before going to trial and and alleviate this kid have having spent, over three months in custody. Nikhil: about the the working out resolution and trial? What was the pre trial negotiations looking like? What did the DA want? What kind of punishment do they want? What kind of charge Annie: I I'm pretty sure that they weren't willing to change the charge, which was primarily why we went to trial, 'cause I wasn't going to have this little child admit to some felony, especially given the facts. Yeah, David: Did you ask the re for the reduction? maybe Annie: I asked for a misdemeanor. He really wanted suitable placement, which is a group home. David: The parents didn't want to go home. Or did they want to go home at all? Annie: They would say the right things. They would say, Of course we want him home, of course we want him back but then they wouldn't act in accordance, in a line with what they were saying and so David: Did they say like we want him back if he does X, Y, and Z? Cause I I feel like sometimes parents will be like, if well, if he starts behaving or if he starts doing Nikhil: If he knows how serious this is, he learned his lesson. Annie: They kept saying that they wanted services, they wanted help. And I was like, and I had a social worker helping me on the case and she was like, Well, DCFS will give you services and will give you assistance, but they had to voluntarily open a case, which means they'd have to admit there was an issue and they wouldn't do that. and just a part of trying to explore and be prepared for alternatives, we found there's a special suitable placement that's out of state, but they specialize in reactive attachment disorder. And so we and they have golden retrievers that they assign the kids with as a part of their therapy. And it was, what what I've pictured probably the best setting for him. And we found this great placement and I was gonna try and use that in bargaining to get a lower charge maybe for to have him go there. 'Cause he was excited about the dogs. So David: And they wouldn't or who was not why didn't that fall through Annie: The DA wouldn't budge. The DAs in this particular area charge as much as they can, as high as they can. They're very unreasonable. And juvenile court, is supposed to be a collaborative environment where everyone is trying to do the best for the child and that's not the setup. David: Do they take their DNA at age eleven also? Or Yes. 'Cause Annie: I think for any felony. David: I I always think it's messed up when juvenile when they just take these kids' DNA right when they're arrested, or even when they're convicted or Nikhil: I think it's only if their petition is sustained on a f quote unquote felony. But they also you're right, they in in juvenile they overcharge everything. There's so many cases in juvenile that we got that I was always like the even in in overcharging adult court, this wouldn't be a a a felony. This is definitely a misdemeanor in adult court. But I think they always want the exposure on the kids. They want all as much time that they can hang over their head. They want and they want that 'cause they feel like the consequences are so easily erased, I think the DAs think, that they think that, well then that's why we should give them the most serious charge that we can. okay, so tell us so then obviously your suitable placement strategy didn't work. David: Wait, did you go to their boss? 'Cause sometimes it's like you gotta go to their supervisor. Annie: I would I would, but they this was also a DA who wasn't particularly flexible and willing to I said, it wasn't collaborative. It was us versus them and it was like a total penal environment where it's like, this is a future criminal who did something wrong and we're gonna punish him. Nikhil: really? David: was was he new to juvenile? 'Cause when I did juvenile they c they always came in really hard, fresh out of their felony assignments and you always wanted to just hey, this is just a vacation. We're here just to rehabilitate these kids, relax, go ahead, dismiss a strike. just just chill out. it takes them about a couple of months of fighting and then they get tired and then they start submitting a little bit. Annie: well, yes, this the bench officer that heard this case was he was relatively new, he was a commissioner. he was a former defense attorney, so I I think thought in my mind, hey, he's gonna listen to my art Nikhil: Anybody's gonna listen to this. Annie: He's gonna listen, he's gonna find that this kid was, abused. He this was not him attacking his mother, but I I thought wrong. Nikhil: So tell us about the trial. Annie: So the the adjudication, Nikhil: Or a J. Annie: yes. So mother testified I don't think no, she didn't cry. Nikhil: I'm surprised she said w the most surprising thing I I heard she say so far that you've relayed to us is that she popped him in the mouth. I'm sure did you have some fun with that right there? That seems Annie: that that was her phrasing, I believe, was popped him in the mouth. I I tried to as much as possible, reiterate that she did this out of anger and frustration. No, and Nikhil: And not reasonable discipline. Annie: sh the DA should have probably stopped the proceeding and had counsel appointed to her so that she should have been advised not to admit leaving a mark, 'cause I think that's the distinction between abuse and discipline is if you leave a mark if you cause bleeding or some injury that that but of course the DA's not gonna prosecute their own witness. Nikhil: Of course not. They've they've picked they've picked a side in this case, right? And it's against the eleven year old evil genius, tyrannical, evildoer that he is. Annie: So yeah, it wasn't very complicated. So mom testified. She appeared, consistent with her demeanor before in that I just knew she didn't want him. and then the the officer testified and I really didn't get any traction with the bench officer when I was trying to show the BS well the the GLADIS R. David: If a juvenile is under the age of fourteen at the time of arrest, Enray Gladys R, a California Supreme Court case from nineteen seventy, requires that the prosecution prove that the juvenile knew their conduct was unlawful and wrong at the time they committed the alleged criminal act. Annie: The trying to have have him know right from wrong that, he knew what he was doing was wrong. And the judge cut me off and he didn't let me get into that much questioning because, the officer asks the questions like using adult lingo, do you wave your rights? I'm sorry, a child probably doesn't know the difference of, wave W A I V E and W A V E. And he's probably like, What is he asking me? and David: No, I I always had to explain that to my juvenile clients, like what it means to waive their rights. When you're waving your rights Nikhil: almost I w what's your experience, David? Did you say any of them really truly understood their admonition of their rights when they were David: That that was my f my favorite part of the whole being a juvenile defender was explaining their rights. and then and then you just start you start you can go to trial. Now you don't have to, but you can. And then, they they have to bring in the evidence. What's the evidence in this case? And they'd be like, Okay, I don't know, there is no video. well they can bring in eyewitness testimony. Did anybody see you driving the car? Yeah, who? The cop. All right, so then who has to come into court and say you drove the car? The cop does and Nikhil: But it just shows you how elementally different juvenile practice is, right? right and then these bench officers who should know better, right? they should understand that kids are different, their brains work different. This is an eleven year old, this is not some thirty year old man that we're we're holding to the standard of, being able to read and write, but yet they they cut you off. They don't Annie: Right. And this was not a child who had had, prior experience being arrested, being detained, or dealing with law enforcement. I'm pretty sure this was his first contact and kids are taught to admire police officers and to trust them. Nikhil: And to be forthcoming. Annie: Right. David: I think that's what's the worst part is these kids are abused. This kid's abused. He major emotional issues. And then the system's response is to lock him up and treat him like a criminal. Annie: And then when he doesn't behave in juvenile hall, we get these reports in court before trial, he's misbehaving. It was like, Yeah, what do you expect? You put him in a jail setting and he has special needs, he does not gonna know how to conform his behavior. Nikhil: Yeah. David: So your where your client testified too, right? Annie: He did. she's saying she hit you with an open hand, sh she's saying it wasn't that bad. you thought your nose was broken, that her fist was closed. I'm like open versus closed is a big deal, And I'm like, There's no other way for us to get that but David: What about all the blood? Did you ask the mother if she caused the cause the blood in your nose? Annie: Yeah, and what was I think super telling is that she made sure those clothes could not be found, that we couldn't see the bloodstains, that everything was either super cleaned up or discarded. David: Does she admit to throwing away the c the clothes? Annie: she she tried to just dodge. She's like, I don't know what happened. Nikhil: I don't know what happened to these bloody clouds. David: Did you sign a an S a subpoena deuces Ticum for the clothes? Annie: No. David: So you are you all right, so did you argue yourself? did you just say it should just be a misdemeanor or were you just trying to get it reduced to a misdemeanor? Annie: No, I was trying to get it to go away 'cause I thought this was total BS from the beginning. So after mom testified, I didn't feel like there was really enough to make the argument. Plus I thought if this little kid who has a slight speech impediment, gets up on the stand and testifies that the bench would see it would be more sympathetic and would see it from his shoes because, he's the only one that could tell that side of the story. David: So what's he saying then, in his testimony? Annie: so it was it was f fairly consistent with what his mom said it was. he admitted to saying the bad words and he, expressed remorse and David: But you asked him why he hit his mom, right? Annie: Right. And he said I was scared. He's like, I thought she was gonna hit me again. David: Okay. Annie: and we I really, tried to parse that out and ask it as many times as possible to reiterate his state of mind. And during the mother's testimony I had asked about his special needs and his disorder to get that into evidence so that I could argue like, Hey look, this is not your average kid who was popped in the mouth for discipline and then had a bad reaction. This is a kid who has trouble trusting, who has trouble controlling his behaviors and his reactions to certain things and that, him kicking and punching and a as a response is not the same as an average kid doing it. It's someone who's been traumatized, whose brain doesn't fire in the right way. David: What was the the prosecutor's closing argument? Annie: You in juvenile the DAs don't really put much effort into their closings. I feel like they kinda just go over a couple of points and and re summarize what what we heard. They don't really come up with arguments and that was that was true for this case. David: They don't. Annie: No, they don't have to because you're you're sitting in front of someone who pretty much sees everyone as guilty anyway. It's not like when you have a jury and you just need one person to be on your side, you only have the one and it's the one who's, already heard all the facts that they're supposed to artificially separate out of their mind and not consider but they're not an evidence. Nikhil: What's also funny, right, in Juvenile, I always think this is crazy, right? The same judge that we ask for release of our clients, right, is this person that's like, judge, can you please release my client based on the seriousness of the offense? And that judge is supposed to view everything that that's been alleged as true and then go, Mm, based on thinking everything is true, I think your client's too dangerous. And then, two weeks later, or in your case, maybe a couple months later, is supposed to like, All right, I know I've been thinking that this is all true for months, but I'm gonna pretend that none of it's true and I'm gonna be open minded to whether or not there's enough evidence I it's just it is literally this farcical system where we pretend like these judges no I don't think any human being is capable of clearing their mind like that and being objective. There's so much confirmation bias because to to to find your client not guilty would be then to go back and say, my decision to keep this client in custody 'cause he's dangerous was probably wrong. Right? so there's n never a an incentive or even a subconscious incentive to to find your client not guilty. David: I always found that when they would come in, the kid would be in custody, the parents want him to come home, it's his first time being arrested, he wants to come home and they're arguing, No, he has to be in it's no, no, it's too dangerous, too dangerous and then we come back two weeks later and probation recommends for them to go home and everyone's like, Okay, he can go home now. It's just he had to be in custody for two Nikhil: Because some bureaucrat interviewed mom and wrote it on a piece of paper. David: Numbers and something like that. We need the numbers in custody and sometimes I would even just mock the system, openly argue, Your Honor, we're i y we all know this is home on probation in two weeks. We all know that. It's it's gonna be home on probation. Let's just send him home now. What's the point? And then nope, he's gonna be in custody. For Annie: Right, that David: his own protection. Annie: that always irritated me when it's like, all the kid has to do is say admit and you'll let him go home and it's like what has changed about this dynamic in this home environment that now he said admit and magically it's okay to release him and luckily the David: Dangling cookies in front of him or carrot Annie: Well the I always had the bench officer would always say in response to that the well now services can be implemented. It's like, you mean in three weeks when the wait list is cleared? Nikhil: Yeah, it's like as if you're really gonna get them there. That first three weeks are gonna be tough, is really tough to get that that dynamic changed at all. And even then, how many parents have you seen been r resistant to to wraparound or any type of service coming in like this person's telling me how to raise my kid? And you're Yeah, because you have problem. Right? You wouldn't be in the criminal court system if you were just this amazing parent that could handle all these problems. so so what happened when you so closing arguments are done, the ki the petition is sustained. Annie: Right. So I was I was trying to argue not only that I presented enough evidence for a self defense claim, but that the DA did nothing to show beyond a reasonable doubt that that this wasn't self defense. Nikhil: Which is their obligation. Annie: Right. David: It's the DA has to prove it was not commit that the assault was committed not in self defense. Annie: Right, once I raise a little a little bit of evidence, enough to throw right to be like, Hey, maybe this is self defense, then the DA has to beyond a reasonable doubt say, No, this wasn't and I can't believe that that was over the bench officer's head. Like it to me, I'm like, you did this job. How do you not understand the dynamic here? And I'm like the DA offered nothing to refute our claim that this was self defense. And he the he tried to rest his decision on the distinction that the time between her, the mom, walking away to get paper towels to clean up the blood, somehow would diffuse the situation enough so that he couldn't therefore keep acting in self defense. Nikhil: yeah, so then it abates because there's some some time Annie: It's not imminent anymore. But I'm like, but this kid with this disorder is still crying, is still f fearful and freaked out and thinking she's gonna hit him when she's thinking I'm just gonna wipe the blood up but he was saying, Don't touch me, don't come near me Nikhil: Probably because this fifty year old man or whatever all he is, he's like I wouldn't be afraid of my mother eleven minutes out or two minutes after she hit me in the face. It's just like it's so funny, right? Because there's no real attempt to put yourself in the shoe of the victim or the defendant. It's just I don't think it's reasonable based on my position of privilege or or wealth, or even up here on the bench behind this robe. I wouldn't I wouldn't think like that. But it's like your life is so unlike any other any other person's. so then so then the case is sustained. Annie: Right. He did throw us that bone where he reduced the charge to a misdemeanor and then home on probation and then I think he wanted placement. Yeah, Nikhil: Nine month camp. Annie: I think he wanted placement. but the kid was released and then unfortunately there were subsequent probation violations and he ended up back in juvenile because his dad, like I said, was was really equipped to contact probation and send them information and evidence of his violations, throwing a tantrum at home, like what kids do. Nikhil: and then it's a probation condition. You must obey all all rules of your parents no matter what they say. Right. Yeah. ridiculous. Annie: Yeah. Nikhil: So there is a silver lining or a a positive ending to this this David: Annie, he lost. Annie: Yes, this was not a not guilty. Nikhil: no, but it right? David: So after you lose a case, then there's any paperwork you gotta do with your client? Annie: Right. So I filed an appeal. but unfortunately, it just takes forever to get assigned to appellate counsel for them to do their thing and then the court to actually get it and hear it and decide it. So David: Well appellate council gets it, they file a petition and then the government responds and then there's another brief like Annie: Yeah, there's several back and forths and then so I th it was probably a year and a half later, I get a call from the appellate attorney and she was really excited and she wanted to let me know that they reversed and I like, Really? I was like, That is pretty cool and I I couldn't believe it and she sent me the opinion and I checked it out and Nikhil: So what what was the what was the basis for the reversal? that's that that's very uncommon, right, in any criminal practice. Annie: Yeah, I think typically reversals are more on technical procedural points or or judicial errors and maybe not giving an instruction or something. But in this case the it was what I had mentioned about the the DA, that they didn't prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this wasn't self defense. David: So the appellate court said that this was a s a self defense claim or Annie: Yeah, that they didn't refute it. David: Which is which is hard to do because I guess the appellate court has to view the facts most favorable and f for the prosecution 'cause that's the way the judge decided. And they're just profiled saying the judge got it wrong. There's no evidence. Which is all never happens. Nikhil: it's one in a million was wrong on the facts essentially. Annie: Right. So w the a couple of things they pointed out was they didn't buy the whole this situation cooled off between the mom going to the bathroom for a couple of minutes and coming back. They were like, they pointed out that the kid testified he was still scared, he was still crying. He was found in a bush later by the police crying and scared. Mom, they said that, mom's testimony didn't contradict that. That the child and the mother's testimony, were fairly consistent and that, she was angry, she was frustrated, he was scared, he was crying. throughout the whole incident, the ability to make a self defense argument didn't dissipate in that time that the mother had gone to the bathroom and that, they saw it what I was trying to argue, from his perspective, he was still scared. He thought she was coming at him again. And they're like, the DA didn't do anything to show that that wasn't the case. David: Is this a published opinion or no? just a reversal. Court of appeals, just through the court of appeals Annie: you can find it in in Westlaw, but it says, not not citable. Nikhil: Got David: It just made its way to the Court of Appeals though, right? Right. Okay. Nikhil: So then also let me ask you this about that decision. Did you have any interaction with the commissioner after 'cause then the decision was a reversal. There's a remititor telling the judge to reverse the findings, the lower court direction. David: I'm still waiting for reversals on my juvenile cases. I check them out every once a month just to see if Nikhil: Did you have any interaction with the commissioner when that was case was reversed or Annie: No he wasn't there much longer before he went to a a different courthouse, salti far away. Uhhuh. and I hope someone told him about the decision. because I think it's one he should feel badly about, but David: Where was your client when the decision came out? Was he in camp? Was he Annie: He had placement un unfortunately, I think probably in due to the parents' proactive activities, a new case was filed against him. So I took that opportunity to file a an objection and get him out of that courthouse, which is highly punitive in nature compared to all the other juvenile courthouses in the county. I did. And then David: So you you papered. Just one juvenile court? Annie: there's two in that particular location and the judge that's there is worse than the commissioner. So Non stip to the other nearby courthouse which is much better. David: Under Civil Code Procedure 170.6, a party has a right to disqualify a judge to the case if the judge is prejudiced or biased. This is commonly known as papering a judge and can only be done one time by a party. For a commissioner to preside over a case, each party must agree or stipulate to it. Thus, for Annie to get the case out of the bad courthouse, she papered the judge in one courtroom and non-stipped or didn't agree to the commissioner in the other. Annie: And so a different public defender took the case from there on. So I told her as soon as I got the decision and she was super excited about it and she shared my sentiments about the parents. So I don't think I was wrong. Nikhil: Wow. Well congrats. David: Congratulations. Annie: Thank you. And luckily the bench officer who who replaced this commissioner was awesome. He's so good and he does what he's supposed to do. and by that he he's probably as close as a jury as you'll get in juvenile court. he gives the DAs a hard time when they overfile. He like for instance, I had a possession of a pocket knife at school and the DA's filed as a felony. And I was, making comments in open court like, give me a break, this is a foun th if this if this is not a misdemeanor, I don't I don't know what one would look like. And the commissioner echoed my sentiment and gave the DA a hard time. And he he's granted two of my seven eighty two motions, which is basically dismiss 'cause this is either not a crime or this is not someone who qualifies or needs rehabilitation. it's so minor. He I got a not guilty from him. Like he's a and Wow. Okay. Yeah. He's like a he's a good he's and he takes forever calling cases, but it's because he tries to talk to the kids and inspire them and motivate them. He gives them books. He like he's come out from the bench in his robe and walked over to shake a kid's hand. he's an awesome guy. So I think David: Do you think it makes a makes a difference at all? Annie: he does. I think he does. some Obviously, it's an addict, right? They have to want to change, but some of the kids really do get inspired by him. And the book he gives them is a book that really had a an effect on him and he passes it out to some of the kids that go to camp multiple times. What's that book? I'm blanking on it right now. it's Manchild in the Promised Land. David: Okay. Nikhil: All right. That's awesome. I I think with my experience I think that there are judges like people I feel like some judges get to the bench and they just kinda just the status quo is what they've seen before them, everybody else has done it like this. I've been an asshole, I'm gonna be an asshole to everybody that comes into my courtroom, give everybody a tough time but I truly feel like if you really wanna make a difference, there's a lot of opportunities and showing dignity to people and giving them just a modicum of respect, and saying, Hey, I care about you and my job is to to to oversee what's going on in your life right now and showing them that you really care. It it makes a I think especially with kids, yeah, that kernel implants maybe it doesn't implant right away or pay dividends right away, but later on in life you can say, Hey, this judge said something to me that the he cared about me and wanted me to change my life. Annie: And he tries to relate to them. He tries to tell them Look, man, I used to start fires. I used to steal stupid things and he would he tries to relate to them so they don't think that he's some lofty person they could never be. He like tries to get on their level and be like, I used to screw up. I used to, not have my head screwed on straight and a ten minute, five minute progress report might take thirty, forty minutes with him, but he's, You just sit there because he's really trying to help these kids get out of the system. so he's great. I was really happy to see him as the replacement. David: Yeah, do you wish we would have asked you about your not guilty in front of them? Annie: Nah. David: Anything else? Nikhil: No. Thank you for joining us, Annie. Really appreciated you being here. Annie: Yeah, it was my pleasure. David: Yes, Annie. It was great having you on today. Appreciate it. Thank you for coming.