speaker-0: Welcome to ANG from the Archives. For this episode, we've reached way back to where it all began. The very first episode. Back in time when Dave's editing skills were limited. I mean, who still uses Garage Band anyway? Without further ado, enjoy this week's vintage episode of Another Not Guilty. He had a moral and legal obligation to find out what the actual truth was before he prosecuted people for crimes. And y you know, asking him, Don't you wanna know what happened? Don't you wanna know the truth? to which he responded, That's not my job. She was abused by her husband previously, abused by her husband on the night of the incident, disrespected by the police officer, dragged to the station, arrested, breathalyzer, test, administer. When you're in the moment, you just I don't know, you never have faith. You never think it's gonna work out. This is why Juries are so important because everybody else is indoctrinated into the system somehow. They have a role to play and they're a repeat player. You know, to them, it's like another day at work. speaker-1: Welcome to Another Not Guilty. I'm David. I'm Nikhil. We're public defenders here to share the untold stories of the criminal justice system. Objection. That assumes there's justice in the system, which there ain't. I prefer calling it the American criminal system. Okay. Stories from the American criminal system from the forbidden point of view. Also known as the point of view of the defense. The one that the man doesn't want you to know about. These stories are about the many not guilties we public defenders get on a daily basis in an unjust Criminal system with the deck stacked against us. We got a defender with us today who has successfully won one of those cases, got himself a nice not guilty. Why don't you introduce yourself? speaker-0: ⁓ hello everybody. my name is John and I am a public defender. I'm here to tell a story about one particular trial that I had. speaker-1: Nice. So you gotta not guilty, huh? speaker-0: I did. All right. One. speaker-1: You've had several not guilties. I know. I you know, I've I've seen you around. I I know you got some good skills. ⁓ well so what was this case about? speaker-0: So this was a DUI case, which is a driving under the influence case, but i that's not really what it was about. In this particular case, my client was a woman who was pulled over by law enforcement ⁓ late at night after calling nine one for law enforcement to respond to the scene. And the reason That she had called 911 is because during her 911 call, she reported being the victim of domestic violence at the hands of her boyfriend. As she's calling 911 for help, her boyfriend, who was previously in the car with her, leaves the scene. And by the time the ⁓ law enforcement agent gets there, ⁓ my client is the only person left, at which point, ⁓ ultimately She is arrested for driving under the influence because she is sitting in the driver's seat of a car at the time that ⁓ the law enforcement officer gets there. So speaker-1: So hold on. So the when sh when the law enforcement officer gets there, is the vehicle stopped or speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. I will ⁓ I'll back up a little bit. Okay. So what happened was ⁓ she was in the passenger seat of her car and her boyfriend was in the passenger seat of the car, or excuse me, the driver's seat of the car. And so they were driving together and there were some things that had happened previously in the night. ⁓ based on the information I had at the time, ⁓ what it looked like was her boyfriend was out at a house late night partying. She came to the house, ⁓ potentially unannounced, and he did not know that she was gonna be there, which he found very upsetting for whatever reason. So at that point in time, ⁓ he becomes physical with her, drags her to the car, throws her in the passenger seat and starts to drive away. ⁓ it it that's what you would think, right? Right. So as they're in the car together, ⁓ she is understandably distraught and she calls nine one one. speaker-1: Sounds like a kidnapping to me. speaker-0: after, you know, having some amount of physical interaction with her boyfriend in the car. So as she's calling 911, he freaks out and ⁓ pulls the car over to the side of the road, jumps out and runs away. She climbs over the center divide of the car, gets in the driver's seat, stays on the phone with 911 and starts just driving in circles around the block, waiting for the police to arrive. And when the police arrive, ⁓ she's Frantic, which is reflected in the 911 call. You know, when in the call you can hear her kind of crying and screaming and ⁓ exhibiting various emotions, you know, in a in a in a heightened state. Basically, when the police get there, call it's a domestic violence call. She's calling the police to say, My boyfriend is has hit me, I need help. ⁓ and the nine one one operator is talking to her, saying, Where are you? And she freely admits that she's in the car. And the nine one one operator is saying, ⁓ You know, we need you to stop, stop moving so the police can find you. And she is driving relatively slowly in a circle around the block. And the nine one one call ends with her saying, I see the police, I see the police, they're here. speaker-1: Was she like, Thank God, thank God the police are here. I speaker-0: I I d I don't remember if it was like that. speaker-1: My heroes are here. I'm a victim of domestic violence. I was just kidnapped. Thank you for coming through nine one one. speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. So I guess the policy is for the 911 operator to stay on stay on the call until the police make contact. So the call is like seven minutes long or something like that. And there's various pauses and silences. ⁓ some of it's incoherent. ⁓ but it sounds, you know, it it sounds very genuine. You know, she's saying how she's been struck and then kind of fluctuating back and forth, ⁓ at certain points saying how much she cares about. speaker-1: Until the actual policemate comes. So very typical like psychological profile of someone who's been abused who has like a you know, they love their spouse or partner and correct and been abused by them and is conf you know, just confronting that that conflict or that dilemma of this person who I love has physically abused me. speaker-0: Yeah. So sh she gets the nine one one operator on the line, the kind of heat of the moment, calls for immediate assistance, doesn't know what to do, and then as the call progresses, you you you you you can hear her emotions kind of fluctuate back and forth. She never hangs up or anything, she stays on the line, but ⁓ you know, she's she's saying, you know, I love him, but you know, this is what just happened in the moment. speaker-1: So the police show up. Mm-hmm. she gives him a description of the assailant and then the police go after him. ⁓ speaker-0: no. So speaker-1: I mean it's seven minutes away, so he's just walking somewhere, right? Or speaker-0: The police make contact with my client. ⁓ an officer arrives and my client stops, admittedly is is in the car and the car is in motion and ⁓ pulls over when when the police are there. The officer gets out. My client ⁓ you know there's two different descriptions. You know, according to my client, she gives, you know, a a detailed description of what's taken place. According to the police officer, she is difficult to understand in the moment. ⁓ police officer would later testify that, you know, she seemed ⁓ frantic and she seemed ⁓ excited or upset, you know, that she was crying. ⁓ none of that was in dispute. But ⁓ so the officer, I guess at a certain point, you know, is having a conversation with her and then does something which, you know, I think everybody can can imagine taking place in in various contexts, just kind of stops the conversation that's going on and says, Ma'am, have you been drinking? And so kinda cuts off my client, you know, mid sentence when she's explaining this scenario, ⁓ and says, you know, have you been drinking? And so to which my client, who ⁓ admittedly has been, but not to a a crazy amount or anything like that, ⁓ you know, kind of says, like, yeah, you know, I had something to drink, but that that's not really the point, you know. ⁓ I'm trying to I'm trying to talk to you about something else right now. ⁓ and then, you know, the cop kind of doubles down and says, you know, at that point, ⁓ You once there's been an admission, if you're in the driver's seat of vehicle and you say you've had anything to drink, you know, a police officer will kinda go into an automated mode at that point a lot of the time and become robots? Yeah, exactly. Have you been drinking? Yes. I'd like you to come with me. I need you to do some tests. And so that's the end. At which point my client essentially completely shuts off and Yeah. And so at that point she says, No, you know, but I I'm not doing your tests. What what are you talking about? That's I why would I ever have to do that? You're here to help me. I called you and now you want me to put my finger on my nose. Absolutely not. Yeah. So speaker-1: And wait and just so I guess from my own edification, I mean kidnap is a felony offense, right? I mean that's kind of a that's a charge that if if they found this guy who ran out of the car and, you know, and these allegations were true. I mean, this guy is facing prison time for what's strike. That's a strike, right? I mean this guy I mean that's a serious offense. This is not just some you know, some you know, drunken lovers quarrel where there's maybe, you know, some mutual pushing and shoving. ⁓ kidnapping is a very serious offense. We dedicate a lot of resources to going after people like that. speaker-0: That's what you would think if you were to compare the, you know, relative moral wrongdoing between a just over the legal limit drunk driving offense and a kidnapping offense, I think the natural assumption would be that ⁓ the law enforcement agencies would prioritize the kidnapping. Yes. But unfortunately that's not what happened here. So speaker-1: Let me ask you this, why did you end up with the case? How did you get the case? speaker-0: So that's an interesting s ⁓ question and I think also plays into everything that's going on here. ⁓ I got the case actually after it was a couple months into the proceedings. So essentially another attorney had been handling the case up until that point in time. ⁓ at which point, ⁓ you know, I wasn't present for any of those hearings or court dates or anything like that. But that attorney discovered at a certain point that they had represented the boyfriend on a separate criminal matter in the past, which created a conflict of interest for them because they could not represent both the boyfriend and the girlfriend who was my now was going to become my client. So her case ⁓ was passed on to me, kind of given to a fresh attorney who had had no prior experience working with the boyfriend in the past. And at that point, ⁓ you know, I inquired of the other attorney, like, I know you represented this person, but, you know, what are they ⁓ you know, w what was the case that you had with them, you know, what's going on, because it might be relevant in the future if this person comes in to testify, you know, you you need to know about their backgrounds. And as it turned out, when you ran ⁓ the boyfriend's name in the court computer system, ⁓ the case that he was previously represented on by that attorney was in fact a domestic, a felony, domestic violence complaint where my client was the complaining witness or victim. So not only has my client now told the story to the police on the night she was arrested for DUI that she was being abused by this person, but about two years prior to that, ⁓ he had actually been formally arrested and charged with domestic violence ⁓ perpetrated against her, the the very same victim. speaker-1: It's my understanding, let me ask you this, that usually when someone is a victim of domestic violence and there's like a conviction ⁓ that a restraining order is issued. So in this case, ⁓ was there a valid restraining order ⁓ keeping ⁓ the boyfriend away from your client at the time of ⁓ speaker-0: Right, there was not. In fairness, there was not. So what had happened with the prior case was that at some point in the prosecution had ⁓ announced unable to proceed on that case. And that's all the information I have, ⁓ because that's all that was provided in the court minute order or court docket. So he really con He was not convicted. He was arrested, he was charged, it was scheduled for a what's called a preliminary hearing. speaker-1: Victed then. speaker-0: And on the day of the preliminary hearing, ⁓ the case was dismissed by the prosecution and the reason stated was that they were unable to proceed with the prosecution for whatever reason they deemed on that day. speaker-1: Got it. So ⁓ you got the case and then ⁓ so tell us what like the I mean, leading up to why this case went to trial, what were the plea negotiations like? What were you looking for? What was your client? speaker-0: Right. So ⁓ understandably, you know, after speaking with my client, she wasn't looking for anything other than a dismissal ⁓ and an apology for putting her through ⁓ what she went through, which consisted of being subjected to a ⁓ you know, a breathalyzer test, arrested, put in jail for about two or three nights, and having to pay bail to get out again. So ⁓ I sort of explained my situation to the district attorney and ⁓ the the The major complication in the ⁓ case was that the police officer's report, ⁓ which led to the filing of the DUI charge by the district attorney's office was just so incredibly bare of relevant facts from the evening that negotiating with the district attorney was was very difficult because they they read the police report and they take it as true and In the police report there was no mention of a boyfriend, there was no mention that my client had ⁓ a given a name or a description. Or call well they had to concede that she called nine one one because ⁓ speaker-1: Called nine one one. the description of the police report for the nine one the dispatch call. speaker-0: The dispatch call was domestic violence. speaker-1: And just just like kind of like a ⁓ more summary, not detailed. She called we responded to a dispatch call of domestic violence and then I arrested this woman for D UI. Yeah. speaker-0: Yeah, so it just gave like a one line at the top that was I responded to such and such area on such and such date and time because there was a report of domestic violence. ⁓ and then it just immediately jumped into ⁓ upon contacting the person who is identified as the caller, I made the determination that they had been ⁓ consuming alcohol while driving a vehicle and then just launches into the driving under the influence. speaker-1: So robot talk a lot of robot talk here. Robot talk, yeah. Yeah. speaker-0: Very boilerplate. Just no no d complete failure to, you know, acknowledge anything that might the context. So it was actually a really long and drawn out process with the prosecutor's office to try to figure this out because ⁓ sort of my first move was to ⁓ go to the prosecutor and say, ⁓ you know, here is my client's version of what happened, you know, in a very bareborne ⁓ bare bone format and I gave them the name of the boyfriend and I told them at this point in time that I was requesting any criminal background information on the boyfriend to see if he did in fact have any other convictions that I didn't know about, any other instances of domestic violence. ⁓ and at that point the district attorney just turned to me and said no. And I was c confused at this point in time and I was like, wait, you know, w what do you mean no? And they said to me that They only had a legal obligation to provide me with the background information on potential witnesses or actual witnesses in the case. And I said, Well, right. Well he was present on the night that all this happened, so he's a potential witness, to which they said, That's your version of the events. My police officer never even wrote down his name, so I'm choosing to believe my police officer's version of events and I'm not calling him as a witness, so I don't have to give you any of his information. about his prior criminal proceedings or prosecution for domestic violence or anything of the sort. But as a starting point in negotiations, ⁓ that was not the best beginning to ⁓ you know, what we thought were fair negotiations and a fair outcome for the case. speaker-1: So you're trying to be reasonable. I I I I always feel like, man, if they just you know, they just see that the person's innocent or speaker-0: I would like to think so. Yeah. And I especially thought th at that point in time I was like, ⁓ we have this prior ⁓ instance of alleged domestic violence where this person was arrested and the the district attorney's office themselves had filed a criminal charge against him. So they must have at at least at one point in time found some validity to that claim. So, you know, talking with the DA now, who, you know, didn't know anything about the prior incident, was not involved with that, but talking to him now and saying, Look, y your office filed this charge. Like you you're aware that this happened and to which his response was well like I don't know. I personally don't know anything about it. And I'm and I'm refusing to look into it because I don't plan on calling that person as a witness so I don't have to tell you anything about it. speaker-1: It seems to like the major shortcoming, I think, in of Brady evidence, right? Is that we give so much authority to the prosecutor to determine like what's exculpatory, how to how they have to determine what's exculpatory, when they have to give it to us. Like so basically, I mean, this prosecutor can stick his head in the sand and goes, ⁓ I don't think your defense is exculpatory 'cause it's it's not in my police report, so I don't have to give you any evidence. Exculpatory evidence is evidence that tends to show that the accused or defendant is innocent of the charged crime. Under Brady versus Maryland in nineteen sixty three, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that the prosecution and police are required to turn over such evidence to the defense. speaker-0: And and it put me in a really, you know, awkward position at that point in time because in my mind I felt as if I then had to prove the existence of this human being, you know, the boyfriend. I I had to prove to the DA that he was a real person who existed, who had a prior allegation of domestic violence, and you know, they have the resources to look into this, but the the burden sort of fell to me and because the police officer had also failed to even mention his name or description of him. Which my client was telling me she absolutely positively gave to the police officer on that night and said here, you know, he actually I d you know, I've been I've been misstating the entire time. He was her husband, so they were legally married. ⁓ wow. ⁓ and so, you know, this is a a formalized relationship where there would be, you know, court documentation of their relationship with one another. You know, they've they've signed a certificate, they've in fact been to court over, you know, certain things about the relationship in the past. And so I was just kind of flabbergasted that ⁓ you know, he prosecutor didn't seem inclined to even you know look into this and and absent from any absent any you know obligation to turn over exculpatory evidence, which, you know, I would say does exist, ⁓ it just seemed like ⁓ like like just be ⁓ someone being purposefully obtuse. And so I we you know, the the first day we kinda talked about it or maybe it was a second or third court appearance, it just it just ended in a shouting match between me and him essentially in the middle of the courtroom. Where he was explaining to me how it wasn't his legal obligation to turn over these things and I was in turn responding that he had a moral and legal obligation to find out what the actual truth was before he prosecuted people for crimes and y you know, asking him, Don't you want to know what happened? Don't you wanna know the truth? to which he responded, That's not my job. speaker-1: I mean they are h held to a higher ethical standard than defence attorneys, right? speaker-0: ⁓ th I I mean the the jobs are different. They have a different job, you know, in their speaker-1: Why do you think he was being such a dick? speaker-0: You know, I I think it's one of these problems where the relationship between the police and the prosecutor is so sacred, you know, they have to re remain on such good terms with each other, ⁓ that the ability of the prosecutor to question anything that a police officer has written in a report is is ⁓ severely limited is what I would say. Because speaker-1: Blasphemy. speaker-0: Yeah, because they can't you know, these are the people that they rely on to come into court and to testify on their behalf and if you ruin that relationship somehow or you accuse them of, you know, at at worst, you know, at the very least what you have here is a police officer who is exhibiting some kind of indifference, you know, just a a complete indifference to their job, to their moral obligations. ⁓ at worst you have someone who's actively falsifying a police report by omission. speaker-1: Material omission. Yeah. I mean it's not just like I add a small detail. It's I'm not including this because I want you to burn for D UI. speaker-0: Material omission. Yeah. My client's entire defense and statements to the police officer from that evening were omitted from the report. So it depends how you look at it. You know, did she make something up? That's not true. No, she reported facts. You know, my client had had something to drink. She gave her a breathalyzer test. The breathalyzer test ⁓ gave a result of a point one zero percentage of alcohol, which the legal limit is point zero eight. ⁓ she was driving a car. So There was that, but then, you know, never mentioning at all any of the reasons why she happened to be driving the car on that evening, which to me did seem fully around the block. Yeah. speaker-1: While kidnapping, speaker-0: Yeah, while while driving around the block while on the phone with nine one one and not disconnecting the nine one one call until the police officer actually arrived. So speaker-1: So all right, so you you've you've realized that you're not gonna get anywhere with the with the district attorney. ⁓ so this case is gonna go to trial, right? So what are you doing to prep for trial? speaker-0: So I mean this is ⁓ so now as I was saying before, I was in this kind of awkward situation where I felt like I had to pr I had to validate my client's story to the district attorney, right? Because he's he's come to me and he said, I think you're essentially he's saying to me, I'm trusting my police officer who would have recorded all of the important information and didn't, therefore what your client is saying must not be true. So because the police officer didn't write anything in the report. You know, the DA is operating under the assumption that my client has not has ⁓ made up this imaginary husband who ⁓ was with her on the night abusing her. So speaker-1: DA lives in a world where everybody's happy and go lucky, there's this this battle of good versus evil, the police are good. And everything that a defense attorney or a defendant claims must immediately always be looked with suspicion and skepticism. speaker-0: Even Yeah, kinda like of course she would say something like that. ⁓ you know, she's trying to get out of a DUI. Okay. So and she can't dispute the fact that there was alcohol in her bloodstream or that she was driving. You know, those are undisputed. So she's making up this excuse to try to weasel her way out of it is essentially what he's saying. So I, you know, these people are married, right? So my client obviously has his name and his contact information and she knows where he lives and how to get in touch with him. So now I'm in this awkward position where I have to reach out to him. To ask him about how he abused my client on the night of her DUI so that I can provide this information to the district attorney to ⁓ at at the very least let him know that, you know, I'm not lying to him, to prove to him that I'm not lying to him, that my client isn't lying to me. So of course, as you could imagine, when you try to contact somebody and ask them to admit to committing domestic violence, they're understandably hesitant to do so. So so as it turns out, we actually were able to get in touch with him and and one of the ⁓ investigators who was working for me, ⁓ found him and he gave a somewhat mixed statement, right? He says, like, yeah, I was there, yeah, you know, I was with her, but I didn't hit her, which is, you know, what what you would expect him to say. So he said kind of some good things and some things that ⁓ you know, w weren't as my client was portraying them. speaker-1: He corroborated it though. He's at least at the scene. You put him at the scene. speaker-0: Yeah, so he says he actually says that ⁓ he admits that they were in the car together, he admits that he was driving, he admits that they were fighting, but he then says as I was driving the car, ⁓ my client, the woman, was slapping him, so he decided to pull the car over and get out and leave the scene. And he says that he stood in the middle of the road, like the median, there's a median divider in the middle of the road, and he says he stood in the medium of the road about twenty feet away and watched my client get arrested for DUI. That was his statement. So then so then I I I the statement is recorded, it's written out. ⁓ I give it to the prosecutor and I'm kind of like, see, here, you know, here you go. Here's your, you know, smoking gun, if you will. Like I've proved that this is a real life human being with a date of birth and an address and a phone number. And he has even gone so far as to corroborate that he was present at the scene on the night my client was arrested. Thereby proving that your police officer was negligent in their duties and failed to record his presence or at least record ⁓ my client's statement that he was present. ⁓ to which the district attorney says, Well, he says he didn't hit her. So I don't care if he was present, ⁓ I still think your client is lying about him hitting her 'cause he in fact says the opposite that she was striking him. So, you know, once again, you know speaker-1: This Allison Wonderline is like you failed to prove to me because this person didn't admit to beating his wife that it must have not happened because of course he would have admitted it. speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. And the sort of the most at this point in time, the most egregious thing to me is that, you know, if you ever talk to a prosecutor or somebody who works for law enforcement in, you know, like a ⁓ a domestic violence unit of any kind, they'll they'll talk to you day and night about the habitual nature of these events. Right. When you have two people who are in a relationship and one of them is abusive towards the other, it's never a single event. That's you know, they'll they'll talk all day about the cycle of violence and how it's never a single event. And here we have an instance where this person has while not a conviction, a prior arrest for domestic violence, a new allegation of domestic. Felony domestic violence. Felony domestic violence. A new allegation of domestic violence and a nine one one call where, like we talked about before, the person calling is speaking in terms that like any prosecutor normally would be capable of understanding, which is simultaneously asking for help while excusing the behavior of the offender ⁓ and exhibiting remorse for for the defender, you know, irrational remorse somehow. So I I was just kind of struck by how ⁓ obtuse they were being yeah. Just their failure to accept the things that most of the time they're more than willing to talk to me about. You know, when when I'm representing a client who's accused of domestic violence and the tables are turned, you know, they they'll tell me about this stuff all day long as if it's the gospel. speaker-1: What do you mean? What why do you think that there's just like this double speak? Why is the prosecutor when your client's accused of domestic violence, then we subscribe to these theories of, you know, the cycle of violence and how, you know, they're corroborative, nine one one calls. And then when you're when you're trying to use it in your defense of your client, but then it's dismissed. Why why do you think that there's that double speak from the prosecution? speaker-0: You know, I I think it's just once the prosecutor files a charge, they have a really hard time letting go of it. It's like a freight train. It's like a dog that's got their teeth on a bone and they don't want to let go of it, ⁓ you know, because they don't want to undo what their colleagues have done. So essentially, at least in the courthouse that I work in, you have a system where one district attorney will file a charge. speaker-1: Take a freight train. speaker-0: And another district attorney will actually be the person in charge of prosecuting it, of taking it to trial if it goes to trial and of working up the case. So all the time when you go to talk to them, they will say things to you, which I find kind of amazing, ⁓ because it's not rooted in like law or morals or logic, logic or ethics. They'll just say to you, I I just can't step on my colleagues' toes. speaker-1: So I mean the system seems to be compartmentalized to to encourage this lack of confrontation between them, like saying, you know, one DA to another DA, Hey, I think you made a mistake, they or even to the cops or whatever, that just will compartmentalize this so much that, you know, everybody's unwillingness to to confront somebody with you made a mistake or y you know, you're unethical son of a bitch. Right, like then because we're all trying to play so nicely and get along, you know, the defendants are screwed up. speaker-0: Especially in an instant like this where I think, you know, in the jurisdiction where I practice, most of the time the district attorney who is prosecuting a misdemeanor DUI case, which is what this is, is gonna be one of the ⁓ level lower level attorneys. Yeah. So the person who's filed the charge is more senior to them. The person who is supervising them is more senior to them, obviously, and they don't want to be They don't wanna be the DA who goes to their boss and asks for a reduction or dismissal. That's speaker-1: They wouldn't wanna be that fish swimming against the school. They don't wanna appear soft. They don't wanna appear like they have compassion. speaker-0: Well, they don't want to go to the they don't want to go to their boss who in all likelihood has risen through the ranks to become a supervisor because they tough on crime. Yeah, they have a tough on crime stance and they have ⁓ earned a reputation as somebody who gets convictions or something to that effect. And when you're a a a newer employee, I think it's your worst fear over concerns for your own job security and your own professional development. You know, it's your worst fear to go even if you believe that something should be done, it's your worst fear to go to your boss and say, I want to dismiss this case because if they disagree with you at that point in time, you know, your upward mobility within the department is is is squashed, or at least that's what they're afraid of happening. speaker-1: So let's get back to the We have two political we have two political ⁓ crimes here. DUI versus domestic violence. ⁓ How'd it go? Who won? Or is there any more leading up to trial you want to share? speaker-0: Well, ⁓ Yeah, I'll share a little bit more. ⁓ I'm not sure I'd use I'm not sure I'd say anybody won here. I think everybody came out a little bit worse at the end of it. But ⁓ but yeah, so ⁓ Yeah, exactly. But ⁓ so th my my pretrial negotiations with the district attorney kinda carry on for a couple weeks, you know, of arguing back and forth and me being upset and them refusing to budge. ⁓ and eventually at a certain point ⁓ I don't know, I guess I speaker-1: Good day in the criminal justice. ⁓ speaker-0: perhaps wore them down to to some extent and the district attorney handling the case comes back to me and says, Okay, okay, I've I've talked to my boss and I think we can figure this out. And I'm like, Okay, great. They're gonna dismiss the case. It took a couple months, but we finally got through to them with this and, you know, they're gonna dismiss the case. And so I'm talking to the district attorney and she says, I've talked to my supervisor and we're willing to let your client plea to a wet reckless With DUI terms. speaker-2: This speaker-0: And so, you know, th to my client, you know, this is yeah, which is not a real thing. You know, if you're my client and you're in the position of, you know, you you're you feel as if you're being wrongfully prosecuted for a crime you didn't commit or, you know, reaching out to the police for help in a time of turmoil and they've turned on you and now you And you went to jail and you went to jail. speaker-1: Which speaker-2: You- you were- speaker-0: Exactly. So my c you know, i I'm I have a legal obligation to tell my client what the offer is so that they can make an educated decision about what they would like to do. If I don't tell my client the offer, I'm not doing my job. So I tell my client the offer, ⁓ to which she like understandably, you know, lays in to me about how that's not an offer and how she wants to go to trial. speaker-1: A DUI or ⁓ a wet is still ⁓ you ⁓ still have to do the alcohol program, you still two points on your driver's license. It's literally everything the same except for semantic difference of ninety days ⁓ maximum exposure. speaker-0: There are some minor differences. There are some minor benefits, but if you're coming from the position that my client was coming from, you know, there's no difference. You know, you're still being prosecuted, you still get a criminal charge on your record. It still has the ability to mess up your employment prospects and your life generally. So you know, to which point ⁓ you know, at which point we just say no, you know, that's y w I guess we just have to go to trial. So this is how we ended up going to trial. And so At the trial, ⁓ and there was one other thing, I'm not sure if it's even important to mention here, but there's one other thing. ⁓ we actually had a hearing prior to trial to make a determination about whether the police officer had ⁓ withheld information ⁓ from us and ⁓ we lost, which I anticipated because ⁓ you know, the the standard for things like that is that the police or the prosecution have to consciously withhold. You know, they have to be aware that they have something that defense needs and they have to choose not to give it to them. And the the judge was actually sort of sympathetic and he after the officer was done testifying and left the courtroom said that he wasn't gonna agree with me and he wasn't gonna, you know, dismiss the case on those grounds or anything close to it, but he just made an off hand comment at the end that it would appear that the officer was highly negligent in her duties, but unfortunately, negligence is not the standard. I mean speaker-1: But it's again I'm sorry, but so you had a hearing before the trial. To argue that the case should be dismissed because the officer probably didn't what record the name of the witness? speaker-0: Right. Correct. So the officer, my argument at that point in time was that the officer, ⁓ going back to what we said before about an inability to collect evidence at a later date, you know, my argument to the court was that the officer at that point in time had an obligation when responding to a domestic violence nine one one call to at at least acknowledge at some point during her investigation that she was there for domestic violence. You know, to at least speaker-1: Investigate domestic violence. speaker-0: write in the report what my client was saying and then talk about why it was unfounded or untrue and why she moved on to a DUI investigation, which was absent up until that point in time. I sort of just did that to make a point in many ways. You know, but this is when I was still trying to negotiate with the DA, so I kind of wanted them to see, you know, firsthand, 'cause a lot of the time they don't even talk to the officers, they just read the written report and they won't follow up and they'll just say, Well, this is what it says in the report and they don't even bother to contact the witnesses until they arrive to testify. speaker-1: This is a motion you calendared before the trial. Okay, so the trial it still hasn't even been sent out for trial. Okay, so now you're doing a motion to dismiss. Uh-huh. You bring in the officer so the DA can hear how horrible this officer is. speaker-0: Has not been sent out for trial. Correct. Yeah. To which the judge says, you know, I'm not getting rid of the case that's in overstepping my boundaries in this particular instance, but it would appear that the officer has been highly negligent in their response to this call for service. speaker-1: The judge's chicken shit basically. Yeah. You know, won't won't go ahead and do what's right. So you basically put out clear case and they hide behind some legal semantics that ⁓ it doesn't rise to the level. Because what off just like you know, what officer's gonna get up there and say, ⁓ you know what? I did consciously hide evidence from the defense because I was more concerned with the DUI than I was with the domestic violence offense. Really? Like it's never gonna that you're never gonna get that magical piece of evidence. speaker-0: The amount of evidence you need to win that motion is ⁓ absurd. Functionally unobtainable. Yeah. speaker-1: Okay. So it's just like it's just like the your defense witness ⁓ admitting to your investigator that he beat your client. Yeah. Like it's just like unattainable like like that. speaker-0: Yeah. So I guess it you know, when viewed in the best of terms, you could you could maybe say that the judge was leaning on the prosecutor at that point in time. Yeah. So he's not gonna do it but, you know, maybe winking at the prosecutor, hinting at them that if they wanted to do it, you know, he'd probably be okay. Yeah. He he wouldn't argue over it. So ⁓ under the most generous terms, that's that's what I could assume. speaker-1: You're being so kind. Yeah, thank you, thank you. I I I don't have kind words for this judge, but I mean I'm I'm glad you speaker-0: I don't know. I don't know. So it's so then it goes so it goes to trial. The crux of my argument to the judge at that point in time is that if this case goes to trial, it's no secret here that I'm gonna be arguing that my client was under some form of duress or was acting under some necessity when she drove the car, which would excuse her legally. speaker-1: The rest is a threat of harm made to compel someone to do something against their will or judgment. Necessity, a defense that permits a person to act in a criminal manner when an emergency situation not of the person's own creation compels the person to act in a criminal manner to avoid greater harm from occurring. speaker-0: Right. And so to prove that she was under that duress or exhibiting or like under that necessity, ⁓ we need to show that sh what was you know, that she was being abused, like she says she was being. One way to do this would be to perhaps have pictures of her physical state from the night when this took place, which is another thing that the officer neglected to do. ⁓ you know, the trial goes about according you know, like h how you would imagine it would. So the police officer testifies that, you know, gets up and testifies that at the time she was there, she didn't notice any indications of domestic violence. She didn't see anybody else on scene. ⁓ you know, she even said some sort of like half hearted stuff about how ⁓ she looked around the block, you know, turned her head and didn't see anybody and determined that my client was not being truthful and moved on to her D UI investigation. ⁓ she she looked up and down the block. She didn't see anybody speaker-1: What? Means ⁓ yeah you're calling mistakes. She called out, Hey, anybody perpetrate domestic violence, please step forward. speaker-0: Lord. Yeah. And so i I asked it during that point, you know, did you call for backup? Did you make a perimeter? Did you, you know, did you broadcast the name of the individual? And if not why, did you broadcast a description of the individual and if not why? And so she said, ⁓ you know, she explained that away by just saying, ⁓ no one ever gave me that information, so I couldn't tell anybody. speaker-1: ⁓ so she now she's claiming that so she gets up on the stand and she lies, basically. Well did she contradict her testimony from the motion? speaker-0: No, no, no. Her testimony was consistent. Her testimony was you know, was relatively consistent, either saying I couldn't understand what the woman was telling me or she didn't tell me that. So, ⁓ you know, essentially ⁓ disavowing the fact that she had information that she did then did not choose to use. And so we go to trial and you know, the cop says what the cop is gonna say. My client gets up and tells, you know. a story about, like we were talking about in the beginning, basically a recounting of the entire night and gets to talk about how ⁓ you know the night began and how the domestic violence began and where she was and how she was in the passenger seat first. and you know the f the funny thing is is that you know normally the the district attorney did not play the 911 call so during their case. So the district attorney presents their case first and they just asked the cop, you know, did you respond? And then, you know, the answer was y yes. And what did you respond to? I'd responded to a domestic violence call. But then when my client testified, we chose to play the entire call, which is, you know, seven minutes of hysterics essentially about this event. And so speaker-1: It must have went over real well with the jury, I'm sure. speaker-0: I w I would assume so, yeah. ⁓ because it was you know, it's a live recording of what's taking place in the moment. So there's no time to fabricate fabricate, there's no time to make things up, you know, you're just getting someone's emotions as they're coming. And it was pretty clear from the call that those were, you know, real or raw emotions. speaker-1: Did prosecutor try to limit the plane of the nine one one call? speaker-0: No, no. No. I mean, you know, f for what it's worth, the prosecutors kinda let the chips fall where they may. ⁓ you know, she argued her case, she objected to me sometimes, but ⁓ for the most part, pretty much everything came out. ⁓ and so my client testified. ⁓ the husband, boyfriend did not testify. He did not make it to court, surprisingly enough. ⁓ really? Yeah, yeah. It was shocking, I know. ⁓ we we yeah, he didn't he did not come. speaker-1: Can I ask you a question? Yeah, yeah. So ⁓ prior to the trial starting, what was ⁓ what was jury selection like? Was the D U the DA doing the typical DUI voidier? speaker-0: Yeah, the DA was almost it was interesting to watch because it was you know, like I I you know, in my mind leading up to this point, you know, we had been very hardline, you know, saying we just want a dismissal, we want a dismissal. And, you know, in my mind I was like, they, you know, of c y I don't what how are you gonna I I didn't know how they were gonna explain that away, right? Like how they were gonna you know, my client was seemingly a very sympathetic defendant and there would seemingly be proof to this effect via the nine one one call. So I didn't know how they were going to try to explain that away. and they, you know, as it turned out, they didn't try to explain it away. They just flat out ignored it. ⁓ didn't in void here, they didn't address it. They got up and talked about how this was a domestic violence incident. They stuck to the police officer's report, right? So they they just said a police officer responded. speaker-1: Yeah, for the trick. What about your Vladir? Did you bring up domestic violence or what did you bring up? speaker-0: I it's funny 'cause we we definitely just came at at it from two different angles, right? So it was almost like having two prosecutors because she was prosecuting a DUI case and I was prosecuting a domestic violence case. So she did her DUI void to see who would be good in a DUI trial and I got up and I imagine, you know, had some overlap at the very least with what a prosecutor would normally do in a domestic violence trial, where they were actually trying to prosecute for domestic violence. So it's Sort of trying to find people who'd be sympathetic to ⁓ a woman in my client's circumstances. speaker-1: So that was your case. You just put your client up and then I won one call. speaker-0: Right. Yeah. I mean it was interesting 'cause I essentially ignored everything they did because we were conceding the blood alcohol level and conceding the fact that my client drove. So there's really nothing to say about those things. ⁓ speaker-1: Did they you're kinda doing F S Cs, filtered sobriety test? speaker-0: No, she was so mad at the police officer that ⁓ she refused to do them. So she told the she you know, at that point in time when she was first getting arrested, like saw what was happening, was it you know, like, ⁓ my god, this is really turning around on me, what is going on? ⁓ you know, she flat out flat out refused. speaker-1: You mean to say that after being kidnapped and abused by her husband, she didn't want to voluntarily agree to count backwards or touch her nose six times? My nose is bruised, officer. I can't it's bleeding. I can't really touch it right now. Okay, so then it went to the case into argument. So did the did the did the prosecutor ignore Your necessity slash duress ⁓ defense argument. Let's first ask I mean, did you get the ⁓ did you ask the judge for the necessity and duress instruction? I 'cause that was your defense and obviously she was been the victim and been kidnapped. So she testified, I'm sure, to the elements of those defenses. So there was evidence of that actually happening and so speaker-0: Did ask, yes. Real eviden there was real evidence via my client's testimony. And I won't wanna call. speaker-1: And then one call you know, and as much as we want to complain about the prosecution and their hard line stance and they can't dismiss a case, this and that, I mean, that's why we have judges for checks and balances. speaker-0: Right, yeah, because they're neutral arbitrators. And the district attorneys, you know, they are interested in the pursuit of justice, but occasionally, you know, they don't necessarily ⁓ have that as their foremost priority. speaker-1: Wow, you are very being very kind to ⁓ certain certain stakeholders in the speaker-0: I I would you know, I'll say they're you know, the way they behave in court I think varies from their mission statement. Their mission statement is the pursuit of justice, but ⁓ due to various incentives, structural incentives, ⁓ I don't think that's what always happens. So good thing we have a judge, right? Right. Yeah. So the judge denied the duress instruction. Shut up. Yeah. speaker-1: After after the pretrial motion is dismissed, where you clearly made it c I mean, obvious that you were gonna go with this defense, you're opening your d ⁓ defense evidence you were not allowed to argue, huh? Okay. speaker-0: I was I was very clear, you know, it was very open. Uhhuh. You know, 'cause I to me ⁓ in this instance there's no sense hiding the ball. There's no strategic advantage to no you know, like a a sneak attack or anything like that. Everybody knew what was going on at all times almost. speaker-1: Okay, I'm I'm sorry, I'm incredulous. ⁓ what on what basis was this instruction left out? speaker-0: So the judge denied the instruction, right? So there's, you know, ⁓ unfortunately I'm forgetting the exact language of the instruction. There's I think seven six or seven elements that you need. And the judge ⁓ told me and told my client, told everybody that ⁓ you know, ⁓ in order to grant the duress instruction, essentially you have to have no other available options to you other than breaking the law to protect yourself from physical harm. Okay. Right. So I was like, Yeah, I know, that's my client had to run away. So she got in the car and ran away. This is what I'm thinking in my mind. Yeah. But in the judge's mind, things were working a little bit differently. So the judge said, My client did not have to drive the car. She could have locked the doors and sat in the car, or she could have also got out of the car and run in the opposite direction of her husband's. On foot. On foot. speaker-1: Okay. Yeah. In this neighborhood at night and kidnapped. speaker-0: In in this is this is a random neighborhood. There's no you know, she the car is pulled off of the freeway onto the first intersection off the freeway, at which point this guy bails and runs away. So she's still out there. According to his statement, he is watching my client interact with the police officer from the median behind the bushes or something. speaker-1: He's also still out there. But and but you the judge thinks that she c the alternative would be just to flee on foot. speaker-0: Well, there's also no evidence of that because my client did not know where he was specifically, like was not in his sight line, right? Or he was not in her sight. speaker-1: ⁓ that's what I mean. I mean this guy's out there somewhere. speaker-0: Out there, yeah. Lurking. speaker-1: Okay, hold on. So but from a legal point, and this is I guess for our legal listeners, isn't that issue something to be decided by the jury if that was accurate or not? The trier of fact facts. A trier of fact or finder of fact is a person or group of persons, usually a jury, who determines facts in the legal proceeding, usually a trial. To determine a fact is to decide from the evidence whether something existed or some event occurred. So isn't that really like There's some evidence of it and if the j jury wants to reject that argument and say, Hey, she could have ran away or if she she could have locked the doors, then that's for them to make a decision. speaker-0: Yeah. I mean you would hope, right? Right. speaker-1: I mean that's what it sounds like to me. I'm just a lawyer, you know. So if the judge denies your duress instruction, does that mean you can argue duress as your defence to the jury? speaker-0: No, it means you're you are legally prohibited from arguing duress. So the jury is not going to receive that instruction. So the jury is not going to be ⁓ at the end of the trial, the judge reads all of the necessary instructions to the jury kind of like a ⁓ a how-to on doing your job. You know, the lawyers have finished their cases, they've finished their closings. I'm gonna tell you how the law works, and then you're gonna go back into the deliberation room and make your decision. speaker-1: You're speaker-0: So, you know, I was hoping that the judge would give this instruction saying, you know, when somebody is under duress, it's possible 'cause it's not a definite, like you were saying, ⁓ the judge would give them instruction that it's possible for them to find a duress excuse here. ⁓ and so it's not directing them that that's what happened or anything of that nature. It's saying here are the seven elements, like if you find all seven of these you may find that the defendant is not guilty for reason of of duress. speaker-1: Siemso speaker-0: Well it's kind of an interesting like that's why I said in the beginning we were ⁓ very out in the open about it, because you need to in order to have the instruction granted, you need to provide evidence that all of the elements are present. ⁓ what I mean is you have to talk about it during the trial. Basically, yeah. Yeah. So we had to you know, we were up front with the judge and we said, Essentially, you know, you know, ⁓ because the p one of the things the prosecutor did object to was some of the speaker-1: Some evidence. speaker-0: background information, right? Like what happened in the car before the police got there, you know, that's not relevant to the DUI. ⁓ what happened at the house where my client met her boyfriend, that's not relevant to the DUI. So at that point in time, the district attorney was trying to exclude all that elements and just saying, you know, we need to look at this at a moment in time. It's a DUI. We only need to talk about the elements of the DUI. To which I had to then say, but we will be seeking a duress instruction. So here's why all this was relevant. So the judge allowed it to come in. you know, kind of pending her decision because she had to hear the evidence herself. And then at the end of the day, ⁓ said, I'm not giving that instruction. So at that point in time I was a little deflated and I was like, you know, we've argued with the DA, we've argued with the cop, we've argued with the judge. And, you know, just nobody is is cutting us any slack here. No one's cutting us a break. And now I can't even argue to the jury, you know, what I have been hoping to do the entire time. speaker-1: So you don't get to argue. So what do you get to say? I mean, I I'll be real, if I was in your shoes, I would just be standing up there, ⁓ kind of just being like, please don't vote guilty for my client. speaker-0: Yeah, 'cause he's 'cause we've conceded she's drunk by the legal in terms of the legal limit. Yeah. She was driving, in terms of every definition of driving. And so I yeah, I was. I was I speaker-1: Yeah. argue that the punch to the face ⁓ that sort of affected the the breathalyzer or speaker-0: Could have, I could have. I should have. But ⁓ yeah, so I'm just kinda I'm just I I'm in my head, you know, my wheels are turning and I'm like grasping at straws here. I've organized my whole closing, like assuming that I would get this instruction and I'm gonna point out to the jury why all sell seven elements are present. And so then I'm just reading the instruction for the DUI again, you know, kinda like trying to trigger something, you know, think of anything that I can argue. And, you know, ⁓ essentially what I ended up saying to the jury was Why would she have done this? You know, like 'cause for every crime you have to intend to do it. There's a basic intent, you know, requirement. ⁓ and so you have to have, you know, like bad thoughts. You have to choose to do a criminal act. So essentially what I just argued to the jury was highlighting that one word and saying, you know Willful? Yeah, willful. Willful. That she willfully did this, you know, that she intended to do this, and asking, you know, d and asking them like, is that what happened? You know, w do you think she woke up in the morning or left the house and decided that this is what she was going to do with her evening? And at every step of the way, you know, every second of the hours preceding the event, you know, there's no way she could have possibly decided to do this. She was dragged along. You know, she she literally, you know, this is not a figurative statement. She was literally dragged along. So how could you? Yeah. speaker-1: Force into a car. Wait, and d I mean, I'll be real. I mean, I feel like I've tried to argue this before and I feel like some sharper DAs would object and say it's kinda outside the purview of what what willful actually means and Yeah. Maybe a judge might cut you off too, but did they just let you speaker-0: Argue that? They just let me talk. And so at this point, you know I'm also kind of fuming because I'm like, I've been denied every request I've made throughout this entire process. So I'm just gonna try to harp on the human elements of this event and pray that somebody on the jury is feeling sympathetic. And as it turns out, ⁓ they were feeling sympathetic. speaker-1: How long did it take how long was the the ⁓ deliberation? speaker-0: ⁓ it was somewhere between like five and ten minutes. No. Yeah. Yeah. So speaker-1: Wow. Did you when it buzzed that fast, did you think it was did you feel like it was gonna not guilty? speaker-0: At the end of the day, you know, when the courtroom was about to close and I went back to my s I walked out of the courtroom after, you know, the judge put the jury in the deliberation room and gave them their instructions. I walked down to my office and when I got to my office I got a phone call to come back up. With because the jury had a verdict. So I think as a defense attorney, you're always assuming the worst, you know, and you you're scared for your client and you feel, you know, you're you're upset like they're upset and you know, you You're just apprehensive. You know, you want to do well for your client and you're worried that people don't see what you want them to or don't agree with you somehow. And so that's how I was feeling at the time. And then, you know, in in retrospect, you know, i you know, now I look back on it and I'm like, Yeah, of course. Like, how are they ever gonna convict this poor woman? This poor woman who talked about how she was abused by her husband previously, abused by her husband on the night of the incident, disrespected by the police officer, dragged to the station, arrested. breathalyze or test administered. You know, of course, of course, you know, like the people are gonna find something wrong with this. But when you're in the moment, you just I don't know, you never have faith. You never think it's gonna work out that way. 'Cause everybody you've been dealing with up to that point speaker-1: Had had no faith and was trying to cut you off at every moment. speaker-0: Every you forget, you know, and this is why juries are so important, because everybody else is indoctrinated into the system somehow. They have a role to play and they're a a repeat player. You know, to them it's like another day at work. And you forget when you get twelve people who aren't exposed to this kind of stuff on a regular basis that they're gonna look at it with a fresh lens and, you know, it's out of it's it's just amazing to me that, you know, for twelve people who heard the facts from both sides that, you know, it was a relatively easy decision when It had taken months and months of arguing and negotiation to get the district attorney to offer a wet reckless. So it was a happy ending, sort of. And the reason I said before is that nobody wins is because the judge assessed trial costs, which means that my despite the fact that my client got it not guilty, she was required to pay twelve hundred dollars to the court for the privilege of having a trial. Privilege of proving her own innocence. Yeah. And then at the end, you know, the the the funniest thing to me, not funniest, saddest thing to me is that the district attorney who who tried the case came up to me, I forget if it was like that, I think it was the next day, you know, 'cause we we work together and we see each other somewhat normal regularly, ⁓ came up to me and said something to the effect of, Can I be honest with you? I think that was the right decision. Sometimes you just have to let a jury hear a case. You know? To which I, you know, I thought, no, you don't. You you could have dismissed it. No y the your whole role is you get speaker-1: Yeah. You're the prosecutor. speaker-0: You are a filter to what reaches the jury. I can't dismiss cases. I don't have that ability as a defense attorney. You as the prosecutor decide what to prosecute and what to dismiss, what's worth it and what isn't. That statement at the end, you know, just a total dereliction of your duties. Just a complete misunderstanding of what you're actually there to do. Because I would never agree with the fact that innocent people should be required to go to a jury to prove their innocence. You know. speaker-1: You think there are some checks and balances as we were talking about earlier that would help prevent both the from like I mean, even from like a purely economic perspective, right? Like why are we wasting so much time and effort when the evidence that she was innocent was pretty apparent? I mean. speaker-0: There are some instances where where there's a gray area where there are conflicting stories, you know, and to me this was not one of them. This one seemed pretty clear cut from the get go and it seemed like a an unwillingness to to think, to critically think about what had taken place. Or care, yeah, right. Like 'cause what happens, you know you know, you still argue the district attorney still argued to the jury for a conviction. And what if they do? You know, would you feel bad afterward? I I don't know. I don't know. speaker-1: Or just care. They don't care. Alright, well good job, John. That that was victory for justice. Make us defenders proud. speaker-0: Thanks, you know. A victory. A small victory. Thank you. Thank you guys. speaker-1: Thanks for tuning in to this week's episode of Another Not Guilty. Shout out to Daniel Mark, original ANG theme music composer, and Mike Grimm for the remix. And guess what? We'll be back in two weeks with another Not Guilty straight from the ch- speaker-0: Trenches.