Jack: Hello and welcome back to the Self Builders Podcast brought to you by Mayflower Mortgage and Finance, the podcast for anyone planning, funding, or building their own home. Today's episode, I'm joined by Neil, who has very kindly agreed to come on and share the good bits, the stressful bits, and everything in between on his project. So it's a real conversation around a real project with sort of the real decisions that they went through and the real lessons learned. So, you know. Thank you, Neil, for for coming on. It's great to have you on. And Neil: Happy May- Jack: yeah, we'll we'll get into it. So as always, where we like start is right at the beginning. So if you could just give us a a quick introduction to yourself, you know, tell the listeners a little about where you sort of were in life when the idea for the self build came about and you know what your project was, please. Neil: but I suppose I'm a bit of a serial house builder. So I actually developed Property for a Living. So I've got a student property business in Liverpool. And kind of alongside that, that's obviously very commercial, but alongside that over the last 15 years, we've actually built three family houses or family homes. So the one that we are on at the moment that Mayflower helped with the financing on is the third new build. So, yeah, probably a little bit stupid. Jack: A repeat offender. Is the Neil: Yeah, definitely. And look, I think in my day to day, you're always looking at new ideas and new things and things offered to you. with this particular build, a great site was offered to us. I probably wasn't looking and I managed to convince my wife that we should do it again. So yeah, here we are. Yeah, just probably about four months in as we start. Jack: Formal that's in. And the previous houses you built, so have you have you sort of upscaled every time, or has it been area changes? What's the evolution? Neil: Not all in the same area. In fact, the first new build was on the same road as the first development that we ever did. our original build was a Victorian house that we converted from three apartments into a family home that was meant to be a forever home. And then we did the first new build, also a forever home. And now we move to the house we're in at the moment, which was a larger new build. look, think first new build was about 7,000 square foot. the one we're in at the moment, about 12,000 square foot. And then the third build is on the same road again. So we've done four houses on two roads. So no imagination basically. Jack: Just yeah. At least you l at least you know the location, that's always Neil: And look, this current building is a little bit bigger again. So this one's about 14,000 square foot, but actually there's quite a bit extra in the garage in this house. quite a, that extra space is probably in garage. And the big difference is in style of architecture. so we've kind Jack: Okay, so Neil: of refurb, a very traditional new build. And then a very contemporary house that we're in at the moment and we're going back to traditional. So, so yeah, there you go. Jack: Back again. So we're in the third Forever Home. Rich. Neil: Yeah, needs to be the last one. Jack: It needs to be the last one. And then starting point of the project. So you said you were offered the site. So was it you weren't actively looking for it? How did that come about? Neil: No, looking, but I ever look my, I suppose my track record has been to build the houses. So probably a good, my architect said to me, you don't actually like the finished product. You like the process. And I think there's a degree of truth in that. so typically what we've done is we've built our house. We've been delighted with it and everyone, we genuinely have been delighted with the finished product. And they've been generally relatively easy processes. shouldn't say that, but they have been generally easy. But then within the first couple of years, I start to pick fault with, we should have done this, we should have done that, which I think is a fairly standard house builders kind of whatever the word is, curse. So I'm always speaking to the local agents where we are and always kind of say, Hey, what's the current place where you know, is there somebody kind of looking, maybe they'd be interested, you can always show them around. And then you get the flip of that where they kind of then will say, look at this plot, look at this house, what do you think? And that's how we came across this plot. Jack: Perfect. is a bit of a curse of a of a house builder or a self builder, isn't You're buying a house off the shelf second hand, you get in, you find all the faults but go, it is what it is. But if you build it yourself, you sort of go, I know I can change that, I can do that, I can do that better next time. Neil: There's obviously something fundamentally wrong with my personality Jack: Yeah. Neil: because it appears I'm never happy, so there you go. Jack: We're lucky that everyone's got these screw looses 'cause it's how we Neil: Yeah. Jack: how we how we do what we do. and the plot you bought, was it with planning or did you have to apply for planning on this one? Neil: No, so there was no planning. It's quite an interesting plot actually that the guy who we bought off, he passed away. So we were dealing with his family, but it had actually been his forever home. the guy we bought the plot off was quite a famous eighties property developer, house builder, volume house builder. And he had bought a plot of land in the late seventies, built the house in the early eighties. And I think at that time he was in his late 30s and then he stayed there until he passed away just before his 80th birthday. So when the plot was first kind of offered to us, he had passed away and it was going through the probate process. yeah, do you know what, I forgot what the original question was. Jack: Plubbing, planning, how was the planning? Neil: Yes, so there was a house on it that had been there since the early 80s. It was of its time. It was a very particular type of architecture. It was a lovely plot, backs onto countryside and a river to the rear. So we kind of took the, I suppose an educated gamble that we thought the planners would side with us and would be supportive of redevelopment. And luckily they were. Jack: Okay. And was it was it pretty straightforward once the planning went in? Were you making massive changes to it or again footprint wise similar? Neil: Quite a big difference actually. So the house we bought was about 6,000 square foot. So we've over doubled that. But a lot of that is in the basement. So we were building quite a big basement. So there's probably 5,000 square foot in the basement. So above ground, we probably haven't changed it too much. We changed the footprint. We've made the house narrower but deeper. But we kind of thought that the planners would be as supportive as they were. actually we, so we're in Trafford and Trafford have a planning performance agreement process, which sort of my developments are in Liverpool. There's no such process as far as I'm aware. But we basically paid for an expedited planning process, which kind of gave you a pre-app and it gives you more kind of touch and feel with the planners. And they were really good, I've got to say they were, They didn't like our first design. was too, we originally wanted to build kind of a Georgian-y type property and they said it was too formal and they wanted more Victorian style architecture and we were quite happy to do that. Jack: Small changes, like small changes, big changes, but in the grand scheme of things, Neil: Yeah. Jack: not too bad. And as this is the third Forever Home, was there anything you sort of learnt from previous applications and processes that you applied to this one, or was it just completely different? Neil: I think every time I move into the house, feel as though I've learned from the previous one and then I find all the faults with the current design. hopefully, yes, we've now got the perfect floor plan and the right style of architecture and it's the right plot and the right location. maybe come back to me in five years or eight years. Jack: Well that'll be only a fourth from a home then. That'll be trying trying to iron out all the the rest of them. I qu a quick touch on the sort of the money side of things and again being sort of a little bit more experienced, you sort of understood the funding process as Neil: Yeah. Jack: you as you sort of go through. Was there any surprises with that with this one or Neil: Honestly, the surprise was that Mayflower, and this is genuinely true, Mayflower made the process a lot easier than I expected. I carry a lot of debt across my properties and my developments and the house that we are currently in. So, you know, we're in, I suppose, the fortunate position where we can stay in the current house and build the new house. And that's as a result of securing this finance. But, know, I... I've got a lot of commercial debt, but I've also got quite a high mortgage on the current place. So I probably thought I was pushing the envelope a little bit when I came to Mayflower. But Mark, who I dealt with pretty early on, was, well, actually your structure and the way you set up, I think we can work with that. So the surprise was that he made it work as quickly as he did. So that was quite nice. Jack: And then budgeting for this project. So again, a little bit fortunate in terms of experience, but this one. custons that you sort of put together aga use any sort of experience from the other ones. Have you sort of cut anything out of this one that you didn't previously or sort of given extra budget to any areas? Neil: No, I tend to generally in life kind of push the envelope. So we've got a QS cost estimate on this current project as we always would do. I probably expect that we will spend more than that cost estimate. So I probably tend to work the other way where the QS will come back and say, look, this is if you really manage it really tightly, this is what you can build the house for. But I probably expect that will go over. So and look, I get those people out there that. can't do that. And, you know, people will be people building houses where you've got to manage every penny. I'm not saying that we're not in that position because you do read there's a, you know, there's a there's a ceiling to what the finished product is going to be worth. If it's not a forever home, you've got to try and sell and that's a position we're in now with the current home. So so the price and the cost is always quite an interesting subject for me, I think. Jack: So yeah, a little bit more fluid than than most yeah. Neil: I also think when you're doing a bespoke home, it can't just be about the, if you can make it work, it can't just be about the bottom line, kind of what does it cost? Because I think you can build under a really tight budget and deliver, and then you live in the property and then you then spend the next five years doing all the stuff that you kind of cut out anyway, you know? So, I think if you can make it work financially, I like to Jack: Making amendments. Yeah. Neil: see it through. Jack: Brilliant. And the build itself, how how have you approached this one? Have you got like a main contractor, yourself managing it? What's what's the process? Neil: self-managed using my team, which is the first time we've done it. The previous two new builds have been with a really good local contractor and they deliver two fantastic projects. But I kind of felt with this one that my team, the team that kind of managed my projects on the commercial side, you know, we've done bigger and bigger and more in depth or more detailed projects as we've kind of gone through the last kind of 10, 15 years. So there's a bit of I thought I spoke to my project manager and he said he could build it. And I kind of thought, well, why not? Why not try and do it and why not try and cut out the contractors margin? Let's see whether that's so far it's been a good decision, but come back to me in 18 months time. So. Jack: That's the way I get it on. So you're letting them loose on your own your own home brave. Neil: Yeah, and look, I'm still on really good terms with the guy that built my last two houses and he's actually involved to a degree with this, more from an advisory point of view. And I have said to him, look, I don't expect that this build will be anywhere near as smooth as what the last two were because he's been doing these types of houses for 10, 15, 20 years, know. So I expect there to be ups and downs. Jack: Lease it at the end of the phone. Get a bit of advice and dip in dip. Neil: I thought there's a difference to doing, you know, student bedrooms to a certain size and a certain spec and lots of them against, you know, a pretty bespoke high-end family home, you know. Jack: And what materials are you are you using? Is it brick and block traditional build? Neil: So this is ICF actually. we've used that. So two houses ago, the house was full ICF. The current house we live in was half ICF. And then this current build, we've gone back to a full ICF system. So it goes up very quickly. And then it feels as though takes forever to actually put the brick skin on it and put the window and get watertight, know. But it's a great system. Jack: Yeah. What what what drew you towards the ICF rather than traditional? Was it speed of Neil: I guess having used it before in the previous builds and seen it in action, the thermal qualities are really good. Obviously building regs have changed quite a lot over the last 10 or 12 years. So the ICF system is really family efficient. The speed of build in terms of getting your... So the ICF package, we've let that as a subcontract. And that's basically basement slab, all the walls, all the floors, concrete stairs, all the steel package. And then they give us that shell back and then we take it from there. So we started it demolition, all the ground works, drainage, getting everything ready. They're now on site delivering their package of works. Jack: And now now you're the site, you've got four months in. Have you had any surprises so far or so far so Neil: Well, Jack: good? Neil: we have been very fortunate in that I know it's not been great for lots of people, weather, farmers and such like, but the weather's been amazing. So doing ground works when it rained for forever in the Northwest is very unusual. So although it is absolutely chucking it down today, so back to normal. Jack: No, I was just thinking that outside it was dark this morning. Perfect. And then as you go through, do you have any sort of phases of the project that you're sort of looking forward to the most or you expect Neil: The end. Jack: the end when you can start looking for the next one? But Neil: Look, I sometimes wonder why I put myself through these. I obviously do enjoy them and to some degree my wife must enjoy it as well because she keeps saying, yeah, let's do it again. But I do feel already four months in, you're constantly looking at the pennies. And that's where I'm kind of saying, I want to try and not all be about the funds. But it's kind of inherent that you, you know, you're there looking, well, where are we up to? And, and sometimes probably with my personality type that maybe gets in the way of enjoying some of the, you know, the fit out part or the, because by the time you get to fit out, I'm kind of then going, no, we can't spend that on that. And then the interior designer gets upset. so, but yeah. Jack: The the ethos gets a bit shaky when it's further on you go through the the project. Neil: So it's kind of a blow away to say the end, Jack: Yeah. Neil: yeah, know, seeing the finished product and knowing that you can afford to deliver the finished product is quite a big moment. Jack: Again, from the other projects pushing it into this one. So is there any mistakes that you've made in previous properties or not mistakes, but any sort of problems, delays that you've had that you've taken the experience and applied it to this project? Neil: Yeah, so I think when we did our first new build, so it's quite interesting that, know, the very first project, family project we did, which was refurb, you're working with pretty much a defined set of spaces. And yeah, we extended and we did a basement on that and what have you, but you kind of, from the start, you kind of know what spaces you're really working with. New build, you know, when you've got a set of plans on a piece of paper and you can see a green field or a house that needs to be demolished. You can look at, and you do, you you look at the plans in depth and you kind of think this is it. And then you start building. I think when we building the first house, the kitchen and kind of dining and entertaining space really quite early on, I think we both thought, we've messed this up. It's not right. was basically that it was too long and narrow. And that's kind of then there's definitely a follow on from that into the house we're in now and into the house that we're building. You know, you may be, I think when we did the first one, we probably trusted the architect too much. So that's not having a go at architects, but I think. Jack: Yeah, for for your for your family it wasn't quite right. Neil: Yeah. Jack: And how you live your life in your home, therefore, that Neil: Yeah. Yeah. Jack: little bit of experience taken forward is worth it. Neil: If you look at the house we're in now, we actually put a swimming pool in this house because I didn't grow up in anything like a house with a swimming pool or so you kind of think, yeah, I'd want a swimming pool. And we are not doing a swimming pool in the new house. There's a reason for that. but that's some people will put a pool in house and use it every day. We don't. So, obviously there's learnings along the way. Jack: Yeah, it keeps keeps evolving as you as you go along. And are there any sort of tips that you can give self builders? So from any point from sort of planning all the way through to completion, are there any sort of real tips that you can sort of give someone who hasn't got the experience that you have? Neil: So I think even from the point of view of you, where I spend a lot of my time being involved in commercial developments, doing a new build project is I think what surprised me the first time we did it and still does even now, it's the volume of choices that you've got to make and the time that that takes and the... Sometimes the arguments that come off the back of making those choices, depending. You need to be on the same page. And obviously human nature is to not always be on the same page. But there are just so many decisions where I think on the first one, I can remember the architect saying, here's a book with 10,000 hinges and handles. And which ones do you want? can you give me a top five? What's your top five? I'll just choose one of them. But I think that really plays out across. whole job and then I think if you are on budget you are then into well you know if you're buying you know 2,000 sheets of plasterboard it's where do you get your plasterboard from and sometimes saving you know a pound per piece of plasterboard is quite a big financial kind of you know there's an outcome there so I think you have to have the time to be involved in making all of those decisions. Unless you're giving it to a contractor and saying you build the house for me, you know, so if it's True self build It takes up a lot of time That's a practice even when I'm for commercially developing. So Jack: Yeah, realise the time and realise the time and set time aside and your mind more than sort of physical time to to go through it is a great tip. Neil: Yeah, and be prepared for doing a process to wake up pretty much every night thinking, is that the right place for the television? Or I don't know, you know, so. Jack: Yeah, it's it's hard to switch off when you've got a thousand decisions to make make a day. Neil: Yeah, yeah. think also as well being surrounded by, you know, we've got structure engineer and obviously mechanical engineer and architects and you've got you surrounded by lots of professional people who are all very good at what they do, but they're not going to be the people that end up living in the property. So sometimes I think you can be. swayed into making decisions because it kind of suits the engineer or the architect to have a decision in a certain way. I think that sometimes you've got to have a strong enough set of beliefs to say, no, no, this is what I really want. So, yeah. Jack: Take a step back. Look I see how it fits your Neil: Yeah. Jack: your personal life as well, as not just the technically it might fit better for the structural engineer or the architect, but in real Neil: Yeah. Jack: life. Neil: Well, when we build the current house, we've got, we want to polish concrete floors in the kitchen and hallways. and the builder, as much as I have a great relationship with him, so my previous builder, he is like, no, you know, it'll be too difficult. It won't work. You're not doing it. And there was a conversation where obviously two houses in, you feel a bit more confident to say, no, this is what I want. So it's your job to make it work. And yes, there's a cost to that, but this is your job. And I wouldn't have done that maybe on the first build, you know, so and the concrete floors went in and they look great. Jack: win. Neil: Yeah. Jack: I take them. and throughout the projects, is there is there any stage you get to your projects where you you I think you strike me as someone who's got the bug right from day one, to be honest, but it's where where you think this is it, this is working, this is why we love it. Neil: yeah, there probably are several stages. I think obviously when, I think if you're doing, you know, like what we've done in this one, demolition, you spend so long trying to buy the house that you're going to demolish and then dealing with planning and going through all of that. The day that demolition actually starts is quite a good day. And obviously every, everybody likes to see a house getting, or maybe not everybody, but I do love getting a house getting demolished. It's great. And then I think beyond that, then it's kind of nice, particularly doing basements, whatever you want, kind of your earthworks are done, foundations are done. That's kind of quite nice. And then I think once you're weathertight, I think when you're weathertight, it then starts to feel like, this is maybe a house, not a project. And I think most people then, so like, if I look at my wife, Claire, she's not really that interested at the moment, but once it's weathertight and you can walk through a front door and see the spaces and then it all starts to get put together as a house. That's when it gets, I guess, interesting for most normal people. So, not warm. Jack: And if someone's someone sort of listening mid build and feeling a bit stressed at the moment, what what bit of advice could you give them? Neil: I think generally in life I have a thing of I put myself when things aren't going or things feel like it's not going well, I put myself six months in the future. Because I think that when particularly when you're building the house, six months is a really long time. And probably if you are really stressing about something not being right or something's gone in the wrong place or the engineer is not happy or what have you, it's really stressful. But in six months time it will be dealt with. There's always a solution. And sometimes that solution costs you money or time or both. But I think, I mean, look at all the TV shows, everybody kind of gets there in the end, don't they? So you see very few where the project just stops and it fails and it's just left. Everybody seems to find a way. So I think the building, there's always a way. Jack: Even in the dramatised world of grand designs, it it's it gets there. And we Neil: See you then. Jack: don't we don't see it. There's a there's always a way to to get there. Neil: Yeah, there is. I get it with, you know, if you are on a really tight budget and things go wrong, it's not great. And people do run out of money and finance is difficult. I guess for the vast majority of house builders that probably don't find themselves in that overly dramatised TV world, it happens, but probably not as much as TV likes to make out. Jack: Well they've gotta they've gotta f pad it out for an hour, haven't they? Make everyone tune in next time. Neil: I mean, the windows do always turn up on time, just not on television, so... Jack: So it's the case. and just last sort of a little bit on this project then. So where where are you now on this project? What stage are you at now and what's your timeline to sort of get everything Neil: Yeah, so they have, over the last couple of weeks, they've poured the basement slab and they are now in the process of putting the AMVIC walls up. And AMVIC for, so it's ICF, it's an, AMVIC is kind of a version of ICF for people that haven't used that before or know what it is. It's basically that big Lego blocks. It's quite cool to see it kind of, you know, the polystyrene blocks that get delivered to site and you can pick up a whole wall. the right, but they kind of get put together on site and then concrete is poured in the middle and that gives it a structural kind of strength and then the polystyrene provides the insulation and so they are building the basement walls at the moment and if we were having this conversation in two weeks time the lid will be going on the basement so it really is quick you know. So I think for me in two weeks time I'm kind of looking forward to being able to go in actually go into part of what the finished house will one day be, you know. Jack: And then how long have you got left on the project do you reckon? Say eighteen months, you said. Neil: So when we started like everybody does, we wanted to be finished by Christmas next year, the Jack: Yep. Neil: 27th. So about 18 months, I think being realistic is probably going to be spring 28th. So if we can do it quicker, we will, but we probably will. Jack: least realistic, that's always that's always good. So always Christmas. Neil: Everybody always wants to be in for Christmas, don't they? Definitely on the television. Jack: I don't I don't get it, yeah, always always Christmas. I think I like to be in for summer, start of summer and then you can en enjoy the in the good weather. Neil: And look, guess, having done it a few times, I'm relatively relaxed on that. So our current house is on the market for sale. If we sell, we will go into rented. That's, you know, that's we've done that before. It's not great, but then it changes the dynamic in other places from terms of flexibility and finances and what have you. But yeah, the sooner it's done, the better. Jack: Yeah. Not got the pressure of a caravan on site. Which is nice. Neil: No, no, haven't. sorry. I would my wife wouldn't so then Jack: That might push it just a bit too far with well the fourth one, maybe try it, maybe say, Look, if we're gonna do this Neil: Yeah, yeah, so. Jack: now, I'm gonna Neil: Well, I think I just turned 50, the kids are what, two and four years off university. This kind of does need to be. The last house, so yeah. Jack: Never say never. right, we'll finish a quick quick fire round if that's all right. And again, I know you're only a few months through this project, but just in sort of general terms, what's the best money you think you can spend on a project? Or where's the best Neil: That's a really good. Jack: Allocation. Neil: well I guess. Do you know what, probably go back to the architect as much as I was a bit negative about the architects before. I think playing for a really good architect and spending time with your architect to, before you start, try and get as many decisions correct at the start rather than changing things as you go through the project. So, the planning at the start, basically planning with an architect. Jack: Yeah. And what's the the worst money to spend? Not necessarily the worst money you spent on the project, but what's the most painful thing to purchase or or spend money on? Neil: Do you know I guess that's like so I've signed off on a scaffold quote for 50,000 pounds and you get nothing from that scaffold It's temporary. It's I don't know. It's there to protect people to build the house and but it's Jack: Yeah. Me's must. Neil: It's 50,000 pound. That's just you know Jack: Yeah. You you don't get anything visceral for it, do you? There's no there's no end product there, it's just Neil: No, yeah. So I think anything like that sometimes when you're spending is hard to kind of reconcile because you go, well, why am I, you know, if you're spending, I don't know, if you put a beautiful kind of floor in or a beautiful set of windows or well, then you're going to get the benefit of that. But I anything that's temporary is painful. Jack: Painful. is there anything that you'd never skip when building a building the home? Any part of the process or any Neil: Wish I'd seen these questions before. And when I guess, obviously I've got a number of different hats here, haven't I? So I'd Jack: Yeah. Neil: never skip as much as I've just said about scaffold. Never skip the health and safety part of it and making sure that everybody's kind of, that's a more boring kind of business owner type of thing. I don't know. think from Bill, every house is so different to me that it's hard to say, well, I definitely wouldn't do that or would do that. That's a really rubbish answer, but. Jack: So we'll take the health and safety. No one's ever said that one before, so we'll keep we'll keep that one in. best advice for someone just before they start. I they've I think we've already touched on it a little bit, but what's the best advice for someone who's not started yet, who's just dreaming of of building it? Neil: I think it is making sure you've got a good team around you and that you have really, I guess most people do this once. So a lot, I've done this before. think everybody could be guilty. If you get planning, you want to get on site. I think that you can save a lot of time, energy and money by taking a bit of extra time to make sure that you've got the right builder, the right. team around you that will help you get through the process, a good QS, a good set of engineers and what have you. Jack: Brilliant. right, well Neil, that's a great place to leave it. So but thank you so much for coming on, being open and sharing about your project and if it's all right with you, we'll probably catch up with you once you've once you've finished this one and have a have a quick recap and and see how it's gone to finish. Neil: Yeah, yeah, send you send you some pictures show you what we've done so but great. Jack: Yeah, sounds perfect. Amazing. Well, cheers for coming on and hopefully this will help other people start or put them at ease as they're going through the their projects themselves. So thanks for coming on. Neil: Well, yeah, I'll give good luck to anybody that's doing it. So it's a great thing to do. So