SAM: Boom and we are live. Welcome back to the Self -Builders podcast. I'm your host Sam Taylor with me as always is. Mike: It's Mike Paulie. ⁓ no, sorry. I thought Andrew was going to tap in then. Do you know what I was just thinking? Every episode starts with a boom. It's a boom, we're live. SAM: Like, you got snappy with that, like, yeah, I'm like, here we go, yeah. It does. It's a boomer live. Wait, I can't change that. That's the way it is. Today, really, really pleased to invite on our guest, Andy Howes. Andy's on his self built journey at the moment. Andy, how's it going? Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: Yeah, pretty good. We're getting towards the end, so we're pretty happy. Pretty happy. SAM: see the light at the end of the tunnel eh? That's why he's got a smile on his face. Good man, good man. Mike: Are you in yet Andy? Are you in yet? Andy Howes: We are not in, we'll be ⁓ in ⁓ in about five weeks if everything goes to plan. So we should be in about five weeks, yeah. Mike: in for Christmas. Andy Howes: Well, my wife's giving birth in two months, so we better be in five weeks. So ⁓ we ⁓ kind of have to be in, so we're getting there. Mike: Congratulations! Wow! SAM: Congratulations. Mike: Sit down, I'll run on you. SAM: I mean, yeah, I was going to say there's ways of putting a deadline on and then there's ways of putting a deadline on and you've gone hard on that Andy. I like it. I like your style. Excellent. Andy, we always kick these things off with trying to paint a picture for our listeners. OK, what we want is for for our guests to be able to paint a picture, show us a little bit about what this house is going to look like, what this dream home is going to look like for you. So I don't know if you want ⁓ to ⁓ maybe tell us a little bit about our own square footage. Andy Howes: I ⁓ don't know. SAM: location roughly you know is it near a river is it a forest is it a main street whatever the case may be but paint yourself build for us Andy. Andy Howes: Yeah, so we're building in Seven Oaks. We purchased the plot from somebody who was selling off their garden. They spent about a year doing some of the kind ⁓ of ⁓ early surveys, trying to think about whether or not they ⁓ wanted to actually do it, but they opted just to take the money and run, but not very far. So we bought the plot from them. And I would say it's a pretty good size plot. The house is about 100 square meters each floor. Mike: Okay. Next song. Andy Howes: So we have two floors, so 200 square meters. And then at the last minute, we decided to convert the loft. So it's about 300 square meters. So that added some additional cost in at the end. It's timber frame, brick cladding. So to all extents and purposes, you probably wouldn't know it's timber frame, because it doesn't look like that on the inside or the outside. But nice traditional red brick, clay tiles. Yeah, and it looks, it's looking pretty good at the moment. Mike: Nice. Well, if we're on it, Andy, we'll get to construction in a bit, I suppose. But what made you build Timberframe? Because most of our customers at Mayflower will use a Timberframe system or more modern methods. I just find it interesting why everyone sort of tends to opt for that we work with. Andy Howes: Yeah, I think speed really, I mean, you know, by the, you know, your frame goes up in a couple of weeks and at that point you can kind of start looking at the inside, sizing up the inside and get your brickwork going. And actually when your windows are in, really you're kind of watertight to a certain extent and your roof's on. You get going a lot quicker. That's our experience anyway. I don't necessarily know if it's any cheaper, but I think from a speed perspective, it definitely helps things. Mike: Do you think from the risk point of view as well as a self -builder maybe, and I'm assuming you're not in the trade and done one of these before, that it potentially sort of de -risks a little bit of that shell construction because it's off -site or no, not. Andy Howes: Yeah, I mean, we have done one before, so this is our second timber frame. I would say it depends on the quality of your timber framer. We had a gold standard for our first one. We needed to save a little bit on this one and it caused some problems. It was constructed well off site. They lived pretty far away. So we paid, I think we paid a bit of a price. Unless your timber frame is perfect, you're going to pay for it down the line. So. Mike: Okay. Interesting. Go on, let's start unpacking that for us, because that would be a top tip potentially for people listening. SAM: Jump in. Andy Howes: Yeah, so our timber framer did it came in 20k cheaper than the one we wanted to go with. So it was kind of a no brainer for us. ⁓ They ⁓ came from Somerset, so they'd leave at about three or four in the morning, get onto site and pretty much be as keen to leave as quickly as possible. I genuinely think they were pretty good timber framers, but I think their specialty was the timber frame. It was raining, you know, the weather was awful. Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: So I think you just wrap everything in one. You've got to be so precise. And when you've got a big house with a timber frame, if you're 10 mil off at the start and you're a hundred mil off at the end and you brick it, you've got your cavity, which is obviously a very fixed depth. If you're just off by a little bit, by the time you get to the end of that run of brick work, you've got all sorts of problems. So ⁓ if I was to do it again, I'd probably would have gone with the more expensive one, just. Mike: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Gone. Yeah. Andy Howes: because we probably ended up paying that in terms of getting joiners in to fix some of the doors that are a little bit off to get brickies that were having all these sorts of problems. And then we probably didn't, you know, we probably ended up losing that 20 overall. Mike: Interesting. So did you guys from, I'll stick on the construction piece because I'll find this interesting. Did you got, are you sort of overseeing it as the PM if you like Andy, or have you got somebody in who's sort of overseeing it for you? Andy Howes: Yeah. So PM, PM sub it all out. PM the whole thing. Yeah. Start to finish. Mike: We did a podcast the other week, didn't we, Sam? And Reese ⁓ basically said that he would recommend a PM for someone that hasn't done one before. Obviously, you've done one before. Did you have a PM on the last one, or were you overseeing it as the PM, if you like? Is that why you've done it? Andy Howes: Yeah, so my father -in -law has been a civil engineer for about 40 years and they've built a few houses. So they were there kind of holding our hand on the first one. And then this one, a lot, a lot more removed. ⁓ so we pretty much could kick on and we did a lot of the first one. We didn't do as much when I had some back problems and wife was obviously not in a position to, so we kind of knew. Mike: Okay. Andy Howes: we could provide that quality check a lot better than the first one because it was all fresh eyes. I mean, it was like alien concepts to us. But for this one, we kind of can kick on and create the end to end project plan from day one pretty much because we know what happens. Mike: Yeah. Yeah. SAM: Tell us about the plot Andy, just rewind a little bit. Did you, did you, did, yeah, tell us about the journey around finding a plot. What, how did you do that? Andy Howes: Yeah, so I mean, I'm probably not allowed to say the name of the website, but it was just a website where it came through. You know, there's a couple of main ones out there, which most people probably signed up to, but it came through ⁓ and ⁓ yeah, it was plot finder. ⁓ There's a great website came through. We went and had a, we went to have a look naturally pretty dubious going into these things, but it ticked all the boxes. Pretty much check the planning. That's always the first thing you've got to do. Are there any Mike: I mean, we can shout out, are we gonna get done for copyright? I don't think... Okay. Yeah. Andy Howes: significant restrictions on the planning that are going to impact the build, like moving sewers for example, something like that. And then, yeah, took a, put a little deposit, spoke to the neighbour, went out for like a drink and said to them, look, can we give you a little deposit to take it off the market? And then spent nine torturous months getting the self -build mortgage in place. So. Mike: I'm drunk. Wow, nine months to get your mortgage agreed. Andy Howes: Yeah, it was like peak kind of housing and then ⁓ kind ⁓ of COVID -y, then they pulled the last minutes, we had to go back through the process to start again. So it was at Underwriters and they pulled it and then we had to go all the way back through to start again. Mike: ⁓ was it COVID? Okay. There was a period during the COVID time that pretty much every lender pulled their proposition. And they only, lenders were only keeping offers in play that were already at legal offer. So I think we had 63 customers that we had to either pen completely, or there was the few that were still available that we could place. Andy Howes: Hmm. Hmm. Mike: Thankfully that's over with, like the ⁓ COVID days. How did the COVID affect the actual bill cost, Andy? Andy Howes: Yeah. Yeah, say that again, sorry. Mike: How did the COVID and the material prices impact you guys, if you were building over that period? Andy Howes: I mean, material prices probably doubled since we built the first house. I wouldn't say labor's gone up ⁓ hugely, but I would say that the minimum labor price has gone up. So whereas before you might get a day laborer pretty cheap, for anyone to get out of bed these days, I would say is higher than it was before. So your overall labor costs, if you're doing your brick work, I wouldn't say had gone up massively. But if you're getting people to do day rates here and there, then it gets more expensive for sure. Mike: So the plot when you guys found it, went onto plot finder, ⁓ had planning already. Andy Howes: Had planning, yeah. Yeah. Got new, got new, we got new planning, which is part of the reason the mortgage was difficult as well, because they'll only give you a mortgage on the actual plans you want to use. So we had to put new plans in, get them approved. And then, no, before they even put it through to offer and underwriters. So your, the biggest part of the mortgage acceptance process was completely held up. We needed the actual plans that we were going to use. Yeah. Mike: ⁓ before they release any funds, yeah. Yeah. Did you guys go bigger, Andy, or were you going smaller than the original plan? Andy Howes: We didn't go big. We didn't, we were quite lucky because a few houses down precedent had been set for a massive house. So we knew what we could work with. We knew what height we could work with and we knew what we could probably get away with. We also knew the neighbors really didn't mind that much. So we were kind of in a fairly strong position. We kind of knew we were going to get it. So we thought it was worth taking advantage of it really. Mike: not. So I assume the plot finding, that bit sounds relatively straightforward for you guys. Andy Howes: Yeah, straightforward, I guess. It's a balance, isn't it? It's when you're working with somebody who's selling off their garden, you get a bit more of a personal approach, but then you have to work pretty hard to keep them on board and to help them understand your months behind schedule. Don't put it back on the market. We promise we're going to come good. So it was really, I mean, I would say to a certain extent, it was as stressful as the build has been because at any point they could have just pulled the plug. Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: and it was hard getting a mortgage. It's not as easy as it was before. There's a lot more checks. They're a lot more thorough. The cost of living had taken your affordability down a ⁓ lot. ⁓ Certainly made it much more difficult for us, I think. Mike: Yeah. Did you, when you applied Andy, were you in the sort of the rate increase time period where, you know, Bank of England was going up every month, every sort of, every review, or were you sort of prior to that? Andy Howes: ⁓ Yeah, ⁓ kind of. It was, it was, our affordability was always changing. ⁓ So ⁓ you ⁓ never quite knew how much you could borrow and we were right on the limit of what we wanted. We had to really be quite economical with the, with the build costs. And I mean, I did a very thorough justification for all of them, but they came in, I think just under a thousand pounds a square meter, which is way below what the average cost is these days. But there was a lot of paviat in terms of. Mike: Yeah, yeah, that would have Yeah. 2000 Andy Howes: I'm just doing these costs to get the kitchen and the bathroom in to sign it off versus actually... Mike: Yeah, okay. Yeah, it was a tough time. So as a bit of a side note, this would be, it's interesting to get feedback. We've started doing a free costing service for customers, like a fully quantified schedule from start to ⁓ finish. Would it, from someone who's done two, is that handy? Cause we're making the assumption that that is really handy to have. Like it's a hundred page quantified schedule of all your materials and labor, ⁓ or not really. Andy Howes: Mm -hmm. Yeah, I mean, for me, having the specific goal I had to work towards and I'd done it before I could do it, I could do it. I actually think for people that ⁓ are ⁓ doing it for the first time or maybe they're not as they, you know, their mortgage, they've got a bit more flex in it. It's definitely a really useful service because it comes under a lot of scrutiny. So there was a lot of people I had to convince ⁓ that it would work. Yeah. Mike: Yeah. Massively. Particularly at 1000 man a square metre, I think we ⁓ would, I'm probably confident, the guys will probably tell me that I'm wrong, the brokers, but I'm pretty confident we wouldn't be able to place that anymore at 1000 man a square metre. It's just too low. Andy Howes: Now, ⁓ I ⁓ think we just about got it through. There was loads of caveats in terms of this, this, this, this, and this ⁓ just about scraped through. SAM: Sure. Mike: interested in. Who is your lender? Just out of interest. Andy Howes: ⁓ Dudley? Dudley. Mike: Okay, okay, interesting. So design was already done when the... Sorry Sam. SAM: So, good. That's exactly where I was going. I was like, yeah, I wonder what the design actually like. Yeah, yeah. Talk to us about the design and any sort of challenges you had around that. Was there any changes that you had to make or things that you had to compromise on that you would have rather not? Any lessons from the first one that you did to the second? Andy Howes: Yes, so for the first one, we never really changed the plans. So we made some internal changes which didn't really need to go back through planning. But for this one, we did need to change sizes. So we were in a little bit of a difficult position that architects, we didn't really want an architect to go the whole hog and create something for their portfolio. But a draftsman wasn't really able to like visualize some of the changes we were making. So we ended up using my wife's brother who was an architect. He actually came in and kind of made the final set of plans. We probably could have got the final set of plans done by a draftsman, but you really need that final set of plans to ⁓ be ⁓ watertight. You ⁓ know, ⁓ so it ties in with your brick work levels, so it ties in with where your windows and doors are gonna go. Because those are the plans that go out to everybody. It goes out for quotes, it goes out for your timber frame designs, it goes out for window sizing. So. Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: It's a really difficult area sometimes when you don't want to onboard an architect to do the whole thing end to end, but a draftsman also is maybe not the right person because it's not a back extension. Mike: Do you think having your brother -in -law who was the architect gave you that happy medium, whereas others who maybe might not have that personal connection would be that potentially could be a hurdle where you're in that grey ground? Andy Howes: Yeah, I think so. I think, ⁓ again, we were, we were quite lucky. We were quite lucky as well because again, we know about tying in brick sizes. We know about window sizes and stuff. So we, we could kind of fill in some of the gaps, but I also think, ⁓ you know, there's a lot of architects out there who've been in the industry for a long time that actually haven't done a self build end to end. I have some friends and has been working on a proposal in Richmond for a multi -billion dollar project, fully qualified architect, but actually didn't have the confidence to do end -to -end building regs, planning of a self -build, which kind of blew my mind, but it kind of just shows that it is a kind of a different ball game to your standard architecture or whatever that is. Mike: different. Interesting. So construction wise then, did you guys, I assume because you built timber frame before you were adamant that's the route you wanted to go down ⁓ because of the success of the first one. Andy Howes: Yeah, timber frame was on the table from the start. We had a lot of problems with the foundations. So we did, we did, we did in chalk last time. That was our first build. Foundations were about, I don't know, half a meter. They were, they were really, really shallow. ⁓ we were in clay this time and then our, we had some challenges with our building control. I won't say who they are, but we had some challenges where ⁓ I ⁓ think there was a Hawthorn tree that had about a five centimeter diameter trunk. Mike: ⁓ Yeah. ⁓ Yeah. Andy Howes: I think it was about two and a half meters away, and he made us go three meters down into the clay ⁓ in ⁓ August, which was a very wet August, as you can imagine. So they kind of collapsed a couple of times. We ended up having to get people in to put hoarding up and shuttering, and then we ended up doing a block and beam floor in the end. But actually, I think we should have done a block and beam from the start, and we should have just got a structural engineering from the start. SAM: Yeah. Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: It's difficult finding that balance with what we've done the first time because it was a slab. It was super easy. The foundation was so shallow. Yeah, it was a real... Mike: So if there's ⁓ anyone ⁓ else doing it then, it sounds like ground conditions are like if someone who's never done it before, should they ⁓ be ⁓ on point when it comes to ground conditions? Andy Howes: Yeah, I mean, getting out of the ground is where you can make or break your budget. Didn't break ours, fortunately, because like I say, civil engineer in the family, so it helps offset, you know, bringing ⁓ in a groundworks team that would cost you an arm and a leg. But I think getting in a groundworks team early and understanding that and really ⁓ working out what is the best thing for your site is going to save you a lot of money in the long term. Mike: Yeah. at you. So you had the timber frame manufacturer come in and erect, because I know you said you had a few issues with the timber frame system. Did they come in, they did the erection, and then you guys managed sort of subcontractors for ⁓ the skin, fit out, windows, et cetera. Andy Howes: Yeah, they did ⁓ design ⁓ an erection. They did loads of other stuff. Maybe it wasn't their strength. So I think in hindsight that was, you know, because they'd done such a, you know, it looked like a pretty good job on the timber frame. We brought them into other bits like soffits, facias, all frames, you know, just kind of other, you know, various bits, which we ended up pairing back and, you know, at the end of it. ⁓ So yeah, they kind of came in and did, you know, Mike: Okay, yeah. Andy Howes: most of it, but got a timber frame up for us, yeah. Mike: and then subcontract. SAM: What made you add ⁓ on ⁓ the third floor of the attic to take it from 200 to 300? What was the thinking behind that? Andy Howes: Yeah, well, I mean, I assume there's no one from Seven Oaks County Council is watching this or whatever, but we kind of had to make the roof a bit higher. Yeah, yeah. There's Seven Oaks County Council. We had to we had to keep get the roof a bit higher. Clay tiles mean ⁓ you have to have a 35 degree roof. So by the time the roof went up a little bit, still within the house, three doors down or whatever, it just was an opportunity we. SAM: We ⁓ have an audience of six and we're three of them, it's fine, you should be okay. Mike: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Andy Howes: We couldn't like miss. ⁓ and then there was a long discussion about, do we put in the staircase ⁓ after ⁓ and kid it out in the short term? And we eventually just went the whole hog. We put the stairs up there, put very expensive King span between all the rafters to make a, ⁓ yeah, to make it work. And it's an amazing room. Like we've got a roof coming across the front and then a gable coming out the back. So you've got two rooms at the front, but then this huge, long, long room going back with a pair of French doors right at the end. ⁓ amazing room, like more expensive has impacted the budget, but yeah, an amazing room. SAM: Beautiful. worth it. What are you going to use it for? Andy Howes: Not sure yet, probably lock the kids up there, so... SAM: Yeah. Mike: So one on the way in five weeks and you guys have obviously got little ones already. Andy Howes: Got, yeah, one little one already and one on the way. Yeah, at the end, you know, you look at it now, you'd go, that's no way that's gonna be ready in five weeks. But you know, you've got someone coming in to spray, second fix plumbing, second fix electric. You've got the external drainage being finished off outside. So it all happens really, really quickly. So if you looked at it now, you'd probably not think it's gonna, you probably would say five weeks, yeah, good luck. But actually. these last few bits, surprisingly, second fix and the final stage, I think it's the fifth stage, right? Which is Decoration or what? SAM: Did you find that with your first one as well? Was it a little bit faster towards the end than it was the beginning? Because I think that's probably quite a nice tidbit for people who are maybe going at this their own, who maybe don't have experience in the family ⁓ and ⁓ may lose a little bit of enthusiasm and motivation halfway through when it's dragging and dragging. There's complications and challenges. Actually it can speed up towards the end. Is that your view do you think? Andy Howes: Yeah, definitely. I think there's a lot of stuff at the start, which is out of your control. You know, weather, I think we had brickies on site for four months because they were coming in almost a day a week because we had so much rain, which is fortunate for a timber frame because you can still crack on on the inside. But when you get to the kind of those final stages, you've got your kitchen being a fit, you got your plasterers in, your plaster boarding, you know, first fix joiner if you need to move any walls or anything, it's really within your control. but it just takes a lot of organisation because it's literally one person comes in, one person goes out, one person comes in, one person goes out because you don't really want people working on top of each other. Never ends ⁓ well. ⁓ But if you can get those people kind of one after another, then that final bit can just go pretty quickly. Mike: That come up in a podcast we did the other week as well, and it's managing the sort of first, second fix, about how important it is to manage people on site and then being on top of each other or not being on top of each other and managing that sort of workflow. So that's a top tip. Have you got anything else, Andy, like for people that, obviously you've done two, ⁓ so ⁓ perfect person to ask, I suppose, is someone who's doing their first one, because most people that do a self -book tend to only do one. What sort of two things would you say apart from the things you've already mentioned would be the priority of the top tip, let's ⁓ say, ⁓ to bear in mind when they're looking to get building? Andy Howes: Hmm. I would ⁓ say, ⁓ yeah, all the things, finding land is hard, particularly in the South, Southeast, you know, there's no doubt about that. But if you know what you're looking for, it's out there, always check the planning. Planning will help you make a decision on whether you should purchase a plot or not. And really, if you can find someone that's got a bit of experience that you can kind of consult, that will mean you don't have to do a package deal for a builder to do the whole build. And that will save you. Mike: I'm playing you on the spot. Andy Howes: tens if not hundreds of thousands depending on the size of your build if you can sub it out. If you can sub it out you can maintain the quality. If you put it out to tender for a builder to do all of it, it's going to blow your budget from day one really. Mike: And I'm assuming you're referring to a good PM there that can look after everything for you. Give the firm a shout out Andy that you use for the project management. SAM: Yeah. Andy Howes: No, no, we do it. We do all the project management ourselves. No, no, no. ⁓ so full -time job and then we PM outside of nine till six, seven, whatever it is. No. Mike: ⁓ sorry, I thought you said you've got somebody in as a PM on this project. Sorry, misunderstood. ⁓ wow, so you guys have been, Sue, I thought you had a full -time project manager. I thought you said the last one you project managed and this one you got somebody in. Andy Howes: Okay. The last one we project managed and did a lot of the building work. This one we project managed but have got a lot more subcontracted. Yeah, yeah. But I'd ⁓ say, ⁓ yeah, anyone can project manage, but I think ⁓ project managing can be done. But I think if you can find someone you can lean on a little bit that has that experience, it's invaluable because they'll help you make decisions ⁓ or influence you in the right way that will prevent costly decisions in the future. Mike: Okay. ⁓ wow, good for you. That's been tough then. Yeah, I think that's a common theme to be fair. SAM: So, an all -time job, project managing, a baby on the way and you've still got a full head of hair. If you could give our director some tips on how to manage that, that would be wonderful. Mike: Yeah. Andy Howes: ⁓ Yeah, I ⁓ mean, ⁓ yeah, the last one wasn't as bad. So this one was worse than we were expecting, but it's coming to an end. So we're all happy now. SAM: Will you do another in the future, do you think? Andy Howes: If I did another I'd just I'd take some time out and do this full -time. This is way too difficult ⁓ It ⁓ You ⁓ can't leave like as good as your trades are you cannot leave them on site Unsupervised you may exceptionally get some That you can and then we'll call you if they're not sure But by and large no matter how good the trade is if you're not on site watching them regularly you will end up ⁓ being delayed because they think like a trade rather than like the person who has got the plans and is living in the house at the end. Mike: ⁓ Yeah, that's a good tip. Can I just before we cut off Andy, can I just get some feedback from you on something being a self builder? Would ⁓ would something that would enable you to get all of your materials ⁓ priced at say, at 10 different merchants within a 50 mile radius ⁓ of ⁓ your project have been helpful for you at the beginning? Andy Howes: Hmm. ⁓ Absolutely. ⁓ I'm going to compare sand prices, cement prices, plywood prices, CLS prices, each time trying to get the best price. If there's an easy way to do that, it would save you hours. Yeah. Mike: OK, interesting. yet. Yeah, yeah, okay, awesome. Thanks for coming on Andy, I appreciate it. SAM: I ⁓ do really, really appreciate that. Good valuable lessons to be taken from that. And yeah, good luck with everything. How long until it's all ready? Not the baby, the halves. About five weeks. Yeah. Andy Howes: So, we have five weeks, baby's in two months, eight weeks, so we've got, it's tight, but we should make it, I think. Mike: Congratulations, we'll get something sent over in the post. Nice to meet you. Cheers. SAM: I love it. Yeah, perfect. Yeah, really good to meet you. Nice work. Thanks, Andy. Andy Howes: Cheers. Cheers. Thumbs it up.